Name	Known for
Henry Louis Adams Jr. Arnold Harris Arnold Harris See fewer	David Makes Man (2019)
Josh Casaubon Narrator Narrator See fewer	Rules Don't Apply (2016)
Chris Caulpetzer Police Officer Police Officer See fewer	Vanished (2024)
Debra Crittenden Mary Boton (Aimee's mother) Mary Boton (Aimee's mother) See fewer	Uncanny X-Men (2012)
Ann Ervin Self - Former Local New Reporter Self - Former Local New Reporter See fewer	Pole with Paula (2018)
Zeph Jewell Renwick Pope (as Zeph Jewel) Renwick Pope (as Zeph Jewel) See fewer	Endicott Falls
Joe Kenda Self - Host / Homicide Investigator (as Lt. Joseph P. Kenda) Self - Host / Homicide Investigator (as Lt. Joseph P. Kenda) See fewer	Handsome: A Netflix Mystery Movie (2017)
Shannon Lundy Self - Aimee's Cousin Self - Aimee's Cousin See fewer	Homicide Hunter (2011)
Tyner Rushing Karen Vandenhoff Karen Vandenhoff See fewer	Under the Banner of Heaven (2022)
Rima Saleeby Aimee Vandenhoff Aimee Vandenhoff See fewer	The Strangers (2008)
Harrison Stone Chris Vandenhoff Chris Vandenhoff See fewer	The Liberator (2020)
Nicole Swanson Virginia Virginia See fewer	The Great Kentucky Goblin Spree (2022)
Karen Vandenhoff Self - Aimee's Sister Self - Aimee's Sister See fewer	Homicide Hunter (2011)
Benjamin J. Welch Marvin Evans Marvin Evans See fewer	Deathwell (2020)