This document is an excerpt from the EUR-Lex website
Document 52017XC0801(02)
Publication of an amendment application pursuant to Article 50(2)(a) of Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council on quality schemes for agricultural products and foodstuffs
Publication of an amendment application pursuant to Article 50(2)(a) of Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council on quality schemes for agricultural products and foodstuffs
Publication of an amendment application pursuant to Article 50(2)(a) of Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council on quality schemes for agricultural products and foodstuffs
OJ C 250, 1.8.2017, p. 24–32
(BG, ES, CS, DA, DE, ET, EL, EN, FR, HR, IT, LV, LT, HU, MT, NL, PL, PT, RO, SK, SL, FI, SV)
1.8.2017 |
EN |
Official Journal of the European Union |
C 250/24 |
Publication of an amendment application pursuant to Article 50(2)(a) of Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council on quality schemes for agricultural products and foodstuffs
(2017/C 250/07)
This publication confers the right to oppose the amendment application pursuant to Article 51 of Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council (1).
APPLICATION FOR APPROVAL OF NON-MINOR AMENDMENTS TO THE PRODUCT SPECIFICATION FOR A PROTECTED DESIGNATION OF ORIGIN OR PROTECTED GEOGRAPHICAL INDICATION
Application for approval of amendments in accordance with the first subparagraph of Article 53(2) of Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012
‘TERNASCO DE ARAGÓN’
EU No: PGI-ES-02149 – 29.6.2016
PDO ( ) PGI ( X )
1. Applicant group and legitimate interest
Name: |
Regulatory Council for the Protected Geographical Indication ‘Ternasco de Aragón’ |
||||
Address: |
|
||||
Tel. |
+34 976470813 |
||||
Email: |
info@ternascodearagon.es |
The applicant group represents the collective interests of the producers of ‘Ternasco de Aragón’ and is the legitimate interested party in the amendment application for the Specification of the Protected Geographical Indication ‘Ternasco de Aragón’ and is also responsible for its protection.
2. Member State or Third Country
Spain
3. Heading of the specification affected by the amendment
— |
☐ |
Name of product |
— |
☒ |
Description of product |
— |
☐ |
Geographical area |
— |
☒ |
Proof of origin |
— |
☐ |
Method of production |
— |
☒ |
Link |
— |
☐ |
Labelling |
— |
☐ |
Others [specify] |
4. Type of amendment(s)
— |
☒ |
Amendment of the Specification of a registered PDO or PGI which, in accordance with third subparagraph of Article 53(2) of Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012, is non-minor. |
— |
☐ |
Amendment of the Specification of a registered PDO or PGI whose single document (or equivalent) has not been published and which, in accordance with the third subparagraph of Article 53(2) of Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012, is non-minor. |
5. Amendments
5.1. Product description
(Paragraph B, point 2):
Current wording of the Specification:
‘2. |
“Ternasco de Aragón” must meet the following requirements:
|
The Specification should read:
‘2. |
“Ternasco de Aragón” must meet the following requirements:
|
Reasons for the changes stated in the product description:
— |
Age of slaughter It is proposed that the limitation on the age of slaughter be removed because individual checks of carcasses guarantee compliance with the quality parameters laid down in the Specification. The quality of the carcass, meat and fat are affected by a large number of factors, although on account of the young low age of these animals and the traditional system of production, this number is reducing (Sañudo et al., 2013). The criteria used to define the quality of a carcass are principally the fat cover, weight, colour and conformation. These are the parameters used to qualify the carcass of the ‘Ternasco de Aragón’. There are various advantages to using these criteria to qualify the carcasses, such as greater ease of selection, which facilitates the homogeneousness of the guaranteed product. A study carried out by the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine of the University of Zaragoza in 2014 concluded that ‘when the carcass weight is between 8,0 and 12,5 kg, the quality of the meat within the parameters set out in the Specification is independent of the age of the animal’. Therefore the study indicates that the results show that there are no significant differences in the juiciness or luminosity (L*) or hardness of the meat, between a batch of animals slaughtered at 70 days old and another slaughtered at 100 days old. In addition to this study, technicians from the control body monitored the total carcasses used in the study by checking, in each of the batches, that the carcasses sampled which were more than 8 kg for a cold carcass met the conformation and fat cover requirements contained in the Specification. Lastly, they checked that all the carcass and meat quality requirements were complied with in order to be carcasses covered by the Protected Geographical Indication. With the system of production habitually used for the PGI, carcasses are obtained of between 8 and 12,5 kg with excellent conformation, a pale rose meat colour, and an optimum level of infiltration and fat cover. The weight of the carcass is a very important parameter which, together with the young age of these animals, is linked to fat cover, colour and conformation, directly affecting the carcass quality. In paragraph F) Link to the surrounding area, heading 3. ‘Production systems’, provides the following literal description ‘… but the most significant thing about these breeds is their precociousness, a factor which will particularly influence the quality of the ternasco as fat tissues build up earlier … this proven fact of greater precociousness is a genuine differential factor as regards other breeds.’ In addition to the information stated, we should note that the process of certification of the carcasses in order to obtain the PGI designation involves their being reviewed one by one. If the carcass is outside the weight range laid down in the Specification, it is automatically rejected. For carcasses with weights between 8 and 12,5 kg, their general appearance is checked and, if this is satisfactory, the fat cover is assessed. The precociousness of the animals of the breeds concerned means that the excess fat cover determines the age and weight of slaughter, especially in the case of females. For males, weight is more important than fat cover. Animals that have not developed properly may be within the weight range but outside the age range, although this situation would be obvious from the appearance of the carcass. These animals are generally outside the certification requirements because of other factors: insufficient fat, poor conformation, meat colour (excessively red or yellowish), meat texture (because the appropriate pH was not achieved during maturing), excessive testicle size in males or abdominal wall thickness at the midline in females. In order to check the degree to which quality control of the carcass guarantees the characteristics of the product, the PGI control and certification body's technical team performed an analysis using data from 2015. This involved the use of comprehensive individual traceability data (from origin to classification) for 4 937 lambs slaughtered in Mercazaragoza, taken from 386 farms (45,89 % of the total number of livestock farms covered by the PGI). From those 386 farms, 33 were selected and checks on births were requested. The birth dates were cross-checked against classification and weight data. Comprehensive data were analysed for carcasses corresponding to 897 lambs, with the following results: 893 carcasses (99,55 %) were within the ranges for the age of the animal at the time of slaughter and the weight of the carcass; 2 carcasses (0,22 %) had appropriate weights and characteristics, but the animals were slaughtered at an age of more than 100 days; and the 2 remaining carcasses (0,22 %) exceeded 12,5 kg, with the animals also being slaughtered at an age of more than 100 days. We can therefore conclude that lambs whose carcasses are within the weight ranges laid down in the Specification comply with all the quality parameters relating to the PGI, irrespective of the age at slaughter. This amendment does not require a change to the production system, which addresses the precociousness of the fat cover, or affect the way in which the product is made (slaughter, hanging and conservation). It does not, therefore, affect the production of a carcass that meets the requirements laid down in the description of the link: ‘… ideal tissue composition, and the osseus tissue is not exaggerated and there is an appropriate development of the subcutaneous and intermuscular fat covering, including intramuscular fat’. Controlling the weight of the carcass, in addition to the conformation, colour and state of fat cover, can guarantee the quality of the PGI carcasses for ‘Ternasco de Aragón’ and, therefore, we can replace sample-based checks on the age at slaughter by individual classification of the carcasses on the basis of weight and other characteristics. |
— |
Suckling period It is proposed that the minimum age at weaning be reduced to 40 days, given that we have observed no significant differences, in relation to the meat quality parameters set down in the Specification, between animals weaned at 40 or 70 days, and both types of animals comply with the quality characteristics laid down in that Specification. In the system of usual production in Aragon using native breeds, the lambs continue to have direct contact with their mothers until the start of the following sheep reproductive cycle. Lambs on livestock farms will continue to feed on their mothers' milk which is exclusively used for feeding their offspring, and supplementing their diet with the consumption of high-quality feed during the day. Lambs are usually handled in weaning batches in which the ages of the animals differ by a few days, which facilitates management of the animals and of the farm in general, and guarantees appropriate control of this parameter. The product obtained and covered by the PGI will continue to also be characterised by the exclusive consumption of the milk produced by mothers until the time of weaning. Similarly, a recent study was carried out by the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine of the University of Zaragoza on how the suckling period affects the characteristics required by the Specification for the PGI as regards colour, juiciness and texture of the meat. All of the carcasses in this study were monitored by technicians from the control body, who checked on site that in addition to the parameters which were the subject of the study, those which were above 8 kg of cold carcass had met the requirements set out in the Specification for the PGI in terms of their shape and degree of fat cover both internally and externally. The study reported that: ‘pH levels did not differ between the treatments (P = 0,206) with values of 5,70 ± 0,11 for animals which had not been weaned and 5,75 ± 0,14 for those which had been weaned, normal values which did not influence the colour, juiciness or texture, aspects which would be very affected by abnormally high pH values.’ Therefore the study confirmed the following: ‘There were no differences between weaning at 40 days (before the current limit included in the Specification) or not weaning in terms of the juiciness of the meat, its luminosity (L*), its red colour (a*) or its hardness.’ |
5.2. Product description
(Paragraph B, point 1):
Current wording of the Specification:
‘1. |
Lamb used in the production of “Ternasco de Aragón” comes from the following breeds:
|
The Specification should read:
‘1. |
Lamb used in the production of “Ternasco de Aragón” comes from the following breeds:
|
Reasons for the changes indicated:
The Specification currently allows three different breeds: ‘Rasa Aragonesa’, ‘Roya Bilbilitana’ and ‘Ojinegra de Teruel’. An application is being made for the inclusion of the breeds ‘Ansotana’ and ‘Maellana’, as their official recognition as independent breeds was recognised in the Official Catalogue of Livestock Breeds in Spain by means of Royal Decree No 1682/1997 after the creation of the first Specification for ‘Ternasco de Aragón’, which was recognised in the Autonomous Community as a Specific Denomination on 10 July 1989, nationally in October 1992 and in Europe on 21 June 1996.
The two breeds, which currently have a very reduced population of approximately 10 000 reproducing females (ewes). Various livestock, perfectly adapted to the natural environment and meeting the quality parameters for the carcass, were included in the PGI before the publication of Royal Decree No 1682/1997, as they were then considered ecotypes of the breed ‘Rasa Aragonesa’. As a consequence of the publication of the Royal Decree, the livestock breeders indicated were removed. The production system is the same as for the breeds included in the Specification. They are now interested in being included in the PGI.
An application is therefore being made to adapt the Specification to the regulations in force in order to include once again the producers of sheep of the breeds ‘Ansotana’ and ‘Maellana’, which are traditionally considered to be ecotypes of the breed ‘Rasa Aragonesa’.
5.3. Evidence that the product originates from the geographical area (Paragraph D, point 2):
Current wording of the Specification:
‘2. |
Checks and certification: These are fundamental requirements which guarantee the origin of the product:
|
The Specification should read:
‘2. |
Checks and certification: These are fundamental requirements which guarantee the origin of the product:
|
Reasons for the changes indicated:
The same reasons as stated in point 5.2.
5.4. Link to the surrounding area (Paragraph F, point 3. Production and processing systems, a) Production)
Current wording of the Specification:
‘a) |
Production Aragon's agricultural and climatic characteristics have contributed to the development of an important ovine subsector as it is the only species capable of adapting to the sparse and seasonal growth of grass. This type of lamb has a series of particular requirements in terms of weight and age at slaughter which clearly differentiate it from other types of lambs which are commonly slaughtered in Spain. The three types of breeds involved in this indication are listed below:
This proven fact of greater precociousness is a genuine differential factor with regard to other breeds. Therefore the quality of the “Ternasco de Aragón” on the basis of the genotypes quoted is different from and superior to that of other breeds. In terms of food, the sheep feeds on both stubble field and the natural pastures of Aragón where there are large quantities of species of aromatic plants (rosemary, thyme, etc.). The lambs will stay in the sheepfold in stables, receiving their mother's milk during the night and consuming high quality concentrated feed during the day. The consumption of concentrated feed, if desired, combined with mother's milk, add to the finish of the ternasco carcass (tissue composition, distribution, colour, fat consistency, tenderness, colour and “bouquet” of meat) at the weights and ages indicated (10-12 kg and 80-100 days) depending on the Aragonese breeds above.’ |
The Specification should read:
‘a) |
Production Aragon's agricultural and climatic characteristics have contributed to the development of an important ovine subsector as it is the only species capable of adapting to the sparse and seasonal growth of grass. This type of lamb has a series of particular characteristics which clearly differentiate it from other types of lambs which are commonly slaughtered in Spain. The five breeds involved in this indication are listed below:
This proven fact of greater precociousness is a genuine differential factor with regard to other breeds. Therefore the quality of the “Ternasco de Aragón” on the basis of the genotypes quoted is different from and superior to that of other breeds. In terms of food, the sheep feeds on both stubble field and the natural pastures of Aragón where there are large quantities of species of aromatic plants (rosemary, thyme, etc.). The lambs will stay in the sheepfold in stables, receiving their mother's milk during the night and consuming high quality concentrated feed during the day. The consumption of concentrated feed, if desired, combined with mother's milk, add to the finish of the ternasco carcass (tissue composition, distribution, colour, fat consistency, tenderness, colour and “bouquet” of meat) at the weights indicated depending on the Aragonese breeds above.’ |
Reasons for the changes indicated:
Two subparagraphs have been added providing descriptions of the two breeds to be incorporated, as substantiated already in point 5.2.
As the limitation on the age at slaughter is being removed, as substantiated in point 5.1, we have also removed the references to the ages of the animals, in both the second and final subparagraphs, although the remainder of the text has not been altered.
SINGLE DOCUMENT
‘TERNASCO DE ARAGÓN’
EU No: PGI-ES-02149 – 29.6.2016
PDO ( ) PGI ( X )
1. Name
‘Ternasco de Aragón’
2. Member State or Third Country
Spain
3. Description of the agricultural product or foodstuff
3.1. Type of product
Class 1.1. Fresh meat (and offal)
3.2. Description of the product to which the name in 1 applies
Sheep meat from the following breeds: ‘Rasa Aragonesa’, ‘Ojinegra de Teruel’, ‘Roya Bilbilitana’, ‘Maellana’ y ‘Ansotana’. ‘Ternasco de Aragón’ must come from lambs with no distinction being made in terms of gender. Lambs must be fed in stables on their mothers' milk supplemented, if desired, with white straw and concentrates permitted under current legislation. The minimum weaning period shall be 40 days.
The weight of the carcass varies between 8,0 and 12,5 kg. Rectilinear profile with subconvex tendency and rounded contours. External fat white in colour with a firm consistency. Body cavity fat white in colour covering at least half of the kidney and never its totality. Tender, juicy, soft meat with the start of fat infiltration at an intramuscular level and a pale pink colour.
3.3. Feed (for products of animal origin only) and raw materials (for processed products only)
—
3.4. Specific steps in production that must take place in the defined geographical area
The ternasco has organoleptic characteristics linking it to its natural environment and production system, which means that the phases of production and growth of the lambs are carried out in the geographical area.
3.5. Specific rules concerning slicing, grafting, packaging, etc.
—
3.6. Specific rules concerning labelling
Labels must bear the PGI logo, including the reference ‘Ternasco de Aragón’.
The product intended for consumption must bear numbered labels and stamps which will be placed by the registered industry and without a new usage of the latter being allowed.
4. Brief description of the geographical area
The production area of the sheep is located in the Autonomous Community of Aragon.
5. Link with the geographical area
5.1. Specific nature of the geographical area
Aragon has a continental Mediterranean climate: temperate-dry and windy in the central depression and colder and humid when ascending the Pyrenees and the Iberian Mountain Range. The average annual temperatures in the centre of the depression vary between 14 and 15 °C. In the foothills of the mountains (above 500 metres) the temperature drops by a couple of degrees.
Aragon's agricultural and climatic characteristics have contributed to the development of an important ovine subsector as it is the only species capable of adapting to the sparse and seasonal growth of grass.
5.2. Specificity of the product
‘Rasa Aragonesa’ has ternascos which are perfectly finished in terms of the tissue composition of the carcass and has up to 25 % fat on average for the males and females for a carcass weight of 10,74 kg. This precociousness also affects another genuine Aragonese genotype, the ‘Roya Bilbilitana’ group which also for the ternasco type has a similar precociousness with 26,6 % fat in both sexes with carcasses of 10,6 kg. In the ‘Ojinegra de Teruel’ breed percentages of fatty deposits similar to those of the above two breeds were found in the carcass. The same is true for the ‘Maellana’ and ‘Ansotana’ breeds, which were former ecotypes of the ‘Rasa Aragonesa’ breed.
This proven fact of greater precociousness is a genuine differential factor with regard to the other breeds. Therefore the quality of the ‘Ternasco de Aragón’ on the basis of the genotypes quoted is different from and superior to that of other breeds.
The feeding of the lamb combined with the mother's milk, enables the finish of the ternasco carcass (tissue composition, distribution, colour, fat consistency, tenderness and ‘bouquet’ of meat) at the weights indicated depending on the Aragonese breeds above.
5.3. Causal link between the geographical area and the quality or characteristics of the product (for PDO) or a specific quality, the reputation or other characteristic of the product (for PGI).
Since time immemorial in Aragon, the ternasco designation has been known and widely used in reference to the most commonly slaughtered lamb typical of the region. Similarly, outside the area, ternasco was recognised for its origin and high quality, a direct consequence of the ovine breeds that produced it, the grass consumed and the weight at slaughter of the lambs raised.
This expression of quality has led to the term ternasco and by extension ternasca as meaning young and tender in Aragonese cultural parlance, and although this may seem out of place it is quite simply a further confirmation of the undeniable quality of the final product.
The continental climatic conditions of this sparsely vegetated area (low rainfall, strong winds and major temperature variations) promote the development of five native breeds whose principle characteristic is their precocious growth. Since they attain an optimum degree of fat cover at a precocious age, they produce an exquisite meat which is appreciated for its quality.
Reference to publication of the Specification
(Article 6(1), second paragraph, of the present Regulation)
www.aragon.es/calidadagroalimentaria/pliegos
(1) OJ L 343, 14.12.2012, p. 1.