At Track Record Global we're often asked by our clients and their suppliers to what extent certification schemes reduce the need for full supply chain due diligence. As this latest analysis by Earthsight shows, here in relation to soy certification scheme RTRS, certification is not a replacement for regulatory due diligence and enforcement. Roll on #EUDR and similar legislation.
New analysis by Earthsight exposes how soy certification scheme Round Table on Responsible Soy Association (RTRS) is facilitating the greenwashing of deforesters and land grabbers in the Cerrado through holes in its standard, weak enforcement, and a flawed credits system. In October 2024, Earthsight’s investigation, Secret Ingredient, traced soy used to feed European chickens to deforestation and illegalities in the Brazilian Cerrado. Two of the producers featured in the report are certified by RTRS, which provides a stamp of sustainability for over 66,000 soy producers. These cases once again cast doubt over the effectiveness of certification schemes in cleaning up supply chains. Read Secret Ingredient 🔗 https://bit.ly/3Z5ttw6 In RTRS’s own words, being certified is a “synonym for sustainability.” Yet our analysis suggests the scheme’s weak standard is facilitating the greenwashing of deforesters and land grabbers in the Cerrado. RTRS is largely based on the sale of ‘credits’, which firms can purchase to claim they are supporting responsible soy production. However, this does not mean they stop sourcing soy linked to deforestation or human rights abuses. RTRS’s credits system gives global consumers a misleading image of sustainability, while discouraging companies from taking meaningful action to address the impacts of their supply chains. Earthsight’s analysis reveals several instances where RTRS’s principles and criteria have been violated on certified farms, suggesting that even if the standard were strengthened, the scheme’s effectiveness would still be undermined by weak enforcement and a flawed auditing process. As companies prepare to comply with regulations aimed at curbing the environmental and human rights impacts of global supply chains, it is critical that the value of certification schemes is scrutinised. They must not be viewed as evidence of compliance with important due diligence laws, such as the #EUDR and the UK Environment Act. Read the full analysis here 🔗 https://bit.ly/3B2BzNZ