How can you ensure secure error handling and logging using design patterns?

Error handling and logging are essential aspects of any software application, especially when it comes to security. Errors can expose sensitive information, cause unexpected behavior, or even compromise the system. Logging can help track and diagnose issues, as well as provide evidence of malicious activity. However, both error handling and logging also pose some challenges, such as how to avoid revealing too much information, how to protect the logs from tampering, and how to ensure consistency and reliability. In this article, you will learn how to use some common design patterns to address these challenges and improve your error handling and logging security.

1 The Observer Pattern

The observer pattern is a behavioral design pattern that defines a one-to-many relationship between a subject and multiple observers. The subject notifies the observers of any changes in its state, and the observers react accordingly. This pattern can be useful for error handling and logging, as it decouples the source of the error from the actions that need to be taken. For example, you can have a subject that represents the application state, and observers that perform different tasks, such as logging the error, displaying a message to the user, or sending an alert to the administrator. This way, you can add or remove observers without affecting the subject, and you can also vary the behavior of the observers depending on the type and severity of the error.

Add your perspective

Amritpal Singh

Principal Software Engineer at PKWare
Report contribution
Performing different actions on error using Observer interface IObserver { public void Notify(); } interface IObservable { public void Subscribe(IObserver); } class Subject : IObservable { List<IObserver> errHandlers = new(); public void Subscribe(IObserver observer) { errHandlers.Add(observer); } public void Action() { //On Error foreach(IObserver observer in errHandlers) observer.Notify(); } } class ErrHandler1: IObserver { public void Notify() { //Log Error; } } class ErrHandler2:IObserver { public void Notify() { //Send Email to Admin; } } class main() { IObservable obj = new Subject(); obj.Subscribe(new ErrHandler1()); obj.Subscribe(new ErrHandler2()); }

Like

2 The Chain of Responsibility Pattern

The chain of responsibility pattern is another behavioral design pattern that allows you to pass a request along a chain of handlers, each of which can either handle the request or pass it to the next handler. This pattern can be useful for error handling and logging, as it allows you to separate the logic of handling different types of errors, and to avoid hard-coding the order of the handlers. For example, you can have a chain of handlers that deal with different levels of errors, such as validation errors, business logic errors, or system errors. Each handler can log the error, perform some recovery action, or escalate the error to the next handler. This way, you can change the order or the behavior of the handlers without affecting the rest of the chain, and you can also handle new types of errors by adding new handlers.

Add your perspective

3 The Singleton Pattern

The singleton pattern is a creational design pattern that ensures that only one instance of a class exists in the application, and that it can be accessed from anywhere. This pattern can be useful for error handling and logging, as it allows you to centralize the access and management of the resources that are involved in these tasks, such as files, databases, or network connections. For example, you can have a singleton class that represents the logger, and that encapsulates the logic of writing to the log file, rotating the log file, or encrypting the log file. This way, you can ensure that only one logger instance exists, and that it can be used by any component that needs to log an error, without having to create or close the log file multiple times.

Add your perspective

4 The Proxy Pattern

The proxy pattern is a structural design pattern that provides a surrogate or placeholder for another object, and that controls the access to that object. This pattern can be useful for error handling and logging, as it allows you to add some functionality or security to the original object, without modifying it. For example, you can have a proxy class that wraps the logger object, and that adds some features, such as filtering the log messages, caching the log messages, or sending the log messages to a remote server. This way, you can enhance the functionality or the performance of the logger, without changing the interface or the implementation of the logger.

Add your perspective

5 The Decorator Pattern

The decorator pattern is another structural design pattern that allows you to add some behavior or functionality to an object, without modifying its structure or subclassing it. This pattern can be useful for error handling and logging, as it allows you to customize the output or the format of the error messages or the log messages, without changing the source of the messages. For example, you can have a decorator class that wraps the logger object, and that adds some information, such as the timestamp, the severity, or the source of the error or the log message. This way, you can enrich the content or the appearance of the messages, without affecting the logic or the behavior of the logger.

Add your perspective

Amritpal Singh

Principal Software Engineer at PKWare
Report contribution
Interface ISubject { public Create(); } class User : ISubject { public Create() { //Create User } } abstract class SubjectDecorator : ISubject { Logger _logger; ISubject _sub; public SubjectDecorator(ISubject sub, Logger log) { _logger = log; _sub = sub; } public int Create() => _sub.Create(); } class ConsoleLogDecorator : SubjectDecorator { public ConsoleLogDecorator(ISubject sub, Logger log) : base(sub, log) { } public Create() { base.Create(); //On Error Console.Log(Error); } } class DatabaseLogDecorator : SubjectDecorator { public DatabaseLogDecorator(ISubject sub, Logger log) : base(sub, log) { } public Create() { base.Create(); //On Error //Log in Database } }

Like

6 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

How can you ensure secure error handling and logging using design patterns?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 The Observer Pattern

2 The Chain of Responsibility Pattern

3 The Singleton Pattern

4 The Proxy Pattern

5 The Decorator Pattern

6 Here’s what else to consider

Design Patterns

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on Design Patterns

More relevant reading