How can you give useful animation feedback without technical knowledge?

1 The purpose

Before you start giving feedback, you need to understand the purpose of the animation. What is the message, story, or emotion that the animation is trying to convey? Who is the target audience? What is the context and genre of the project? Knowing the purpose will help you focus on the most relevant and important aspects of the animation, and avoid nitpicking or missing the big picture.

4 The language

When giving feedback, it's essential to use language that is clear and effective, without causing offense or discouraging the animator. To do this, try using "I" statements instead of "you" statements. For example, instead of saying "You made this part confusing," say "I felt confused by this part." Additionally, use descriptive words rather than evaluative words - for instance, instead of saying "The movement was boring and dull," say "The movement was slow and smooth." Furthermore, use questions rather than commands and suggestions instead of orders. For example, rather than saying "You should change this choice," try asking "What was your intention with this choice?" or suggest "Maybe you could try this option" instead of ordering "You must do this option."

5 The delivery

Delivering feedback in an effective way is important for helping animators create better animations. Choose a suitable time and place to share your feedback, and be concise and focused. Additionally, maintain a positive and friendly attitude, and stay open and receptive to the animator's response. With these tips, you can provide useful animation feedback without technical knowledge, while also learning more about the art and craft of animation. This will help the animator achieve their goals, improve their skills, and create better animations.

6 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?