How can you maintain a consistent CI process across different environments?

Continuous integration (CI) is a key practice for application development, as it allows you to automate and streamline the build, test, and deployment of your code. However, CI can also pose some challenges when you need to work across different environments, such as development, testing, staging, and production. How can you maintain a consistent CI process across different environments and ensure that your code is reliable, secure, and compatible? Here are some tips and best practices to help you achieve this goal.

Find expert answers in this collaborative article

Selected by the community from 5 contributions. Learn more

1 Use a common CI tool

One of the first steps to maintain a consistent CI process across different environments is to use a common CI tool that supports your chosen languages, frameworks, and platforms. A common CI tool can help you standardize your workflows, scripts, and configurations, and avoid discrepancies and errors that may arise from using different tools. Some examples of popular CI tools are Jenkins, Travis CI, CircleCI, and GitHub Actions.

Add your perspective

Rob Irons

Global DevSecOps Champion | Pioneering operational excellence & efficiency through automation & innovation
Report contribution
This should be a no-brainer, but I have run into organizations that are in the migration from one CI tool, or no CI tool, just manual builds, to another. The goal would be to migrate as quickly as possible, keeping in mind the delivery schedules for each team/software application. If you can begin the migration of a few pipelines at the beginning of each sprint or PI, you have time to get it done. Please don't force teams to migrate to a new CI tool 2 days before the end of a sprint and for a major release! I would also add that there are 2 CI tools notable missing from the original article, Azure DevOps from Microsoft, and Bamboo Cloud from Atlassian.

Like
Jonathan Hall

I rescue Golang projects | Sign up to learn about Go every day boldlygo.tech/daily
Report contribution
There are only two acceptable ways to maintain consistent CI across multiple platforms: 1. Consistently don't do CI at all. 2. Delete all but one platform.

Like
Divyesh L.

Senior Database Engineer @ Mercury Insurance : JAVA/J2EE/JDBC, Microservices, Spring Boot, API Development, and Cloud Platforms (AWS, GC, Azure), Scrum Master Certified
Report contribution
One of the first steps to maintain a consistent CI process across different environments is to use a common CI tool that supports your chosen languages, frameworks, and platforms. A common CI tool can help you standardize your workflows, scripts, and configurations, and avoid discrepancies and errors that may arise from using different tools. Some examples of popular CI tools are Jenkins, Travis CI, CircleCI, and GitHub Actions.

Like

2 Configure your environments consistently

Another important step to maintain a consistent CI process across different environments is to configure your environments consistently. This means that you should use the same versions, dependencies, libraries, and settings for your code and infrastructure across all your environments. You can use tools like Docker, Kubernetes, Ansible, or Terraform to automate and manage your environment configurations and ensure that they are reproducible and scalable.

Add your perspective

Rob Irons

Global DevSecOps Champion | Pioneering operational excellence & efficiency through automation & innovation
Report contribution
Using the same tools, dependencies, and versions across environments is great, but make sure that your code doesn't have anything that is specific to an environment, e.g. microservice name, API gateway, etc.. If the application truly needs to know values for the environment, make sure they are external to the code and retrieved as needed from an environment variable, key vault, etc.. I have seen applications with large conditional logic blocks to set internal variables based on the environment. This makes a tight coupling between the code and the execution environment, which will lead to maintenance issues.

Like

3 Implement branching and merging strategies

A third step to maintain a consistent CI process across different environments is to implement branching and merging strategies that suit your development workflow and team size. Branching and merging strategies can help you organize your code, isolate features, fix bugs, and integrate changes in a controlled and efficient way. You can use tools like Git, SVN, or Mercurial to manage your version control system and follow common branching models like GitFlow, GitHub Flow, or Trunk-Based Development.

Add your perspective

Rob Irons

Global DevSecOps Champion | Pioneering operational excellence & efficiency through automation & innovation
Report contribution
Implementing a branching/merging strategy is key for many aspects of the software development process, not just for supporting consistent CI across environments. From my perspective, branches should not be directly related to an environment. Any branch should be deployable to any environment. There shouldn't be anything in the code or the CI tool that has direct ties to an environment. From a release perspective, there may be branches with certain features that are targeted for a QA or UAT environment, but that is related to the process, not a restriction where that branch could be deployed.

Like

4 Test your code thoroughly

A fourth step to maintain a consistent CI process across different environments is to test your code thoroughly and regularly. Testing your code can help you detect and prevent bugs, errors, vulnerabilities, and performance issues that may affect your application quality and functionality. You can use tools like JUnit, TestNG, Selenium, or Cucumber to automate and execute various types of tests, such as unit, integration, functional, or acceptance tests.

Add your perspective

5 Monitor and troubleshoot your CI process

A fifth step to maintain a consistent CI process across different environments is to monitor and troubleshoot your CI process and its results. Monitoring and troubleshooting your CI process can help you identify and resolve any issues that may occur during the build, test, or deployment stages, and ensure that your code is always ready for delivery. You can use tools like Nagios, Prometheus, Grafana, or Splunk to collect and analyze metrics, logs, alerts, and feedback from your CI process.

Add your perspective

6 Document and communicate your CI process

A sixth and final step to maintain a consistent CI process across different environments is to document and communicate your CI process and its best practices to your team and stakeholders. Documenting and communicating your CI process can help you establish clear expectations, guidelines, and standards for your code quality and delivery, and foster collaboration and alignment among your team members and clients. You can use tools like Confluence, Wiki, or Slack to create and share documentation, reports, and notifications about your CI process.

Add your perspective

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

How can you maintain a consistent CI process across different environments?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Use a common CI tool

2 Configure your environments consistently

3 Implement branching and merging strategies

4 Test your code thoroughly

5 Monitor and troubleshoot your CI process

6 Document and communicate your CI process

7 Here’s what else to consider

Application Development

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on Application Development

More relevant reading