How do you judge the quality of presentation sources?

1 Check the source type

Different types of sources have different purposes, audiences, and levels of credibility. For example, academic journals are usually peer-reviewed and offer in-depth research and analysis, while blogs are more informal and may express personal opinions or experiences. Depending on your presentation topic, purpose, and audience, you may need to use a combination of primary, secondary, and tertiary sources, such as original documents, books, articles, reports, reviews, encyclopedias, etc. You should also consider the currency, accuracy, and completeness of the source information.

2 Check the source author

Another way to judge the quality of presentation sources is to look at the author's credentials, reputation, and affiliation. You want to use sources that are written by experts, professionals, or authorities in the field or topic you are presenting. You can check the author's background, education, publications, awards, or affiliations with reputable institutions or organizations. You can also look at the author's tone, bias, and perspective, and see if they provide evidence, references, or citations for their claims or data.

3 Check the source quality

A third tip to judge the quality of presentation sources is to use some criteria or standards to assess the quality of the source content and presentation. You can use the CRAAP test, which stands for Currency, Relevance, Authority, Accuracy, and Purpose, to evaluate each source based on these aspects. For example, you can ask yourself questions like: Is the source up-to-date and timely? Is the source relevant and useful for your presentation? Is the source authoritative and credible? Is the source accurate and verifiable? Is the source objective and clear?

4 Check the source availability

A fourth tip to judge the quality of presentation sources is to make sure that the source is available and accessible for your presentation. You may find a great source online, but it may be behind a paywall, require a subscription, or have limited access. You may also find a great source in print, but it may be out of stock, out of print, or hard to locate. You should always check the availability and accessibility of the source before you decide to use it for your presentation. You should also make sure that you have the permission and the proper citation format to use the source.

5 Check the source diversity

A fifth tip to judge the quality of presentation sources is to diversify your sources and avoid relying on one type, one author, or one perspective. You want to use a variety of sources that offer different viewpoints, evidence, and insights on your presentation topic. You also want to use a balance of sources that support and challenge your arguments, claims, and data. Using diverse sources can help you avoid plagiarism, bias, and repetition, and enhance your credibility, critical thinking, and creativity.

6 Check the source relevance

A final tip to judge the quality of presentation sources is to always check the relevance of the source to your presentation. You may find a high-quality, authoritative, and available source, but it may not be relevant or appropriate for your presentation topic, purpose, or audience. You should always ask yourself how the source relates to your presentation, how it contributes to your main points, and how it engages your audience. You should also avoid using sources that are too general, too specific, or too off-topic for your presentation.

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?