Learn about the trade-offs between QAM, PSK, and FSK in terms of bandwidth, power, noise, and complexity in digital communication.

While QAM offers high data rates by varying both amplitude and phase, it does have notable drawbacks. Its complexity leads to higher costs and power consumption compared to simpler schemes like PSK and FSK. Additionally, its sensitivity to noise and interference can degrade signal quality and increase error rates. Synchronization challenges further complicate its implementation, as precise detection of both amplitude and phase is crucial for maintaining signal integrity.

Last updated on Aug 16, 2024

What are the advantages and disadvantages of using QAM over PSK or FSK?

In digital communication, modulation is the process of encoding information into a carrier signal, such as a radio wave or a light beam. Different modulation schemes have different trade-offs in terms of bandwidth, power, noise, and complexity. In this article, we will compare three common modulation schemes: quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM), phase-shift keying (PSK), and frequency-shift keying (FSK).

1 QAM Basics

QAM is a modulation scheme that combines two amplitude-modulated signals with different phases, resulting in four or more possible states for each symbol. For example, 16-QAM uses four different amplitude levels and four different phase angles, creating 16 possible combinations. QAM can transmit more bits per symbol than PSK or FSK, increasing the data rate and efficiency.

Add your perspective

Dennis Waiguru

Digital Marketing Manager | Graphic designer | Corporate Communication & Management | Social Media Account Manager | Ghostwriter | Digital PR and Online Networking
Report contribution
Advantages of QAM over PSK and FSK: Efficient Use of Bandwidth: QAM allows for higher data rates within a given bandwidth compared to PSK and FSK. By modulating both amplitude and phase, QAM can encode more bits per symbol, leading to increased spectral efficiency. Disadvantages of QAM compared to PSK and FSK: Increased Complexity: QAM modulation and demodulation require more complex signal processing algorithms and hardware compared to PSK and FSK. This complexity can result in higher implementation costs and computational overhead, particularly for high-order QAM constellations.

Like

2 QAM Advantages

One of the main advantages of QAM is that it can achieve higher spectral efficiency than PSK or FSK, meaning it can transmit more information in a given bandwidth. This is especially useful for applications that require high data rates, such as broadband internet, digital TV, and wireless networks. QAM can also adapt to different channel conditions by changing the number of states or the constellation shape, improving the performance and reliability.

Add your perspective

Muhammad Ahsan

Performance Marketing Specialist at Engel & Völkers Dubai
Report contribution
QAM's primary advantage lies in its high spectral efficiency, allowing for greater data transmission rates within the same bandwidth compared to PSK or FSK. This is crucial for applications needing high-speed data transfer, like broadband and digital TV. Additionally, QAM's adaptability to varying channel conditions through adjustments in constellation size or shape enhances both performance and reliability, making it versatile for diverse communication needs.

Like

3 QAM Disadvantages

However, QAM also has some disadvantages that limit its applicability. QAM requires more complex transmitters and receivers than PSK or FSK, increasing the cost and power consumption. QAM is also more sensitive to noise, interference, and distortion, reducing the signal quality and increasing the error rate. QAM may also suffer from synchronization issues, as the receiver needs to accurately detect the amplitude and phase of the signal.

Add your perspective

Muhammad Ahsan

Performance Marketing Specialist at Engel & Völkers Dubai
Report contribution
While QAM offers high data rates by varying both amplitude and phase, it does have notable drawbacks. Its complexity leads to higher costs and power consumption compared to simpler schemes like PSK and FSK. Additionally, its sensitivity to noise and interference can degrade signal quality and increase error rates. Synchronization challenges further complicate its implementation, as precise detection of both amplitude and phase is crucial for maintaining signal integrity.

Like

4 PSK Basics

PSK is a modulation scheme that changes the phase of the carrier signal according to the information bits. For example, binary PSK (BPSK) uses two phases, 0 and 180 degrees, to represent 0 and 1. PSK can also use more phases, such as quadrature PSK (QPSK) or 8-PSK, to transmit more bits per symbol.

Add your perspective

5 PSK Advantages

PSK has some advantages over QAM and FSK in terms of simplicity, robustness, and power efficiency. PSK does not require amplitude modulation, which simplifies the transmitter and receiver design and reduces the nonlinear distortion. PSK is also more resistant to noise and fading than QAM, as it only depends on the phase difference between the signal and the reference. PSK can also use constant envelope modulation, which maintains the same power level for all symbols, saving energy and reducing interference.

Add your perspective

6 PSK Disadvantages

On the other hand, PSK has some drawbacks that affect its performance and capacity. PSK has lower spectral efficiency than QAM, as it needs more bandwidth to transmit the same amount of information. PSK also has lower bit error rate (BER) performance than QAM at high signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs), as the phase transitions become more difficult to detect. PSK may also require more complex phase synchronization and demodulation techniques, especially for higher-order PSK.

Add your perspective

7 FSK Basics

FSK is a modulation scheme that changes the frequency of the carrier signal according to the information bits. For example, binary FSK (BFSK) uses two frequencies, one for 0 and one for 1. FSK can also use more frequencies, such as quadrature FSK (QFSK) or 8-FSK, to transmit more bits per symbol.

Add your perspective

8 FSK Advantages

FSK has some advantages over QAM and PSK in terms of ease of implementation, detection, and modulation. FSK does not require phase or amplitude modulation, which simplifies the transmitter and receiver design and reduces the nonlinear distortion. FSK is also easy to detect and demodulate, as it only requires a frequency discriminator or a filter bank. FSK can also use non-coherent detection, which does not need a reference signal or a phase synchronization.

Add your perspective

Joel Kwabena Aboagye, MA.

Digital Marketing | Digital Communications | Brands and Communications MGMT | Social Media Associate | Digital Creator | E-Learner | DJI Drone Pilot
Report contribution
FSK simplifies transmitter and receiver design by avoiding phase or amplitude modulation, reducing nonlinear distortion. It allows easy detection and demodulation using a frequency discriminator or filter bank. Additionally, FSK supports non-coherent detection, eliminating the need for a reference signal or phase synchronization. These features make FSK advantageous over QAM and PSK in certain applications.

Like

9 FSK Disadvantages

However, FSK also has some disadvantages that limit its efficiency and quality. FSK has lower spectral efficiency than QAM and PSK, as it needs more bandwidth to transmit the same amount of information. FSK also has higher BER performance than QAM and PSK at low SNRs, as the frequency separation becomes more difficult to distinguish. FSK may also suffer from inter-symbol interference (ISI), as the frequency transitions may overlap with adjacent symbols.

Add your perspective

10 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

What are the advantages and disadvantages of using QAM over PSK or FSK?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

1 QAM Basics

2 QAM Advantages

3 QAM Disadvantages

4 PSK Basics

5 PSK Advantages

6 PSK Disadvantages

7 FSK Basics

8 FSK Advantages

9 FSK Disadvantages

10 Here’s what else to consider

Digital Communication

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on Digital Communication

More relevant reading