What are the most effective and efficient sampling techniques for equipment cleaning verification?

1 Swab Sampling

Swab sampling is a direct sampling technique that involves wiping a sterile swab over a predefined area of the equipment surface, and then extracting and analyzing the swab for residues. Swab sampling is suitable for hard-to-reach areas, such as corners, crevices, valves, or joints, where other sampling methods may not be able to access. Swab sampling can also provide a quantitative measure of the residue level per unit area, which can be compared to the acceptance criteria. However, swab sampling has some limitations, such as the potential for cross-contamination, the variability of swabbing pressure and technique, and the difficulty of recovering all the residues from the swab.

2 Rinse Sampling

Rinse sampling is an indirect sampling technique that involves collecting and analyzing the rinse water or solvent that is used to wash the equipment after cleaning. Rinse sampling is suitable for large or complex equipment, where direct sampling may not be feasible or representative. Rinse sampling can also provide a global measure of the residue level in the entire equipment, which can be compared to the acceptance criteria. However, rinse sampling has some challenges, such as the selection of the appropriate rinse solvent, the determination of the rinse volume and flow rate, and the detection of low concentrations of residues in the rinse solution.

3 Coupon Sampling

Coupon sampling is a hybrid sampling technique that involves placing a small piece of material (coupon) that mimics the equipment surface in contact with the product and the cleaning agent, and then removing and analyzing the coupon for residues. Coupon sampling is suitable for validating new or modified cleaning processes, where actual equipment may not be available or accessible. Coupon sampling can also provide a controlled and consistent way of testing the cleaning efficiency and the recovery of residues from the surface. However, coupon sampling has some drawbacks, such as the need to ensure the similarity of the coupon and the equipment material, the placement and removal of the coupon, and the extrapolation of the coupon results to the equipment scale.

4 Other Sampling Techniques

Besides the above-mentioned sampling techniques, there are some other methods that can be used for equipment cleaning verification, depending on the specific situation and requirements. For example, visual inspection can be used as a preliminary or complementary method to check for any visible residues or stains on the equipment surface. However, visual inspection cannot detect residues below a certain threshold or in hidden areas. Another example is ATP bioluminescence, which is a rapid and sensitive method to detect the presence of microbial or organic residues on the equipment surface. However, ATP bioluminescence cannot differentiate between different types of residues or quantify their levels.

5 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?