How can you balance objective vendor performance evaluations with positive vendor relationships?

Vendor performance evaluation is a crucial part of contract management, as it helps you monitor the quality, timeliness, and compliance of the services or products you procure. However, evaluating your vendors objectively can also pose some challenges for maintaining positive and collaborative relationships with them. How can you balance these two aspects of vendor management without compromising your goals or expectations? Here are some tips to help you.

1 Define clear and measurable criteria

Before you start evaluating your vendors, you need to establish the criteria and metrics that you will use to assess their performance. These should be aligned with your contract terms, your business objectives, and your industry standards. You should also communicate these criteria to your vendors upfront, so that they know what you expect from them and how you will measure their success. By defining clear and measurable criteria, you can avoid ambiguity, confusion, and disputes in your evaluation process.

Add your perspective

Rashad Smith, MBA

Accounting Specialist
Report contribution
Once you've defined the criteria and metrics for assessing vendor performance, it's crucial to verify that your internal Account managers align with these standards. Regular weekly evaluations proactively identify discrepancies, facilitating real-time corrections before impacting the account. As you assess vendors, maintain a set of guidelines based on issues observed during the contract period, outlining strategies for prevention in future dealings. This structured approach ensures ongoing adherence to standards and fosters continuous improvement in vendor management.

Like
Noah Alfaro

Technical creative
Report contribution
Create a list of the most important qualities that your company needs in its vendors. Things such as average response time, credit limits, number of salespeople, stock, and sourcing ability are valuable metrics to keep. Your vendor should be aware of what you are tracking for transparency's sake and so that both parties will be motivated to best support each other.

Like

2 Use multiple sources of data

To ensure that your vendor performance evaluation is objective and accurate, you should use multiple sources of data to collect and analyze information. For example, you can use surveys, interviews, audits, reports, feedback, and benchmarks to gather different perspectives and evidence on your vendor's performance. You should also involve different stakeholders in your evaluation process, such as your project managers, end-users, quality assurance team, and senior management. By using multiple sources of data, you can reduce bias, verify results, and gain a comprehensive understanding of your vendor's performance.

Add your perspective

Kathryn Parmeter

Senior Contract Negotiator | Sourcing Leader | Creator | Innovator | Relationship Champion | Precision Linguist | Pioneer in Change
Report contribution
They should be one and the same. Performance comes before positive reinforcement about the relationship. Often people try to make friends with vendors because they fear what they don't know about what the vendor will be doing for them. This is a HUGE mistake. Forgetting who you are in a relationship effectively ends it and you wind up working for them instead of the reverse.

Like

3 Provide constructive feedback

One of the main purposes of vendor performance evaluation is to identify areas of improvement and provide feedback to your vendors. However, feedback can be perceived as positive or negative depending on how you deliver it. To maintain positive vendor relationships, you should provide constructive feedback that is specific, timely, respectful, and actionable. You should also acknowledge your vendor's strengths and achievements, and express appreciation for their efforts. By providing constructive feedback, you can motivate your vendors, foster trust, and encourage continuous improvement.

Add your perspective

4 Negotiate solutions and incentives

Sometimes, your vendor performance evaluation may reveal some gaps or issues that need to be addressed or resolved. In such cases, you should not rush to terminate or penalize your vendors, but rather negotiate solutions and incentives that can help them improve their performance. For example, you can offer additional training, support, resources, or guidance to your vendors, or revise some of the contract terms or scope. You can also reward your vendors for meeting or exceeding your expectations, such as by extending the contract, increasing the payment, or giving referrals. By negotiating solutions and incentives, you can show your vendors that you value their partnership and want them to succeed.

Add your perspective

Noah Alfaro

Technical creative
Report contribution
Corrective actions for vendors must be done with tact. You should (1) display your data. You vendor should know that you are not acting off a hunch, or some other ulterior motive. (2) Give your vendor the opportunity to confirm your data with their own. People and computers make mistakes. Don't be the one shaking your finger at someone when you could be wrong. (3) Come to an agreement for a corrective plan based on shared metrics, that way, you both know you can track progress.

Like

5 Review and update your evaluation process

Finally, you should not treat your vendor performance evaluation as a one-time or static activity, but rather as an ongoing and dynamic process. You should review and update your evaluation process regularly, to ensure that it reflects your changing needs, goals, and priorities. You should also solicit feedback from your vendors on your evaluation process, and incorporate their suggestions or concerns. By reviewing and updating your evaluation process, you can ensure that it is relevant, effective, and fair for both parties.

Add your perspective

6 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

How can you balance objective vendor performance evaluations with positive vendor relationships?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Define clear and measurable criteria

2 Use multiple sources of data

3 Provide constructive feedback

4 Negotiate solutions and incentives

5 Review and update your evaluation process

6 Here’s what else to consider

Contract Management

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on Contract Management

More relevant reading