Learn how to communicate the importance and benefits of performance evaluations to your staff in your culinary business, and how to conduct them effectively.

Meet with the team and explain the purpose of the performance evaluations and also inform them how the process will go. If in your system you have self-appraisals, give them a blank copy each and explain how they should use the self-appraisal to prepare for the main appraisal meeting. Stress the importance of coming prepared for the main meeting to have a beneficial appraisal meeting for the team members. Answer any questions the team may have and assure them that you are available if they need any further explanation or clarification.

What is the best way to communicate the importance of performance evaluations to your staff?

As a culinary manager, you know how vital it is to conduct regular performance evaluations for your staff. They help you assess their strengths, weaknesses, goals, and needs, as well as provide feedback and recognition. But how do you communicate the importance of these evaluations to your staff, especially if they are reluctant, defensive, or anxious about them? Here are some tips to help you prepare, conduct, and follow up on performance evaluations in a way that benefits both you and your staff.

1 Explain the purpose

Before you schedule a performance evaluation, make sure your staff understands why you are doing it and what you expect from them. Explain the purpose of the evaluation, the criteria you will use, the format and duration of the meeting, and the outcomes you hope to achieve. Emphasize that the evaluation is not a punishment or a judgment, but a tool to help them grow, improve, and succeed in their roles. Invite them to ask questions and voice any concerns they may have.

Add your perspective

Eugenios Savva

Hospitality & HR Consultant | Recruiter | Trainer | Talent Hunter Member of the Jury - Cyprus Tourism Awards
Report contribution
Meet with the team and explain the purpose of the performance evaluations and also inform them how the process will go. If in your system you have self-appraisals, give them a blank copy each and explain how they should use the self-appraisal to prepare for the main appraisal meeting. Stress the importance of coming prepared for the main meeting to have a beneficial appraisal meeting for the team members. Answer any questions the team may have and assure them that you are available if they need any further explanation or clarification.

Like
Amanda A.

Concierge | Content Writer
Report contribution
As a trainer of many years, this is completely true. Any performance evaluation can never be seen as a negative event, something to be scared of, or as a tool to chastise you with. If there is this kind of culture in your company perhaps a change of job could be right option! All feedback, all input, all constructive criticism, is good. It is welcomed, it is eaten up for breakfast. If someone can look at your work and give you some suggestions, or feedback, how could this possibly be a bad thing? In fact it makes things very clear for both parties. If the job is not the right fit for your skill set isn't it better to find out sooner rather than later?

Like

2 Be prepared and organized

One of the best ways to communicate the importance of performance evaluations is to show that you take them seriously and respect your staff's time and input. Be prepared and organized for each evaluation, and have all the relevant data, documents, and feedback ready. Review your staff's previous evaluations, goals, and achievements, and note any changes or progress. Avoid surprises or vague statements, and focus on facts and examples. Provide positive and constructive feedback, and recognize your staff's contributions and accomplishments.

Add your perspective

3 Listen and engage

Performance evaluations should not be a one-way conversation, but a dialogue between you and your staff. Listen and engage with your staff, and encourage them to share their opinions, perspectives, and feedback. Ask open-ended questions, such as "How do you feel about your performance in the past year?" or "What are some of the challenges or opportunities you faced?" or "What are some of the skills or areas you would like to develop or improve?" Show empathy and understanding, and acknowledge their feelings and emotions.

Add your perspective

4 Set SMART goals

One of the main objectives of performance evaluations is to help your staff set and achieve SMART goals. SMART stands for Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound. SMART goals are clear, realistic, and aligned with your staff's roles and responsibilities, as well as the overall vision and mission of your culinary business. When you set SMART goals with your staff, you communicate the importance of performance evaluations as a way to monitor their progress, track their results, and celebrate their success.

Add your perspective

5 Provide ongoing support

Performance evaluations are not a one-time event, but a continuous process of feedback and improvement. To communicate the importance of performance evaluations, you need to provide ongoing support to your staff, and follow up on their goals and actions. Check in with them regularly, and offer guidance, coaching, training, or resources as needed. Recognize their efforts and achievements, and reward them accordingly. Address any issues or problems promptly, and adjust their goals or expectations if necessary.

Add your perspective

Alex Munford

Father of 5 | Husband | Restaurant Manager | Hospitality Coach | Aspiring Podcaster | Daily Writer | Newsletter Creator | WHY Hospitality Co-founder & creative lead | WHY Leadership author
Report contribution
On-going support is crucial when it comes to your team. Having continuous touchpoint each day/shift allows for super open communication and forms a relationship based on trust and mutual respect. If your team member misunderstands something you've asked them to do and you don't touch base until the following month/quarter, the results are going to be way off. But if you are providing on-going support each time you work with that person, it provides countless chances to course correct, ask/answer questions, recognise their efforts/results and be their biggest fan. You will also build the reputation within your company, as a leader who actually cares. Not says they do, but shows they do. And those are hard to come by.

Like

6 Solicit feedback

Finally, one of the best ways to communicate the importance of performance evaluations is to solicit feedback from your staff on how they perceive and experience them. Ask them to rate the effectiveness, fairness, and value of the evaluation process, and to suggest any areas for improvement or change. Listen to their feedback, and act on it if possible. By soliciting feedback, you show your staff that you value their opinions and insights, and that you are committed to making performance evaluations a positive and productive experience for both of you.

Add your perspective

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

What is the best way to communicate the importance of performance evaluations to your staff?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Explain the purpose

2 Be prepared and organized

3 Listen and engage

4 Set SMART goals

5 Provide ongoing support

6 Solicit feedback

7 Here’s what else to consider

Culinary Management

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on Culinary Management

More relevant reading

What is the best way to communicate the importance of performance evaluations to your staff?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Explain the purpose

2 Be prepared and organized

3 Listen and engage

4 Set SMART goals

5 Provide ongoing support

6 Solicit feedback

7 Here’s what else to consider

Culinary Management

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

Explore Other Skills