What do you do if you want to provide constructive feedback to an interviewer without being overly critical?

Feedback is definitely a gift however, gifts are always better received when wrapped in love. Before going into a feedback session it’s important to be intentional about your approach and the key items you’ll be discussing. Put on your coaching hat, lead with welcoming energy, and remain present throughout the discussion. Remember, we’ve all been on the other side!

If you want to give feedback to an interviewer, think carefully about the timing. If it's too soon afterwards (or even in the interview itself) it's likely that your judgement could be clouded by the adrenaline or nerves of the situation. Make sure you reflect throughly on the experience before sharing your thoughts. You may want to wait until the interview process is complete, because your feedback (however well-intentioned) could negatively impact how you're perceived. Even if you are unsuccessful in the role, you may want to reapply to the company in the future - or meet the interviewer in a different context. Never send feedback in the heat of the moment, when you might say something you regret!

Don’t delay! Type up feedback after the interview Plan any feedback you’ll be giving. Be honest, but kind Keep it professional and related to the role. Set realistic expectations from the moment you call. Try to avoid being confrontational Be helpful. Make your feedback actionable and be concise Don’t be vague. Share specific examples. Make suggestions about what they could do differently in future Offer feedback on any or all parts of the hiring process, not just the interviews Give positive feedback and praise to build their confidence Give feedback on a wide variety of things. Be consistent. A structured interview process helps with consistency Provide structure. Basing things on a framework makes it easier to give accurate results

As a recruiter, I have always just been very transparent - there are tactful and polite ways to give constructive criticism without being rude. Honesty is the best policy -and as a person who has hundreds of opportunities open nationally, I almost always recommend other options if it’s not a good fit for the company offering the critical feedback … there’s a place for everyone!! Let’s find it together!

Here are some tips - Seek Permission: Before providing feedback, ask the interviewer if they are open to receiving constructive feedback. This shows respect for their feelings and gives them the opportunity to be receptive to your input. Focus on the Positive: Start by highlighting the aspects of the interview that went well or that you appreciated. This sets a positive tone for the conversation and shows that you are approaching the feedback with a constructive mindset. Maintain a Professional Tone: Keep your feedback professional and respectful. Avoid using harsh language or tone that may come across as confrontational. Remember, the goal is to help the interviewer grow and improve.

La manera en que nos comunicamos puede tener un impacto significativo. El tono, el lenguaje corporal y cada detalle contribuyen a que nuestras observaciones sean constructivas y efectivas. ¡Empatiza!.

I recommend asking if the interviewer is open to feedback before just launching into it. The goal of giving successful feedback is to help the other person improve. However, if a person is not in a great headspace to receive feedback, the conversation is meaningless.

Pour ma part, afin d'aborder le sujet de facon constructive, je m'appuyerai sur mon expertise en marque employeur. Indiquant des statistiques sur la candidat care et mettant en exergue l'impact que cela aurait et comment il pourrait améliorer cette expérience candidat

Being tactful is crucial when offering feedback. Choose your words carefully to convey your message in a respectful and considerate manner. Avoid harsh criticism and instead focus on constructive suggestions. Use a positive tone and frame your feedback in a way that encourages improvement rather than discouragement. Tactfulness ensures that your feedback is well-received and fosters a positive dialogue.

Explain a positive experience you had with another interviewer and why that experience was meaningful to you. This provides the interviewer with invaluable insight into best practices and helpful advice on how to improve the candidate experience.

Es importante demostrar compromiso al brindar sugerencias, ya que el impacto es mucho mayor cuando nuestros comentarios son específicos y viables. Por ejemplo, en lugar de decir - Deberíamos mejorar la claridad de las preguntas. Una forma de ser más específicos sería sugerir algo como - Podríamos proporcionar ejemplos concretos para cada pregunta y de esa forma ayudar a los candidatos a comprender mejor qué tipo de respuestas estamos buscando.

Il est essentiel que cela soit factuel. Ne pas faire de retour sur ce que j'ai ressenti mais bien sur les propos tenus. Rappeler le contexte est un pré requis. Par exemple, si vous avez du attendre plusieurs heures pour être recue en entretien, indiquez le nombre d'heures et non résumer cette expérience par une "longue attente".

Provide specific examples to illustrate your feedback effectively. Instead of general statements, offer precise instances where improvements could be made or strengths were demonstrated. Specific feedback helps the interviewer understand your perspective clearly and provides actionable insights for improvement without being overly critical.

Estar formado para entrevistar no es solo centrarse en preguntar e indagar si no también implica saber proporcionar detalles relevantes sobre el proceso; frente a ti hay una persona que tiene expectativas, deseos, necesidades, etc tan importantes como las tuyas por lo que también recuerda "no solo recibir información si no brindar información especifica y relevante"

I think honesty is always best and giving a candidate honest and specific feedback is the best way for them to learn for future interviews. It is important to offer balance though and give them the positives too.

Offer balanced feedback by acknowledging both strengths and areas for improvement. Start by highlighting what went well during the interview, then gently address areas where enhancements could be made. Provide specific examples and offer suggestions for improvement in a constructive manner. Balancing feedback ensures a fair and productive conversation.

Firstly, I would acknowledge the aspect of the interview that went well to set a positive tone. Later, I would suggest the enhancements. Instead of just pointing out problems, I would provide suggestions for improvement. I would maintain a positive and respectful tone throughout the conversation.

Having good and bad experiences, some candidates are holding the offer with 2-3 companies. The hiring process is tuff choose the good one and go with the offer - offers are accepted by the candidates but sometimes they can't join the organization cause of another opportunity.

I think giving a honest feedback, not only encourage the candidate background knowledge but infact gave him ample chances of reflection on his or her existing knowledge. It must be kept in mind that such reviews should not be baised, emotional or irrelevant, it should be precise and offer a supervisory reflection one somebody's role whether he or she is fit enough for the Job criteria and how it could be improved.

¿Como dar devoluciones sandwich? 1. Comienza con un elogio o algo positivo sobre el trabajo realizado. 2. Luego, menciona el área de mejora o el punto a corregir de manera clara y específica. 3. Ofrece sugerencias o consejos para mejorar en esa área. 4. Finaliza con otro comentario positivo o palabras de ánimo para motivar al receptor. Recuerda que la clave está en equilibrar la crítica con el apoyo y la motivación.

After any interview "Feedback shows belief, welcomes the changes, and gives the future vision." Candidates can understand their prospects and clear vision of the future by providing honest feedback -Build understanding and trust -Motivation -Assist -Collaboration -Suggestion -Inspiring -Passionate Everyone has the chance to prosper by establishing leaders who lead with compassion and vision.

Encouraging dialogue fosters a constructive exchange of ideas. Begin by expressing appreciation for the opportunity to share feedback. Then, invite the interviewer to discuss areas for improvement collaboratively. Emphasize the importance of mutual growth and understanding. Active dialogue promotes a positive and productive exchange.

Open and honest communication is so important. I think we all can struggle with the acceptance of feedback but if it does in a way where you can communicate on both sides or show how you can relate to the person can be helpful. You can more easily bring someone's guard down by sharing things about yourself that you know you have had to work on and it might allow for the other person to open up more after you have shared.

Vielleicht gab es auch einen Grund oder die eigene falsche Wahrnehmung, warum der Interviewer so gehandelt hat. Daher sind Rückfragen oft wichtig, um sich nicht eine ggf. fälschliche Meinung zu bilden und unberechtigt negatives Feedback anzubringen. Darüber hinaus kann man durch Rückfragen zum eigenen Feedback nur wachsen und ebenfalls positiv im Gedächtnis des Interviewers bleiben.

Feedbacks are usually not well received; people are typically not prepared to hear that the way they are operating may not be the best option. That's why we should start with compliments on the positive points and raise areas for improvement as advice. This way, we leave the other person free to accept or not.

when we go on time respond to the candidates with positive or negative feedback they understand the value of the interview process. It creates a positive relationship between both of us and shows professionalism. By the on-time response will get good strength in network connections.

When providing constructive feedback to an interviewer, focus on framing your points in a positive and constructive manner. Start by expressing appreciation for the opportunity and their time. Then, offer specific examples or suggestions for improvement rather than general criticisms. Use "I" statements to convey your perspective and avoid sounding accusatory. Finally, end on a positive note, reaffirming your interest in the position or the company.

Constructive feedback is invaluable for personal and professional growth. When providing suggestions or insights, consider the following tips to enhance your communication and make a positive impact: Clarity and Conciseness: Specific Examples. Solution-Oriented Approach. . Positive Tone. Active Listening. Timeliness. Thoughtful feedback contributes to a collaborative and growth-oriented environment. By following these guidelines, you can offer valuable insights while maintaining professionalism and respect.

Don't take it personally. First, understand that the person offering constructive criticism does not intend to make you feel bad about yourself. ... Keep an open mind. Keeping an open mind allows you to properly engage yourself in the process. ... Work towards a solution

When providing constructive feedback to an interviewer, follow these best practices to be helpful without being overly critical:- Start with positives: Highlight the candidate’s strengths and positive aspects of their interview. Be specific: Offer detailed examples to illustrate your points. Focus on improvement: Suggest areas where the candidate can enhance their performance. Encourage self-reflection. Maintain professionalism.

Dire non à un candidat n'est jamais une chose facile. Mais c'est un moment qui peut devenir constructif pour vous et votre relation avec le candidat. Soyez proactif. Prenez les devants et montrez à vos candidats que vous êtes attentifs à leur situation. C'est une façon de les fidéliser, mais aussi de leur faire comprendre qu'ils ne sont pas qu'un simple numéro de CV dans votre système de gestion des candidatures. Dire non de façon claire, nette et précise permet au candidat de se remettre en question, de progresser et d'avancer.

One thing I would consider before giving constructive feedback to an interviewer is whether he/she is soliciting feedback on the information I want to offer and also if giving a constructive feedback to the interviewer would be perceived as an insult or helpful information.

It's fascinating how AI chatbots can transform the initial screening process, offering both scale and consistency. However, it's vital to keep the bot-human synergy at the forefront. A well-programmed chatbot should be an extension of the team, capturing the essence of the role and company culture, while ensuring a smooth handoff to human colleagues for deeper engagement. Also, feedback loops and compliance checks are crucial to refine these digital assistants and maintain ethical standards. After all, the goal is to enhance, not replace, the personal touch that is so critical in recruiting. The future of work is here, and it's a blend of tech efficiency with human empathy. #InnovationInRecruitment #HRTechEvolution #AIandEmpathy