How can you evaluate tourism policies for effectiveness?

There are lots of typical measures but I believe we should start with what the host community defines as success .... then we should also consider what the true carrying capacity is does it provide a nature and human positive outcome. A good example of this is something like the Doughnut Economics City Outcomes.

I will not make a long answer to this question. For a destination the Key performance Indicators are: 1. The number of visitors international and domestic. 2. The length of stay. 3. Expenditure total visit and per day. 4. Dispersion throughout the destination region. 5. Level of satisfaction with the visit and the destination's overall infrastructure and attractions. 6. The degree of satisfaction with the hospitality received from the tourism businesses and the destination community. 7. Ease of access to from and within the destination. 8. Assessment by visitors of the quality of and ease of access to information about the destination. 9. Quality of and ease of travelling to and within the destination. 10. Information in visitor's language

Evaluating tourism policies is essential to: Assess Impact: Understand the actual effects of policies on economic, social, and environmental aspects. In summary, evaluating tourism policies is essential for achieving sustainable and well-balanced tourism development, aligning the sector with broader societal goals, and ensuring that the benefits of tourism are maximized while minimizing negative impacts.

Evaluating tourism policies is essential to support sustainable development in the tourism sector. In most cases, it focuses on maximizing economic gains while minimizing negative impacts on the environment and local communities.

Evaluating tourism policies is also really useful in PPP projects. The creation of public-private collaborations also based on correct knowledge of both tourist flows and the policies that manage them can be one of the keys to their success

Es fundamental evaluar si la política turística está, al menos: A. Alineada con las tendencias del turismo actuales. B. Alineada con el tejido turístico y sus estrategias. C. Alineada con la demanda presente y futura en términos de hábitos de consumo y valores. D. Complementa las carencias que el tejido privado no cubre.

Considerations are: Relevance: Determine if the policy's objectives and activities align with the needs and expectations of target groups and the broader context. Efficiency: Evaluate how well the policy utilizes resources (time, money, human resources) to produce outputs (products, services, events). Effectiveness: Assess the policy's success in achieving intended outcomes and impacts, such as behavioral, attitudinal, or condition changes in beneficiaries and society. Sustainability: Examine the policy's contribution to long-term economic, social, and environmental well-being of the destination and its stakeholders. These criteria provide a comprehensive framework for assessing the performance and impact of tourism policies.

In evaluating tourism policies at Askos Tours, we focus on relevance, efficiency, effectiveness, and sustainability. This ensures our tours, whether in Pompeii, Capri, or Rome, are not only culturally enriching but also sustainably contribute to the preservation of heritage.

En la evaluación de políticas turísticas, es esencial considerar la sostenibilidad, evaluando su impacto económico para asegurar desarrollo equitativo. Desde lo social, evaluar la participación comunitaria y la preservación cultural es clave. Ambientalmente, es fundamental analizar prácticas que minimicen impactos negativos. Económicamente, se busca un crecimiento inclusivo. Evaluar estas áreas garantiza políticas turísticas equilibradas y beneficiosas para las comunidades, el medio ambiente y la economía.

There are several criteria to evaluate the tourism policies. Some of them are as follows: 1) Economic benefits- The tourism sector is the main driver of economic growth for many countries. That's why carefully planned tourism policy can positively support economic benefits 2)Destination management- it plays an important role in the effective management, as well as the marketing of the destination 3) Sustainable development- it stimulates sustainability in tourism and minimizes the negative effects on the environment

At Askos Tours, we blend qualitative and quantitative methods for policy evaluation, including surveys, performance indicators, and client reviews. This helps us maintain high standards and adapt our cultural and archaeological tours to current trends and client expectations.

La evaluación de políticas turísticas debe abordarse desde diversas perspectivas. Desde la sostenibilidad, se deben medir los impactos económicos, sociales y ambientales a largo plazo. En el aspecto social, es esencial evaluar la participación comunitaria y la preservación cultural. Ambientalmente, se deben analizar prácticas que minimicen la huella ecológica. Desde la perspectiva económica, la generación de empleo y el estímulo económico local son indicadores clave. La integración de estas evaluaciones garantiza políticas turísticas equitativas y beneficiosas para todos los involucrados.

Análisis de la demanda y contraposición con el destino y lo que ofrece. Estudio de la iniciativa privada y sus estrategias. Revisión de la estrategia pública y su adecuación con la demanda y coordinación con la estrategia privada. Los grupos de trabajo, las encuestas y, por encima de todo, el análisis cuantitativo y cualitativo tomando como base las estrategias y resultados pasados y presentes, se antoja fundamental.

Surveys: Gather data from tourists, residents, businesses, and officials through questionnaires, interviews, and focus groups to collect both quantitative and qualitative insights. Indicators: Utilize indicators to monitor and compare policy performance or progress, leveraging both existing and new data. Case Studies: Analyze specific policies or elements in detail using multiple sources of evidence to understand context, process, and results. Literature Reviews: Synthesize and evaluate existing research to identify gaps, trends, and best practices related to the policy. These methods provide comprehensive tools for evaluating tourism policies, ensuring a thorough understanding of their impact and effectiveness.

La question de l’évaluation des politiques publiques est l’une des plus importantes en sciences politiques, en sociologie, en économie. Il est donc indispensable de s’appuyer sur les travaux de chercheurs professionnels qui sont en mesure de proposer des modèles inspirants. Les différentes approches existantes en matière de comptabilité en triple capital, on peut être développé scientifiquement avant de trouver des applications concrètes dans des secteurs économiques ou des activités données. L’évaluation des politiques publiques mériterait de recourir à ces nouveaux modèles, mais également d’inspirer une recherche approfondie sur la façon de mesurer l’efficacité de l’action publique en général.

The timing of evaluation of any policy depends on the purpose of evaluation- no single timing of any particular policy would be strategic for every destination.

We evaluate policies at three stages: ex-ante, mid-term, and ex-post. This approach allows continuous refinement of our tours, ensuring they remain culturally enriching and aligned with tourism trends.

In my experience, evaluating tourism policies depends on government planning and short, medium and long-term objectives. Public policy experts need to establish indicators that measure the objectives and also establish weights. Remember what cannot be measured cannot be evaluate

La evaluación de políticas turísticas debe ser continua y adaptativa. Antes de su implementación, permite anticipar impactos desde la sostenibilidad, social, ambiental y económica. Durante la ejecución, evaluaciones regulares son cruciales para ajustes oportunos y maximizar beneficios. Después de periodos significativos, se logra una comprensión a largo plazo de los impactos en sostenibilidad, relaciones sociales, salud ambiental y desarrollo económico. Un enfoque temporalmente variado asegura una evaluación exhaustiva y una gestión efectiva del turismo.

Evaluating tourism policies effectively involves choosing the right timing, typically at three key stages: Ex-Ante Evaluation: Conducted before policy implementation. Focuses on assessing feasibility, potential, and risks to aid in policy design and planning. Sets a baseline and targets. Mid-Term Evaluation: Carried out during policy implementation. Monitors progress and performance, allowing for real-time adjustments and improvements. Ex-Post Evaluation: Undertaken after policy completion. Analyzes outcomes and impacts to facilitate learning, reporting, and informing future policies. Choosing the appropriate timing ensures comprehensive evaluation and continuous improvement of tourism policies.

Government, local communities, NGOs, and the industry itself can evaluate tourism policies. Because each stakeholders have their own uniqueness

At Askos Tours, we combine internal assessments by our expert team with external feedback. This dual approach ensures our tours are authentic, engaging, and respectful of local heritage and customs.

La evaluación de políticas turísticas debe ser un esfuerzo colaborativo que involucre a gobiernos, comunidades locales, la industria turística, organizaciones sin fines de lucro y académicos. Cada entidad aporta una perspectiva única, asegurando una evaluación integral que aborde tanto los intereses locales como los objetivos globales de sostenibilidad y equidad. La participación de diversos actores garantiza que las políticas turísticas se ajusten a las necesidades y aspiraciones de todas las partes involucradas.

En cuanto la práctica sostenible, es indispensable que las métricas puedan arrojar resultados basados en una estrategia sostenible previamente elaborada con base a un análisis de materialidad. La medición de la práctica sostenible dentro del Triple Valor Positivo debe de hacerse pasado el tiempo adecuado tras la implementación

Les politiques publiques en matière de tourisme ne peuvent désormais plus se concevoir autrement qu’à travers une analyse économique, environnementale et sociale. S’ajoute la nécessité d’évaluer la valeur socio écologique du patrimoine naturel et historique. Enfin, le tourisme ne doit pas être négligé car il favorise les échanges entre des populations d’horizons différents. Les voyages et les déplacements constituent un vecteur de lien fondamental dans l’Interconnaissance et finalement en matière de communication. C’est parce que le voyage sera conçu et évalué en prenant en compte ces différentes dimensions, quel permettront de produire les meilleurs effets sociaux, écologiques et enfin économiques, selon une approche durable intégrée.