What do you do if your employer presents a counteroffer during negotiations?

1 Evaluate Intent

When presented with a counteroffer, take a step back to assess the employer's motivation. Are they genuinely valuing your contributions, or are they buying time to find your replacement? It's crucial to consider the reasons behind the counteroffer. If it's merely a reactionary move to your potential departure, it may lack long-term sincerity. Reflect on the company's culture, your career trajectory within the organization, and whether the counteroffer aligns with your professional goals.

2 Analyze Terms

Carefully scrutinize the terms of the counteroffer. Look beyond the salary increase or benefits and consider other important factors such as job title, responsibilities, and work-life balance. Ensure that any promises made are documented. Verbal agreements can be forgotten or disregarded, so having a written commitment is imperative for future accountability. Take your time to understand all aspects of the new offer before making a decision.

3 Consider Loyalty

Reflect on the implications of accepting a counteroffer on your reputation and relationships within the company. While it might seem advantageous in the short term, consider how your initial desire to leave could affect your colleagues' and superiors' trust in you. Loyalty is a two-way street, and if you sense that staying might undermine your standing or future opportunities, it may not be worth the immediate gains.

4 Assess Growth

Think about your long-term career growth and whether staying with your current employer will help you achieve your aspirations. Does the counteroffer include opportunities for professional development, or is it limited to financial incentives? Your decision should be based on where you see yourself in the future and which option—staying or leaving—will best help you get there.

5 Weigh Stability

While change can be good, it also comes with uncertainty. Consider the stability that the counteroffer provides against the unknowns of a new position. If the counteroffer substantially improves your current situation and the new job carries risks such as an unfamiliar corporate culture or untested role, it might be wise to stay put. However, if you're seeking a new challenge or a change of environment, this could be the push you need to move on.

6 Seek Advice

Finally, consult with trusted mentors, peers, or industry contacts before making your decision. They can provide you with unbiased perspectives based on their experiences and knowledge of the market. This external insight can help you weigh the pros and cons from angles you might not have considered, ensuring that your decision is well-informed and aligned with your career objectives.

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?