What do you do if your feedback for a 3D modeler lacks clarity and actionability?

As a 3D modeler, you know how important feedback is for improving your skills and delivering quality work. But what if the feedback you receive is vague, confusing, or unhelpful? How do you respond and ask for more clarity and actionability? In this article, we will share some tips and best practices for giving and receiving feedback in 3D modeling projects.

1 Understand the goal

The first step to deal with unclear or unactionable feedback is to understand the goal of the project and the expectations of the client or supervisor. What is the purpose of the 3D model? What are the requirements and specifications? What are the deadlines and milestones? Having a clear vision of the goal will help you align your work with the feedback and avoid unnecessary revisions or misunderstandings.

Add your perspective

Parminderjit Singh

Innovative Architectural Solutions | Revit & Visualization Proficient | Design Challenges Welcome
Report contribution
Before diving into addressing feedback that seems unclear or hard to act upon, it's essential to grasp the project's core aim and what your client or supervisor expects. Understand why they need the 3D model, what specific features it should have, and when they need it by. Having this clear picture not only guides your work but also ensures you're on the same page, minimizing confusion and unnecessary back-and-forth.

Like

2 Ask for examples

Sometimes, feedback can be subjective or based on personal preferences. For example, someone might say that your 3D model looks too realistic, too stylized, or too simple. But what does that mean exactly? How can you improve your 3D model based on such feedback? One way to clarify this kind of feedback is to ask for examples. Ask the feedback giver to show you some references, samples, or inspirations that illustrate what they are looking for. This will help you visualize their feedback and apply it to your 3D model more effectively.

Add your perspective

Parminderjit Singh

Innovative Architectural Solutions | Revit & Visualization Proficient | Design Challenges Welcome
Report contribution
Feedback can sometimes feel a bit vague, especially when it's based on personal tastes or subjective opinions. For instance, someone might tell you that your 3D model looks 'too realistic' or 'too simple,' leaving you scratching your head on how to improve. In situations like these, it's incredibly helpful to ask for examples. Encourage the person giving feedback to share references or samples that better explain what they mean. Seeing visual examples allows you to grasp their vision more clearly and make targeted adjustments to your 3D model.

Like

3 Use the SMART framework

The SMART framework is a great way to ensure feedback is clear and actionable. SMART stands for Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound. This means that feedback should be tailored to the 3D model's specific aspects, such as shape, color, texture, lighting, or animation. It should also quantify the feedback with scale, proportion, resolution, or frame rate. Moreover, the feedback should be realistic and feasible within your skillset and time constraints. It should also relate to the goal of the project and have a clear deadline or timeframe for completion or revision. Utilizing the SMART framework will help you and the feedback giver communicate more efficiently and effectively.

Add your perspective

Parminderjit Singh

Innovative Architectural Solutions | Revit & Visualization Proficient | Design Challenges Welcome
Report contribution
"The SMART framework is like your feedback GPS, guiding you to clarity and action. Picture this: Specific feedback zooms in on details like the shape, color, or lighting of your 3D model. Measurable feedback adds numbers or scales to the mix, giving you clear benchmarks to hit. Achievable feedback keeps it real, making sure it's something you can actually pull off with your skills and resources. Relevant feedback ties back to the project's goal, ensuring you're not straying off course. And lastly, Time-bound feedback sets a deadline, so you know when to wrap things up. With SMART feedback, you and the feedback giver are on the same page, cruising toward success.

Like

4 Give feedback as well

As a 3D modeler, it is important to give feedback to the client or supervisor who is reviewing your work. Doing so will help you build a rapport, display your professionalism, and prove that you understand the project. Furthermore, giving feedback can clarify any doubts, questions, or suggestions you have about the project or the feedback. Acknowledge the feedback and thank the person for their input. Explain how you interpreted the feedback and how you plan to implement it. You can also ask for confirmation or approval of your interpretation or implementation. If appropriate and constructive, provide your own feedback or opinion on the project or the feedback. Additionally, request more feedback or guidance if needed or desired. Giving feedback will help create a positive and productive feedback loop with the person providing feedback, while simultaneously improving your 3D modeling skills and results.

Add your perspective

5 Learn from feedback

The final step to deal with unclear or unactionable feedback is to learn from it. Feedback is an opportunity to grow and improve as a 3D modeler, not a criticism or a judgment. Therefore, you should always take feedback with an open mind and a positive attitude, and use it to enhance your 3D modeling portfolio and career. To learn from feedback, reflect on the strengths and weaknesses of your 3D model, apply the feedback and make the necessary changes or revisions, compare the before and after versions of your 3D model, seek more feedback, celebrate your achievements, and reward yourself for your hard work. Doing so will help you become a more confident and competent 3D modeler, and deliver more quality and satisfaction to your clients or supervisors.

Add your perspective

6 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

What do you do if your feedback for a 3D modeler lacks clarity and actionability?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Understand the goal

2 Ask for examples

3 Use the SMART framework

4 Give feedback as well

5 Learn from feedback

6 Here’s what else to consider

3D Modeling

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on 3D Modeling

More relevant reading

What do you do if your feedback for a 3D modeler lacks clarity and actionability?

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 Understand the goal

2 Ask for examples

3 Use the SMART framework

4 Give feedback as well

5 Learn from feedback

6 Here’s what else to consider

3D Modeling

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

Explore Other Skills