Andrew Brown’s Post

View profile for Andrew Brown, graphic

Executive Director at East 72 Holdings Limited

The proposed acquisition of Trident Royalties PLC by Deterra Royalties is causing an outburst of criticism on another social media platform. I have been one of the critics - I think it is a shocking deal that shareholders should react virulently against. Deterra owns one of the greatest assets of any ASX listed company - the 1.232% revenue royalty on Mining Area C in the Pilbara with (mainly) BHP as the counterparty. They propose to use some of this revenue to buy a grab-bag of future royalties - the centrepiece being a US lithium royalty - plus some offtakes (which are NOT royalties) at a cost of some US$225m including hefty deal fees (65c per DRR share). Given that the offtakes were only bought 2 years ago for $70m, Deterra are paying $154m for highly risky future royalties. Management are hiding behind UK takeover rules and it is clear their due diligence is less than deep. Given that one of the KMP's for management is acquisitions, that's what they will do. Even though it's like buying a cubic zirconia from a street dealer to put next to the Koh-i-Noor. I own no shares because I won't entrust my money to people who currently spend ~$12m to cash quarterly cheques and have created a bureaucracy and jobs with shareholders money. Capital management at its absolute worst in my opinion. I suggest shareholders carefully analyse this appalling deal and do something about it.

Philip Beard

Head of Self Promotion at Scoop Galatic Industries

5mo

Andrew could not agree more these guys have only one job --and they have stuffed it Scoop

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics