Why Snobbishness Hurts the Wine Industry
Is the idea of the "wine snob" really what consumers want, or are we just deceiving ourselves?
Do we have any solid studies to support this belief, or is it merely a narrative we’ve constructed? Wine enthusiasts haven’t had the option to enjoy wine without the snobbery, and I know many people who don’t find the snobbishness appealing, they simply enjoy wine and drink it. It seems we’re projecting assumptions that may not exist. We've built a framework around snobbery that lacks substantial evidence.
The narrative that wine is complex and requires education has persisted for decades, yet sales continue to decline. If consumers were genuinely seeking that complexity, we should be seeing a surge in wine sales. This indicates a problem, and perhaps a focus on getting more people to enjoy wine by simplifying the experience could save struggling wine businesses and jobs.
In what aspects of your life do you deliberately choose complexity, when a simpler, more straightforward solution is available? For example, would you prefer to spend on a custom website design and programming and take months to finalise your website, or would you rather use a user-friendly platform like Shopify to create your website in a few days if the results are the same? Do you prefer reports that simply provide facts and statistics, or do you prefer concise summaries that provide quick and clear information?
If we gravitate towards simplicity in our personal choices, why do we insist that people can only appreciate wine through the complex and snobbish framework we’ve created?
Perhaps the greatest innovation would be to return to our roots. We need to abandon the idea that wine must be viewed as inaccessible, where formal education is a prerequisite for enjoyment. Historically, winery owners embraced visitors with warmth and valued their feedback. Today, however, we often prioritize the opinions of wine critics over those of actual consumers. It's perplexing that we give more weight to paid ratings than to the customers who keep us in business.
With shifts in consumer behaviour towards authenticity and inclusivity, perceptions of snobbery are changing. Many now view snobbishness negatively, associating it with exclusion and superficiality. Consumers increasingly seek genuine experiences and relatable brands, making them more likely to reject elitist attitudes in favour of authenticity and connection.
Do you want to be perceived as a snob? Do you think snobbery is appealing?
Over the past year, I've shared insights on the transformative power of the way wine speaks, engaging thousands of people on LinkedIn. The flood of supportive messages I have received shows the industry’s fatigue with elitism. Isn’t that a clear signal for change?
Let’s take a moment to reflect, #rethink, and engage in meaningful conversations about this topic.
#rethinkingthewineindustry #winebusiness #wineforum #winetalk #winesnob #wineculture