Marcel van der Heijden MSc’s Post

View profile for Marcel van der Heijden MSc, graphic

Program Manager | Human Rights, Gender Equality, Asylum Reception

Interesting article by Katharina Natter: Why does migration research have so little impact? (1) Policy makers often make selective and symbolic use of knowledge to legitimize their position as decision makers or to support their pre-existing policy preferences; (2) Institutional or individual self-preservation mechanisms determine how knowledge is used (or not) by policy makers; (3) Whether knowledge is used or not is influenced by how salient or politicized it is. As a result, policy makers often stick to migration policies and measures that are known not to work. For example: (a) Criminalization of migrant smuggling (while we know that the absence of regular migration routes creates the conditions in which smuggling can flourish); (b) Restriction of social services for migrants to reduce the alleged pull factors (while there is little evidence that the level of social services determine where migrants go to); (c) Development programmes to address the root causes of migration (while several studies show that development in low-income countries tends to increase rather than reduce emigration); (d) Visa requirements to reduce migration (despite the fact that such restrictions have been shown to often reduce circular movements and encourage people to settle rather than return). https://lnkd.in/e_SAjNKn

Why Has Migration Research So Little Impact? Examining Knowledge Practices in Migration Policy Making and Migration Studies - Katharina Natter, Natalie Welfens, 2024

Why Has Migration Research So Little Impact? Examining Knowledge Practices in Migration Policy Making and Migration Studies - Katharina Natter, Natalie Welfens, 2024

journals.sagepub.com

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics