People with learning disadvantages should be in their own classrooms, according to a new "politician" in Italy.
I disagree with almost every idea of this individual, but this one about separating students really rubs me the wrong way.
My grandma, born in 1922, was a teacher. She was a sole teacher, meaning she taught every class, history, maths, geography, etc. She was already advocating, back then, for including kids with learning disadvantages rather than separating them from the rest.
In the 70s, Italian television would make "commercials" to teach Italian values, inclusion was one of those, and you could see a kid saying that she loves her classmate with a disability because she's super nice and can't wait to see her the next day at school.
Inclusion is part of my culture and, to my understanding, it makes sense both as a logical answer to a need, and as a must from an ethical standpoint.
Now, I would imagine that most of you agree with this, and you'd be disgusted as I have been in hearing about the idea of separating kids with disabilities and kids without them. But let me also address a mistake some people did while trying to advocate against this uneducated idea.
Someone said, paraphrasing: "We need to include those with disabilities, if they go at 0, and I go at 100, we go together at 50!". That's also a wrong perspective. People with no disabilities are not going slower because they include others, the learning effort proceeds as usual and we, educators, must make sure we do our best so that everyone stays on point. We don't sacrifice one's experience to benefit someone else, there has never been the need.
The politician also said: "Someone with a severe learning delay feels more or less discriminated against in a class where everyone understands instantly?" Implying that the separation would benefit those with a disability. [I hope you understand how tough this post is being for me to write while being educative and polite.]
If you separate classes, those that may need more support not only can feel way more discriminated, but you also deny them the chance to prove themselves against their peers.
Separating is unethical and counterproductive.
I am learning more about inclusive design as years go by, but even if you asked me as a kid, about separating students, I would have given you the look of confusion of a lifetime.
I had kids with disabilities in all the classes I grew up in, from them, I learned different points of view, compassion, honesty, and open-mindedness. I learned the value of diversity, and how to support each other sharing our unique skill sets. And I like to think they also got something out of interacting with that hot mess that I was back then.
Keep the interaction up, provide support, promote inclusion.
And, if you feel the need to separate: recycle. Cheers.
Senior Safeguarding & Player Welfare Manager at Football Association of Wales
1wJason Webber Carys Ingram