Taiwo Oyedele’s Post

View profile for Taiwo Oyedele, graphic
Taiwo Oyedele Taiwo Oyedele is an Influencer

Chairman, Presidential Fiscal Policy and Tax Reforms Committee

This has been quoted out of context to suit the objective of the author. What are the issues? 1) Nigeria's VAT system places a huge burden on businesses as they are not allowed to claim the input VAT incurred on services and assets. 2) Some items which constitute basic consumptions (food, education, and healthcare) are liable to VAT rather than being exempt or zero-rated. 3) Many small businesses have to contend with VAT compliance in view of the existing low VAT exemption threshold for small businesses. 4) Many states charge other forms of consumption taxes in addition to VAT thereby creating multiplicity of taxes. 5) Export of services and intellectual property bear VAT rather than being zero-rated to promote exports. What are we proposing? To address the above identified problems, we are proposing the following: 1) full input VAT credit for businesses to reduce their cost of doing business and minimise the strain on their cash flows. 2) remove VAT on an expanded list of basic food, educational and healthcare items to protect the poor. 3) harmonise all consumption taxes into one (VAT only) and adjust the revenue sharing formula in favour of states to address multiplicity of taxes. 4) remove VAT on export of service and intellectual property to promote non oil exports. 5) increase the threshold for VAT exemption for small businesses. 6) enhance the VAT refund process to reduce the strain on working capital of businesses. 7) introduce VAT fiscalisation and electronic invoicing to curb evasion which currently makes compliant businesses uncompetitive. 8) consequential upward adjustment to the VAT rate on items not exempted to avoid a significant drop in revenue. It is important to note that the above proposals do not represent the position of the government but our committee's proposals which we are still undergoing discussions with the private sector for their input. At the same event, we discussed other proposals to reduce companies income tax rate, increase exemption threshold for personal income tax etc but, of course, those will not make the news.

We need to increase VAT rate, says Taiwo Oyedele

We need to increase VAT rate, says Taiwo Oyedele

thecable.ng

Emmanuel Ishiwu

Chief Accountant at Strides Energy & Maritime Limited

7mo

Taiwo Oyedele, I have always held you to a very high esteem, but you see this recommendation of your committee on tax reforms, the majority are more academic than practical. I say this because they address the theoretical discourse about tax in Nigeria rather than the realities on ground. First, your committee did not recommend any reform in FIRS and the mode of tax collections. The practical reality is that if FIRS should collect 60% of taxes they are mandated to collect by extant laws in Nigeria, we can't be hearing of low revenue or tax--GDP ratio being low. The major problem with tax revenues in Nigeria is collection. If you like, raise VAT rate to 90% with the current tax collection system championed by FIRS, the tax revenue will still be low. Devise means of checking tax evasions by entities & their transactions, develop mechanisms for tracing officials who compromise the system for personal gains. Recommend adequate punitive measures. Increasing tax rates without addressing the laxity and porous system currently obtainable is akin to increasing the burden of the obedient taxpayers, while leaving behind the disobedient ones. Society doesn't grow where defaulters go scot free while those that comply ar made to suffer mor

Johnson Agwu

Fmr Gen Sec of Int'l Law Asso (Nigerian Branch), Dispute Resolution Expert, Business Recovery & Insolvency Practitioner, Administrator, Data Protection, Energy Natural Resources and Environmental Law Expert

7mo

The fact that your committee is only lamenting the situation where some states have imposed consumption taxes other than VAT is disheartening. I think your committee should ask the FG to enforce the law instead of lamentation. Currently, the law is that VAT has covered the field on consumption taxes. Therefore such things as sales tax, etc amounting to double taxation of the same consumption should give way. Second, I have not understood your administration's focus on increasing the number of taxes or their rates or both as you seem to promote. You believe that some so called richer people can foot the bill of Nigeria through taxes while the majority should remain poor and exempted from some taxes. Nigeria's money problem can't be solved that way. (By having the same people bear the ultimate tax burden. They would soon reach their tipping point where Boston Tea Party will be a child's tea party). Importantly, the cause of low revenue is not inadequate number/rate of taxation. It is low number of productive people & inefficient collection. Increase the people's earning power and the tax revenues will also increase. You can actually borrow to stimulate production, rather than borrowing to buy Presidential Yatch.

Linus Chime

Supply Chain Manager | SAP, ERP SCM Implementation and Integration Consultant| Operations Manager

7mo

Generally, this current administration embarks on multiple taxation without first work on the economic stability. The results are blowing everywhere, companies are closing down, inflation rate has hit 33.4%, many people are going to lose their job in the near future. Trying to generate more money from the instability economy is more dangerous to the system than good. The economic team should start working on economic stability, work more on the processes integration to attend equilibrium of demands and supply all round. The cause of increase in inflation rate and fluctuations of Naria to Dollar, is as a result of trying to get more money without first creating an enabling environment for the economy to grow.

Taiwo Oyedele The challenge with taxation in Nigeria is FIRS. They are not digitized, and they work with agents. Those agents are the wealthiest Nigerians. Also, they determine who to target, which is why the poor suffer under them and not the rich. Remove agents, infuse technology, and the tax net will be clean and okay. Also, the tax ratio to GDP will go up to 25%.

Smart Agwu

IT Engineer | Network Automation Engineer

7mo

Mr. Chairman Taiwo Oyedele sir, there are just a few things that I would be happy if you comment on: 1. Nigerians pay about 10 different levies per transaction currently, where do all the money go? 2. Before coming up with that idea to increase VAT, have you worked on increasing the quality of living in Nigeria? Have you checked how many people die daily because of epileptic medical system? 3. How would this VAT increase impact the infrastructural development in Nigeria? 4. Are you people deliberately creating more poverty in Nigeria, making things worse as they were already? 5. Mr. Chairman, are your families living in Nigeria, to experience part of the good work you and this government are going? Thank you sir, looking forward to your answers

Abiodun Omotoso

I'm a fractional FP&A Professional. And I will help you focus on profit making decisions, period! #FP&A #FBP #Commercial Finance #AP #AR #CFO

7mo

People quote what makes the news....even when out of context. No surprises there. Dear Taiwo Oyedele I may not be able to attend any of your review sessions but please take this on for review please: Organizations do their best to comply with the company income tax laws....which is quite a burden sir. But we comply. Recently I read of the Act and was exposed to FRCN charges/fees at about 0.05% of Total revenue. I felt hurt by this. In this case, very hurt, because despite businesses hitting rock bottom losses FRCN doesn't give a hoot.....you must go find their money. If the economy must grow, first we shouldn't be trampling on those already down. And what purpose does this serve the FRCN? Still not able to get answers. Very soon, insurance bodies, engineering bodies, and every body will place a lien on business revenues caring less if businesses break even or not. Please you are the last hope we've got having seen politicians only change coats, still same spirit. Help us!!

Godwin Festus

Data Science & AWS Cloud Graduate | Actively Seeking Entry-Level to Mid-Level Roles in Data Science, Analytics, & Cloud Solutions

7mo

Banks today in Nigeria are the apex predators. They charge electronic transfer levy, stamp duty charge, transaction charge, and the FG just added another one. So we're being charged heavily for transactions. The question is: What are we being charged for exactly?

Daniel Femi

Creative Director of Paintage Interiors® - PMP certificate - Professional painter - Business Owner - ND in Statistics - BSC in Statistics - Interior Designer - Foundr of Creating Knowledge

7mo

I disagree, sir. Why borrow when the money can't be used for infrastructures that can service the loan and pay it back? We all borrow from banks to create better opportunities for ourselves and we service that loan until it is paid back. Why can't Nigeria do the same? All govt agencies & offices should do their work, they are losing value every day due to incompetencies and functionality. People are still struggling to pay the current VAT, you still want to increase it. Find order means to generate funds.

Smile IWEJUA AAT, BSc Hons (Oxford Brookes), A. Dip (ACCA), FCA

Senior Executive Consultant at Strategic Business Partners & Co Limited

7mo

Nigeria is going through multidimensional recessions. In February, you sais about 81% of employment in Nigeria do not add value to the economic system, hence the poverty situation This would mean that about 81% of Nigeria's economy is still on subsistence basis. In other words, Nigerians are 'just hustling anyhow' to survive. So, expansionary fiscal policies have become inevitable to organise the economy and stimulate production / consumption, if the Gov would make positive economic impact. To achieve this, policy strategy need to first be long term, reflecting recovery and expansionary purposes. Quick wins would not help here. Key expansionary policy on which the economy was surviving was the subsidy which was first thing Govt removed for good reasons. So you have real task to actually give fiscal buoyancy to the Nigerian economy, whatever magic it may be. Meanwhile, I think the team has a lot to learn from Chinese policy strategies. Policies to increase gov revenue at any level would not help much now, neither any policy to get more taxes from few surviving businesses. On the other hand, increasing spending, purposeful subsidies, cutting down interests and taxes could help out of the recession. Pls also advice Zacch and FIRS

See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics