Attorney General Jackson Famous 1940 Speech on the Role of the Federal Prosecutor (4/1/24): I have recently written an article featuring Justice Robert
H. Jackson’s contributions to tax law and to administrative law, The Tax
Contribution to Deference and APA § 706 (SSRN 4665227 January 17, 2024), here. I
am a Justice Jackson fan, heavily influenced by his contributions to the
discussion of deference in tax cases and other contributions to tax as IRS Chief
Counsel, Assistant Attorney General for Tax, Solicitor General, Attorney
General, and then as Supreme Court Justice authoring the famous unanimous opinion
in Dobson v. Commissioner, 320 U.S. 489 (1943), here,
reh. den. 321 U.S. 231 (1944), here.
(Note: many citations to Dobson omit the opinion denying rehearing, but the opinion on denial of rehearing is important for understanding Dobson.; one interesting feature of
the opinion on rehearing is that Justice Douglas dissented in the denial of
rehearing without explaining his position (not uncommon for Jackson in tax
cases) but Justice Douglas had not dissented from the original opinion. See *
below)
Justice Jackson did so much more than tax; indeed, his major
contributions to the country were not tax contributions; those major
contributions should not eclipse his tax contributions though.
Today, I received an email from a Jackson scholar, John Q.
Barrett, professor of law at St. John’s University (bio here). The bio
mentions that his emails for his “Jackson List” go to more than 100,000 readers.
In today’s email, Professor Barrett
quotes in full Justice Jackson’s famous speech on April 1, 1940 as Attorney
General titled “The Federal Prosecutor.” Readers of this blog may read the
entire speech on the Jackson Center site, here
(with a link to its original publication in ); and on DOJ site here.
Sprinkled through the speech are some real gems of wisdom about the prosecutor’s role.
I will not “cherry-pick” the best or my favorite quotes because all are good
and are really appreciated best in the full context of the speech. (I do alert
that he does not mention the word “tax” in the speech; perhaps that alert may induce some to read the speech.)
Enjoy!
* On Justice Douglas’
propensity to offer no opinion for his dissents in tax cases, see Bernard
Wolfman, Jonathan L.F. Silver, & Marjorie A. Silver, The Behavior of
Justice Douglas in Federal Tax Cases 122 U. Pa. L. Rev. 235 (1973), later
turned into a book titled Dissent Without Opinion: The Behavior of Justice
Douglas in Federal Tax Cases (1975). http://dlvr.it/T4wSl3 ^ Jack Townsend #federal #tax #crime
Helping law firms and lawyers drive business development through strategic marketing and communications efforts
1moCongrats Mike Wilson! 👏