12 Common Challenges in Conducting Effective Hotel Mystery Audits
Guest Delight International | GDI
World’s #1 hotel quality assurance audit company, GDI elevates brand standards for top hotels and airlines globally
Mystery shopping, also known as secret shopping, is a widely used method to assess the quality of service in various industries, including hospitality. Despite its popularity, mystery shopping faces significant challenges, especially in the context of hotel mystery audits. This blog post explores these challenges and provides insights into more effective alternatives for evaluating customer experience in hotels.
What is Mystery Shopping?
Mystery shopping involves hiring individuals to pose as regular customers to evaluate the quality of service, compliance with regulations, and gather specific information about products and services. The primary goal is to gain insights into the customer experience and identify areas for improvement.
The Origins and Evolution of Mystery Shopping.
Mystery shopping originated in the early 1940s and has since become a $1.5 billion industry, with over a million active mystery shoppers worldwide. Its purpose is to measure employee integrity, customer service, and operational standards. However, despite its long history and widespread use, mystery shopping has several drawbacks that limit its effectiveness, particularly in the hotel industry.
Common Challenges in Hotel Mystery Audits:
1. High Costs - Mystery shopping can be a significant expense for hotels. Each visit from a mystery shopper can cost between $30 and $100. Large-scale programs or monthly visits can strain the budgets of smaller hotels without providing a clear return on investment.
2. Inaccuracy and Bias - Mystery shoppers bring their personal experiences, expectations, and subjective opinions into their evaluations, leading to biased and inaccurate reports. A mystery shopper with preconceived notions about a brand may influence their evaluation, making the data unreliable.
3. Limited Scope - Mystery shopping typically focuses on specific aspects of the customer experience, such as customer service, while ignoring other critical factors like product quality and pricing. This limited scope can result in an incomplete view of the overall service quality in hotels.
4. Poor Data Quality - The effectiveness of mystery shopping heavily depends on the capabilities of the mystery shoppers, who vary significantly. High turnover rates in the industry further exacerbate this issue, leading to inconsistent and unreliable data.
5. Illegitimate Data - Since mystery shoppers are not real customers, their feedback lacks authenticity. They approach the evaluation process with a mindset of finding issues rather than experiencing the service as genuine customers would, leading to a negative bias in their reports.
6. Delayed Feedback - Conducting mystery shopping and compiling reports can take time, resulting in delays in receiving feedback. This lag hampers timely improvements, making the data less relevant and actionable.
Recommended by LinkedIn
7. Employee Stress - The knowledge that they might be evaluated at any time can create stress among hotel employees, leading to decreased job satisfaction and morale. This constant scrutiny can affect their natural behavior, further skewing the evaluation results.
8. Heavy Shopper Training Requirements - Mystery shoppers require thorough training to ensure they know what to look for and how to report findings accurately. However, high turnover rates among shoppers and management increase the costs and efforts required for continuous training.
9. Ethical Concerns - Ethical issues arise from the deceptive nature of mystery shopping. Employees may feel deceived and violated when they learn they were evaluated by a mystery shopper, leading to trust issues within the organization.
10. Potential for Fraud - Fraud risks arise when mystery shoppers and employees conspire or when shoppers submit false reports. Repeated visits by the same shoppers can lead to employees recognizing them and altering their behavior, thereby compromising the authenticity and reliability of the evaluation process.
11. Psychological Impact on Shoppers - Mystery shoppers often face significant stress and pressure to deliver precise and comprehensive evaluations, which can negatively affect their mental health. The need to provide detailed and accurate reports can be daunting and overwhelming for many shoppers, impacting their overall well-being.
12. Legal Risks - Conducting mystery shopping without proper disclosure can lead to legal challenges, especially if it violates labour laws or regulations.
A More Effective Alternative: Real-Time Customer Feedback
Instead of relying on the flawed mystery shopping method, hotels can leverage their real customers to gather authentic feedback. Real-time customer feedback technology captures comments, ratings, and feedback from actual guests using their mobile phones. This approach offers several advantages:
Conclusion: While mystery shopping has been a traditional method for evaluating customer service, it faces significant challenges that limit its effectiveness, especially in the hotel industry. High costs, inaccuracy, bias, and delayed feedback are just a few of the many pitfalls. By leveraging real-time customer feedback technology, hotels can gain more reliable, authentic, and actionable insights to continuously improve their service quality and enhance the overall guest experience.
For more information on how to improve your hotel's customer experience and operational standards, visit www.gdiworldwide.com or email us at info@gdiworldwide.com.