5G Faith & the Automotive Industry

5G Faith & the Automotive Industry

As the automotive industry slowly comes to terms with the implications of 5G connections in cars there are few outside the industry that understand the significance of this technology transition. It isn't just a technology turning point. It is an emotional turning point for the industry as well.

Announcements are beginning to appear from telematics suppliers such as Harman International regarding program wins for 5G hardware - modules and antennas - indicating that 5G is indeed coming to embedded automotive connections. This kind of news arrives even as 5G skeptics express their concerns regarding radiation, wireless network coverage and the need for thousands of micro-cells, and the varying allocation of spectrum around the world.

It's a clear case of ready-or-not, here it comes! For car makers it is a case of deja vu all over again. There lies the rub. Wireless carriers giveth and wireless carriers taketh away.

Wireless carriers brought the automotive industry low speed, analog 2G connections. Years later those analog networks were replaced by incompatible digital systems disconnecting hundreds of thousands of connected vehicles with automatic crash notification applications. It was years before the impacted car companies had resolved the resulting class action law suits in the U.S.

Within the past two years AT&T in the U.S. shut down its 2G network, once again impacting multiple auto makers, many of whom offered their formerly connected customers aftermarket hardware upgrades. The onset of 5G raises the specter of network transitions once again.

The issue boils down to the fact that wireless carriers simply don't understand car companies. Conversely, auto makers tend to hate wireless carriers. One measure of the disconnect between wireless carriers and car companies is the fact that many wireless carriers talk about connected cars as being part of the Internet-of-things (IoT) universe.

IoT in the wireless industry is code for low bandwidth applications - sometimes referred to as M2M - machine-to-machine. The IoT world, though, is dominated and characterized by monitoring or diagnostic systems. Automobiles are on the cusp of becoming some of the highest bandwidth using devices on the planet - with the exception of video streamers.

Connected cars are poised to become quite lively users of wireless connectivity. Few wireless carriers are preparing properly for a world where connected cars are not only the largest source of new device connections - a reality that has existed globally for the past few years - but also some of the most intense consumers of bandwidth. That is the real revolution that is sneaking up - not so slowly - on both the wireless and automotive industries. It is also a reason for the introduction of 5G - existing wireless demand is straining capacity.

The fact that the auto industry and wireless carriers have come together under the auspices of the 5G Automotive Association - a 120-member organization spanning carriers, car companies, infrastructure, semiconductor and hardware providers - to sort out technical issues and standards for 5G implementation is a monumental turn for the industry. But one question remains, even as car makers are suspending their disbelief and committing to 5G: This time around, can the wireless carriers make a truly long-term commitment to this latest network architecture - preserving forward compatibility... indefinitely?

The depth of historical frustration and jaded skepticism among long-time automotive engineers as to the reliability of wireless carrier promises is difficult to plumb. The fact that so many have already taken the plunge and begun baking in their 5G plans with all of the technical challenges yet to be overcome is a testament to their fortitude and faith.

Car makers, with few exceptions, are embracing the 5G revolution. That revolution promises to enable and support autonomous vehicles and new, transformative crash avoidance technology while opening the door to richer infotainment experiences in cars. There is no doubt, though, that the adoption of 5G in the automotive industry is a massive leap of faith with fingers crossed in corporate boardrooms from Munich and Stuttgart to Detroit, Tokyo, Seoul, and Shanghai. Hopefully, the industry will avoid a Charlie Brown moment this time around.

Fabio Nonis

Technical Director | Operations Director | Commercial Director | Technical-Commercial Director | Connected Vehicles & Telematics Specialist

5y
Like
Reply

All of which shows us that for V2X safety applications the auto industry should use DSRC/802.11P.

Ephrem Anthony Chemaly PhD

Product Management / Strategy and Planning / MediaTek

5y

It is not the responsibility of the mobile carriers to keep the 'old' networks running because the car OEMs don't understand modular design. It is clear that most people do not buy a car with an Internal Combustion (IC) engine and decide a few years later to 'upgrade' to an electric engine.  The same is true for the transmission, the car seats, etc.  Therefore the car OEMs expect the car to stay the same for the next 20 years and therefore no need for modular designs.  BUT, it is totally reasonable for people to expect to upgrade their router or their mobile phone every 2-4 years to keep up with the latest technology to meet their needs.  Those two industries - automotive and telecom - are coming together now, and they operate at an order of magnitude difference in speed (2 years vs. 20 year replacement cycle).  We have been trying to convince car OEMs for the last 10 years to create a modular design for the user facing electronics (Infotainment, TCU, etc.) since they need to be replaced every few years and the OEMs and the dealers can make money, if they make it a dealer replaceable option (it doesn't have to be, but it is a reasonable business compromise).  Needless to say, this change is not happening at 'technology' speed and the cars will not become 'high tech devices' (IoT as you called it) unless this is understood and executed upon.

Dan DeClerck

Multi-patented inventor, Wireless Technology, Software and Systems Architect, ADAS, Automotive.

5y

You've got it wrong.. Look around you, even in Michigan, fiber-optic cable is being laid at a prodigious rate. This fiber optic is the backhaul of 5G. Car companies don't understand wireless, and they don't get telecom.. at all.  It took Elon Musk/Tesla to deploy widespread usage analytics, and OTA upgrades, to show how it is done. GM, the first automaker to go wireless in a big way, won't even be there until  (at the earliest) MY20! One single OTA software update for a recall will pay for the cost of the wireless TCU! If a wireless carrier were to publish average throughput and dropped call rates on the built in devices in cars, they would  be many times worse than a low cost $200 smartphone. Why? because the automotive devices are built for the lowest cost, least featured, without regard to experience. The concern is not performance, it's more "checkbox" engineering (Do I have a TCU? "yup, Check"), This is done without regard to how good that TCU is, and how to benchmark it against the phone in the consumer's pocket. For now, the best connectivity performance is still a smartphone with decent bluetooth stack for voice and data connected to the car. Wireless companies get IoT: it's how inventory control works on nearly every vending machine in the USA. It's how rail and shipping companies can predict delivery within a 4 hour window. Wireless companies get IoT, and they're building a better mousetrap with 5G. Bigger fatter bandwidth pipes, or connectivity with sub 5 ms latency (10 times quicker than CAN network latency in the car). The larger question is.. Can Auto companies understand how transformative this can be? or will somebody outside the industry (maybe in mobility? maybe in transport) show them the way, and they have to painfully catch up?  

Thanks Roger for putting this all in historical and emotional context.

To view or add a comment, sign in

More articles by Roger C. Lanctot

  • CES 2025: The Nine Lives of EVs

    CES 2025: The Nine Lives of EVs

    Can it be just nine years ago that wannabe EV maker Faraday Future introduced the FF01 “supercar” on a dark drizzly…

    3 Comments
  • CES Required Reading: "The Nvidia Way"

    CES Required Reading: "The Nvidia Way"

    As you prepare for your CES 2025 experience making appointments and packing sleep aids and pain relievers you might add…

  • Tesla: The Most Recalls with a Catch

    Tesla: The Most Recalls with a Catch

    Nearly 10 years ago, automotive recalls were off the charts thanks to General Motors’ flawed ignition switches and…

    2 Comments
  • An End of Year Reminder to MOVE OVER!

    An End of Year Reminder to MOVE OVER!

    A week ago the Illinois State Police announced their cooperation with and adoption of Haas Alert's Safety Cloud…

    1 Comment
  • The Sounds of Silence - Another Reason to Appreciate EVs

    The Sounds of Silence - Another Reason to Appreciate EVs

    Knowing I would be facing a fitful Christmas repast this evening I decided to take a long walk (i.e.

    6 Comments
  • Lonely iHeartRadio Holiday Launch

    Lonely iHeartRadio Holiday Launch

    I suppose if you're going to launch a new music app there's no time like Christmas when audio consumers are looking for…

  • A Robotaxi Lump of Coal from NHTSA

    A Robotaxi Lump of Coal from NHTSA

    The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration gave the gift of self-certification to the robotaxi industry on the…

  • Overhead: It Ain't Drones & It Ain't Santa

    Overhead: It Ain't Drones & It Ain't Santa

    In the wee hours of Monday, SpaceX sent its Starlink 12-2 mission into space with 21 satellites aboard, 13 of them for…

    4 Comments
  • Content from Space, Trouble on Earth

    Content from Space, Trouble on Earth

    On the eve of CES 2025 it's worth considering the status of content delivery from space. Cord cutters are ironically…

  • Panic in Detroit

    Panic in Detroit

    The only thing crazier than the Consumer Electronics Show in Las Vegas (Jan. 7-10) always scheduled within a few days…

    3 Comments

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics