The AI Content Trap: Why Smart CEOs Never Ask AI to Write (And What They Do Instead)

The AI Content Trap: Why Smart CEOs Never Ask AI to Write (And What They Do Instead)

You’ve probably heard all the AI marketing hype by now.

The promises of automated content creation. The fears of robots taking over marketing departments. And endless debates about whether AI will replace human creativity.

But here’s the truth:

Smart marketing leaders aren’t using AI the way you think.

They’re not asking robots to write their stories. They’re not outsourcing their thinking to algorithms. And they’re definitely not letting ChatGPT run their marketing teams.

Instead, they’re doing something far more intriguing—something that flips the script on AI in marketing.

The "Time Machine" Method: Mining Gold from Conversations

Think about this: every day, your business generates incredible conversations.

Team meetings. Customer calls. Strategy sessions.

These moments are packed with insights that often slip through the cracks.

Here’s what the smartest marketers are doing:

  1. Recording these conversations.
  2. Feeding the transcripts into AI tools.
  3. Extracting actionable insights, content ideas, and social media gems.

It’s like turning an ordinary meeting into a goldmine of value. Imagine: one hour of strategy talk becomes weeks’ worth of authentic, engaging content.

It’s not just smart—it’s transformative.

The "Marketing Coach" Strategy: Finding Your Blind Spots

This approach is genius because it makes AI a partner for deeper insight.

Here’s the setup:

Marketing leaders build a "business brain" for AI by feeding it:

  • Their top-performing sales scripts
  • Rich customer feedback
  • High-performing marketing content
  • Historical campaign metrics

Then, they ask something brilliant:

"Pretend you're my marketing coach who's frustrated because we're missing something obvious. What is it?"

The responses? Often surprisingly insightful.

Why? Because AI excels at pattern recognition in ways our human brains simply can't match. It can spot connections and opportunities we might miss when we're deep in the day-to-day operations of running our businesses.

The "Reverse Engineering" Technique: Learning from Success

This is where the real magic happens.

Instead of asking AI to create something new, savvy marketing leaders are using it to analyse their existing wins.

They're having AI dissect their best-performing content to understand:

  • What specific elements resonated with their audience
  • Which messaging patterns drove the most engagement
  • What unique angles set their content apart

The result?

A content strategy that doesn’t just replicate past success—it amplifies it, building on proven formulas.

The "Brand Voice Library" Strategy: Staying Authentic

Consistency is key in marketing.

That’s why savvy marketers are creating living, breathing brand voice libraries.

Instead of letting their brand voice guidelines gather dust in a forgotten folder, they're turning them into an active AI training tool.

Here's what they're feeding into their brand voice library:

  • Their highest-performing social posts
  • Customer testimonials that perfectly capture their brand's impact
  • Internal communications that nail their company culture
  • Examples of their best email campaigns
  • Phrases and terms that define their unique market position

But here's where it gets really interesting: they're not using this library to replace their writers.

Instead, they're using it to help every team member write more consistently in the brand's voice. It's like having a co-writer who's studied every word your company has ever written.

The "Content Expansion" Framework: Turning Good Ideas into Great Ones

This approach has completely changed how marketing leaders think about content development.

Instead of starting from scratch, marketers use AI as a brainstorming partner.

For every piece of content, they ask:

  • What follow-up questions might their audience have?
  • Which perspectives haven’t we explored?
  • What objections should we address?
  • What real-world examples would strengthen our argument?
  • How can we make this content more actionable?

The result?

Content that's not just comprehensive – it's truly valuable to their audience. It anticipates needs, answers questions, and solves problems.

Your Path Forward

AI in marketing isn’t about replacement—it’s about enhancement.

It’s not about what AI can do. It’s about how you use it to solve real challenges.

Here’s how to get started:

  1. Pick one approach that fits your biggest pain point.
  2. Set up a simple test—like one meeting recording or a successful piece of content.
  3. Measure results.
  4. Share insights with your team.
  5. Iterate and improve.

The goal isn’t to overhaul your marketing overnight. It’s to find sustainable ways to work smarter.

Let’s Keep the Conversation Going

Which of these approaches resonates with your challenges? What insights have you uncovered in your AI journey?

The future of marketing isn’t AI replacing creativity—it’s AI amplifying it.

The question isn’t whether to use AI—it’s how to use it to better serve your goals and your audience.

Let’s explore this future together 🤝

#MarketingInnovation #AIinMarketing #DigitalTransformation #AI

To view or add a comment, sign in

More articles by Margo Mulvihill

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics