AI in Private Datacenter vs. Cloud: Benefits, Costs, and Key Considerations

Benefits of Using AI in a Private Datacenter vs. Cloud Solutions

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has become the most significant catalyst for tech innovation in modern times, driving transformative change across industries. The potential of AI to improve efficiency and drive data-based decision-making is unmatched, providing organizations with a clear competitive edge.  It is no longer a question of “IF” organizations will adopt AI but rather “WHEN” and “HOW.” At the same time, AI requires a significant investment in processing power and storage, and a key decision faced by management is deciding the best deployment environment for their AI solutions. The question typically comes down to deciding on a private data center or a cloud deployment. This decision can have far-reaching implications on cost, efficiency, storage, security, etc. Hence, understanding the differences between each model is essential. This article reviews both deployment models and assesses their pros/cons. 

An Overview Of Private Data Centers Vs. Cloud Models

On-prem / private data centers have been the traditional approach for deploying applications, giving organizations granular control over their infrastructure. Adopting this model allows organizations to tailor their hardware and software environments for AI. This is especially beneficial for organizations in heavily regulated industries regarding where and how they store sensitive data. Due to AI's processing power and storage, private data center deployments may require a significant capital expenditure (CapEx) at the start.

In recent years, cloud computing has become increasingly popular as an alternative to on-prem deployments, allowing organizations to deploy applications at a faster and larger scale. Cloud Providers have various predefined AI services that can be tested and deployed without significant upfront investments by organizations. Unlike on-prem, the cloud operates on a shared responsibility model where obligations over security/control are shared between the organization and the cloud provider. Additionally, while the pay-as-you-go model provides initial cost benefits, data transfer fees, storage, processing, etc., can compound over time and may exceed on-prem costs if not appropriately monitored.

Choosing between these two environments can depend on various factors and practical considerations, which will be discussed in detail in the following section.

Factors To Consider

Along with cost, the choice to go with a Private Datacenter or the Cloud for AI deployment hinges on a multitude of factors, such as:

• Scalability and Performance
• Security and Compliance 
• Flexibility

1 - Scalability and Performance 

AI applications require massive amounts of processing power and storage; hence, performance is a key consideration when choosing the deployment environment. 

• Private Data Centers can give organizations deep control over their AI infrastructure, allowing them to allocate dedicated hardware and appliances for their mission-critical deployments. This ownership over the hardware means organizations can deploy high-performance infrastructure, such as GPUs and TPUs, which provide the computational power needed to train complex AI models efficiently. For instance, in the retail industry, this capability enables the development of sophisticated AI models for demand forecasting, personalized recommendations, and inventory management. Organizations in industries that process massive datasets, such as finance, benefit significantly from the ability to deploy such high-performance infrastructure. Taking retail again as an example, AI models can analyze vast amounts of customer data to predict purchasing trends, optimize stock levels, and improve customer experiences through targeted marketing. Additionally, using private data centers reduces latency between the AI model and applications, providing organizations with faster performance times. This is particularly critical in retail, where real-time data processing can enhance decision-making and operational efficiency. It should be noted that using private data centers may lead to scalability problems in the long run and thus require careful planning and resource allocation. It is easy to under or over-allocate resources for AI applications, resulting in potential wastage. For instance, a retailer might overestimate the hardware required for peak shopping seasons, leading to underutilized resources during off-peak periods, or underestimate it, causing performance bottlenecks during critical times. 
• With cloud deployments, resources for AI applications can be scaled up and down as required, which benefits organizations that cannot predict their AI workload. Cloud providers also come pre-configured with a variety of AI services, enabling organizations to explore various AI use cases without any significant upfront investment. Latency can become a problem when using cloud workloads, especially for applications requiring quick responses from AI models. To mitigate latency issues, edge deployments offer a compelling solution. For example, in a retail environment, edge AI can be used for real-time inventory management. Smart cameras and sensors deployed at store locations can process data locally to monitor stock levels, detect when shelves need restocking, and even predict theft. This localized processing reduces the latency associated with sending data to and from the cloud, allowing for immediate, actionable insights and faster decision-making. While solutions like edge deployments are possible, it is clear that cloud deployments cannot match the speed that on-prem data centers can provide. Edge deployments help bridge this gap by bringing processing power closer to the data source, thus enhancing the performance of AI applications that require quick responses.

2 - Security and Compliance 

Security is one of the foremost considerations when deploying AI solutions, and thus, it must be considered when choosing the deployment environment. 

• Deployments within private data centers allow organizations a high control over their security controls. They can choose the level of depth to which controls can be configured, including network security, architecture, encryption, etc. The most significant advantage of this model is data residency, i.e., data remains within an organization's perimeter, which is a crucial consideration for industries regulated by data protection standards like GDPR or HIPAA. Nonetheless, this does come at the cost of investments in technical and human resources, upgrades, compliance audits, etc., all of which must be managed. 
• Cloud deployments also provide tremendous security benefits with cloud-native services that can be used to provide visibility and control. Cloud providers are also typically compliant with leading industry regulations like ISO, PCI DSS, GDPR, SOC 2, NIS2, DORA, etc., which provide independent assurance of their security posture. Additionally, cloud security operates on a shared responsibility model. While cloud providers are responsible for securing the underlying infrastructure, users must ensure their deployments are configured according to best practices. Any migrations to the cloud also require a clear understanding of data residency, as deploying workloads in non-compliant regions is possible, resulting in regulatory fines and penalties. 

3 - Flexibility 

Another critical element is flexibility and the level of innovation and experimentation a deployment model allows.

• Private data centers allow organizations to customize their infrastructure for AI applications. This can be highly beneficial for companies with complex AI requirements that need specialized hardware/software that cannot be met with preconfigured environments. Examples would be integrations with legacy applications or industrial air-gapped IoT systems. This additional flexibility may come at the cost of additional costs and upfront investments. 
• Cloud deployments often excel at providing flexibility due to the variety of native AI services they offer, such as pre-trained models, pre-configured environments, etc. This allows organizations to innovate faster. It must be kept in mind that these pre-configured services often allow surface-level configuration and cannot be customized at a foundational level for customized requirements. Organizations with unique integration needs and who do not want any form of vendor lock-in may not find the flexibility they need in this model. 

Choosing Between The Models 

Now that we have a good idea of each model's pros and cons, let's review the key factors to consider when choosing between them.

Business Needs and Cost

An organization's deployment strategy must align with its long-term business needs. Is AI investment focused on improving organizational efficiency, streamlining the customer experience, or improving innovation? Once the business needs are clear, it can be quickly decided if a private data center or cloud deployment is suitable. A cost-benefit analysis should also be conducted to compare the upfront CapEX of the on-prem data center with the ongoing OpEX of a cloud model. 

Technical Requirements:

The next step is to focus on which technical requirements are most suited for meeting the business needs. Areas such as processing power, storage, latency, etc., must be assessed in this stage. AI requiring high-speed response may be suited for on-prem, whereas AIs that require rapid scaling will be suited for the cloud. 

Security and Compliance 

The organization must consider its security requirements and the level of control it needs over its data. Heavily regulated industries may find private data centers more suitable, whereas organizations with more lenient requirements can take advantage of the numerous security services offered by the cloud.  A clear decision must be made regarding the level of control an organization will relinquish when proceeding with a cloud model. 

Long Term Requirements 

When assessing the above factors, decision-makers must also assess their long-term roadmaps and how to “future-proof” their AI investments. Factors to consider include planned growth, technology needs, and business requirements. Private data centers can be incrementally upgraded when needed, whereas cloud deployments offer customers the benefit of continuous updates without worrying about the underlying infrastructure.

Adopting a hybrid model that provides the best of both worlds is also possible. Organizations with varying levels of AI workloads may find the cloud more suited for rapid AI innovation while keeping their mission-critical AI systems within the private data center.

The Way Forward 

Choosing between deploying AI within a private data center or the cloud is essential for businesses developing their AI roadmaps. Each model offers unique advantages that must be analyzed and aligned with the organization's long-term business goals. As AI continues to evolve and drive innovation, organizations must remain agile and forward-thinking in their approach to AI deployment. Whether opting for private data centers, cloud solutions, or a hybrid approach, the key is to ensure that the chosen environment supports long-term business objectives and drives value and innovation.

VMware Private AI Generative AI VMware NVIDIA #PrivateAI