Will AI Replace Recruiters?
I love AI, I use it every single day.
It makes me more efficient, it makes me better at my job, but is it coming to take my job completely?
In a word, no.
AI can already filter CVs, source candidates, message candidates, provide shortlists, book interviews, provide feedback, answer candidate and hiring manager questions, it can basically do a large chunk of what a recruiter does each day.
But does it do it well? Will it ever be able to do it as well as a human recruiter?
Well that depends on a few things, the capability of the human recruiter and the types of roles you’re recruiting.
If you’re hiring 40 people to work in a warehouse or a call centre, AI can pretty much do most of the legwork for you and do it well. Some companies have implemented this really well. This frees up the recruiter to focus on partnering with their stakeholders, or working on roles that require a more human touch.
So when we talk about the human touch, what am I talking about?
Let’s start with hiring managers. A lot of hiring managers don’t know what they want, or if they do, they can’t articulate it. A really good recruiter will ask the right questions to understand exactly what the manager needs and wants, sure the hiring manager can throw a Job Description into an AI platform, but we’ve all seen the quality of job descriptions!
Can AI extract the unique selling points of the role from the hiring manager, the real reasons WHY a candidate would leave their current role and join this team? Beyond boilerplate corporate reasons, I don’t see it, this type of insight only really comes from a conversation.
Recommended by LinkedIn
If AI can’t extract those reasons, how can it write highly engaging job adverts or messages that will resonate with the target audience? It’s going to be difficult right?
And whilst we’re on the subject of hiring managers, are we assuming that all hiring managers will self serve? Most won’t self serve with the ATS to raise a requisition or book interviews, are we expecting AI to solve this? Are we expecting that hiring managers hey won’t need conversations with a human about the candidates on the shortlist, about their role or advice throughout the process?
How about candidates? Will AI be able to prepare candidates for their interview? Will it be able to give them some background and insight into the personality of their interviewer?
Deciding to take a new job is a massive deal, it’s not like buying a pair of jeans online that you can return if you decide you don’t like them. Good recruiters have conversations with candidates, help them to decide whether to take an offer or not, answer their questions with empathy.
Are our hiring processes set up right for our target audience and the needs of the business? AI can identify bottle necks, it can probably even tell you how to fix them, but can it influence on a human level to convince the key stakeholders that it needs to change?
For these reasons, plus a fair few others, I don’t see AI completely replacing recruiters.
If you’re a recruiter who simply administers a process, well yes you might be in trouble, AI will be able to take away pretty much all of your job.
But if you’re a good recruiter, AI won’t replace you, it will enable you.
It will enable you to do more of the human elements of the role, to have better conversations and provide solutions to both hiring managers and candidates, but only if you embrace it.
Senior Technology Recruiter @ Hewlett Packard Enterprise | Actively recruiting TOP Talents in Israel, Spain, Greece & Portugal | Headhunter & Sourcing Specialist | EDI Global Board Member @ Women In Tech (WIT)
1wIlaria Russo
Recruitment Sales Manager | Proven Track Record in Maximising Profit Margins
6moFor volume recruitment, AI is doing amazing stuff. Could it replace the role of a recruiter within those sectors? Definitely! Could it replace niche recruitment? Not yet... 😮
Project Manager/Leader I SAP S/4HANA Functional Consultant | Scrum Master I PM, SAP S/4HANA, Scrum Master, ISC2 Cybersecurity Principles Certified I - 15 + years work experience
7moFunny...I'm way more sollicitated when there is more AI involved in the process. Maybe because AI is more factual or doesn't have bias. I've seen Talent acquisition ignoring a candidate despite AI providing all matching points with the job description. AI mastering more the topic than Talent acquisition specialist himself. I see more and more people paid to hire engineers like me, with hostess background and no training whatsoever. Not even able to challenge you with one question, because they just don't understand one word of the JD. Asking question like "you know Agile?...it's written on the JD that you must know Agile" 🙄 More AI...a big yes for me! For efficiency and time saving.
Realtor at Edina Realty
7moA1 will never pull in the correct candidates as HR job descriptions are vague & never updated on a yearly basis. In addition, many viable candidates aren't on social media & it takes a seasoned executive recruiter, like mysy, to find the right match. It might work for low level positions but I gave my doubts. .
Talent Acquisition Lead at Deloitte
8moAi will never replace recruiters as recruiters give a personal touch filled with emotions which only ahuman can understand and not a machine.