Is It Always a Bad Thing to Make a Cultural Mistake?

Is It Always a Bad Thing to Make a Cultural Mistake?

Welcome back to my LinkedIn newsletter where I share tips, ideas, and strategies to help you become more effective in business and life.

If we haven't been acquainted yet, I’m a professor of organizational and cross-cultural psychology, the author of Global Dexterity and Reach, and an HBR contributor and consultant. I also work closely with coaches, trainers, consultants and teachers to certify them in my Global Dexterity Method.

To make sure you don't miss an issue, if you haven't subscribed yet, just click the "Subscribe" button in the upper right corner above.

Be sure you are also signed up for my email list which has completely different content, strategies and offers for you to grow your business, brand, and career. I hope you enjoy today's newsletter!

Academic research – as well as plain common sense – suggests that you generally want to avoid making costly mistakes in a foreign culture. But is this always the case? Can it ever be a good thing to make a cultural mistake? Here are a few potential "hidden" benefits of mistakes in a foreign culture. See if you can think of others.

  1. Mistakes are a tool for learning. We all make mistakes when trying to adapt to the norms of a foreign culture. But we don't need to see mistakes through an exclusively performance-oriented lens. Instead of seeing mistakes as failure, we can look at mistakes as learning opportunities - or even as data for improvement. From this mindset, you might even relish the mistakes you make as opportunities for self-development.
  2. Mistakes can become a source of bonding. An American professional recently told me the story of how when she was working in England, her lack of understanding of the daily English tea ritual became a source of bonding between her and her English colleagues. Because she had a sense of humor about her own ineptitude, and her colleagues had a sense of playfulness and willingness to teach her the “proper” British way, the cultural faux pas became a way for the two sides to become closer rather than to be driven farther apart. 
  3. Mistakes are a source of empathy. So many of us live our lives in our own native culture - not really thinking about the challenges that people face when they land on our shores. But the fact of the matter is that it can be extraordinarily challenging and draining to live life with an imperfect knowledge of language and new cultural norms. So when you have the chance to be a foreigner yourself - use that opportunity to develop empathy. It will make you a more compassionate and empathic host to others.

What do you think? Is it always a bad thing to make a cultural mistake?


Bettina Andresen Guimarães (née Petz)

Helping professionals to read between the lines - intercultural | leadership | presentation | media coaching & training

2y

I don't think that cultural mistakes are always a bad thing, and - let's be realistic - sometimes, we will not be able to avoid them. The secret, as so often, lies in the way we deal with our mishaps. Being defensive will not help. However, as you mentioned in your example, dealing with slip-ups in a humorous way (regarding one's own culture!) is most likely to ease a potentially uncomfortable situation. I very much like your approach of seeing mistakes as a source of empathy when we are on the receiving end of it and your way of reframing them as tools for learning.

Like
Reply
Corinne Wilhelm 🚀 Agility Consultant

Communication Coach & Consultant for Feisty Females in Tech SME | Elevating Diverse Voices in Remote Teams Across Europe 🇪🇺 🎧 Actionable tips 🎙Podcast "Experts! Speak English!" #ICF #CEAC #agile #Toastmasters #D&I

2y

Hi there, do you fancy coming onto my podcast, 'Clever2gether Communication' to share your insights on this. I think that a lot of people are reluctant to do business internationally because they are worried about offending people. I would love to address this in a podcast episode in an interview with you. Feel free to check out the show https://bit.ly/clever2getherPODCAST

To view or add a comment, sign in

More articles by Andy Molinsky

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics