Balancing Gameplay: The Science of Fun

Game balancing is an essential component of game design, ensuring that gameplay is engaging, challenging, and fair. Economy balancing specifically addresses how resources are distributed and utilized within the game, impacting player satisfaction and retention.

The Role of Balancing and Economy

Game balancing involves adjusting the difficulty levels, game mechanics, and player progression to maintain a fair and engaging experience. The economy within a game typically revolves around the management of resources such as currency, items, and player energy, which directly influences gameplay dynamics and player engagement. I personally see the gameplay balancing that includes level difficulty, progression balance, core gameplay set up and economy balance in terms of rewards, stats and unity economy.

As you can see, these elements cannot exist independently. Even if you have great game balancing, it won't work without a proper game economy because gameplay can become boring, especially in multiplayer games. This is due to different player motivations and archetypes, which are influenced by various factors.

Detailed Player Motivations and Design Approach

Designing player experiences is a crucial part of game design. Understanding player archetypes helps tailor the game to different preferences, ensuring a broad appeal and satisfying gameplay for diverse audiences. Here are some common player archetypes and the design techniques and features that cater to each:

1. Achievers

Motivation: Achievers seek to complete tasks, earn rewards, and master the game.

Design Techniques:

- Progression Systems: Levels, ranks, and unlockable content.

- Achievements and Trophies: In-game badges and accomplishments.

- Challenges and Quests: Tasks that require skill and strategy.

- Leaderboards: Public recognition for high scores and achievements.

2. Explorers

Motivation: Explorers enjoy discovering new areas, secrets, and lore.

Design Techniques:

- Open Worlds: Expansive environments with hidden locations.

- Lore and Storytelling: Rich backstories and world-building.

- Collectibles and Secrets: Hidden items and Easter eggs.

- Dynamic Environments: Changing worlds that evolve over time.

3. Socializers

Motivation: Socializers play games to interact with others and build relationships.

Design Techniques:

- Multiplayer Modes: Cooperative and competitive gameplay.

- Guilds and Clans: In-game social groups and communities.

- Communication Tools: Chat systems, voice communication, and emotes.

- Events and Activities: Community events and social activities.

4. Killers

Motivation: Killers seek competition and dominance over others.

Design Techniques:

- PvP (Player vs. Player): Competitive game modes and arenas.

- Ranked Matches: Competitive ranking systems and seasons.

- Combat Mechanics: Deep and strategic combat systems.

- Rewards for Victory: Recognition and rewards for defeating other players.

Practical Examples

World of Warcraft:

- Achievers: Raids, dungeons, and gear progression.

- Explorers: Vast world with hidden quests and lore.

- Socializers: Guilds, in-game events, and social hubs.

- Killers: PvP battlegrounds and arena competitions.

- Immersers: Rich storylines and role-playing opportunities.

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild:

- Achievers: Completing shrines and collecting items.

- Explorers: Open world with hidden secrets and treasures.

- Immersers: Deep lore and engaging story.

Fortnite:

- Achievers: Seasonal challenges and battle pass progression.

- Socializers: In-game events and collaborative play.

- Killers: Competitive battle royale mode.

Understanding these archetypes and designing with them in mind ensures that your game can appeal to a wide audience, keeping different types of players engaged and satisfied.

How to do Balancing in Your Game?

There are several instruments and approaches that will help you prepare and control your game:

1. AERM Matrix: A framework that aligns Actions, Experiences, Rewards, and Motivations to ensure each player action is meaningful and enhances overall gameplay.
2. Dynamic Difficulty Adjustment (DDA): Techniques that adapt game difficulty in real-time based on player performance, ensuring the game remains challenging yet accessible.
3. Game Economy Balancing Tools: Utilizing tools like Excel to model and analyze in-game economies, tracking currency flow, item pricing, and progression curves to maintain economic stability.
4. Playtesting and Feedback Loops: Regular internal and external playtesting sessions, combined with player feedback, to identify and address balance issues iteratively.
5. Telemetry and Analytics: Implementing data collection and analysis to monitor player behavior, performance, and progression, using tools like Google Analytics to inform balancing decisions.
6. Balancing Techniques: Applying game theory, heuristic evaluation, mathematical modeling, and iterative design to continuously refine game mechanics and balance.

Game balancing and creating a robust game economy are critical aspects of game design. Here are some useful instruments, techniques, and approaches you can use:

Practical Tips and Tools

1. Use Templates and Tools

• Excel and Google Sheets: There are templates available online for game balancing and economy modeling. Customize these templates to fit your game's needs.
• Game Design Document (GDD): Maintain a detailed GDD that outlines all aspects of game mechanics, economy, and balance.

2. Simulation Tools

• Use own developed or external platforms for designing and simulating game systems and economies visually.

3. Community and Resources

• There are dozens good resources like: progamedev.net, deconstructoroffun.com, linkedin experts, gamerefinery.com and more online communities and resources for game designers to share insights and tools.

4. Books and Articles:

• "Game Mechanics: Advanced Game Design" by Ernest Adams and Joris Dormans.
• "The Art of Game Design: A Book of Lenses" by Jesse Schell.

5. Spreadsheets

Here are a few examples of spreadsheets you can use

Progression and Experience Points (XP)

Suggestions:

• Gradual Increase in XP: Ensure the increase in XP required per level feels significant but not overwhelming to keep players motivated.
• Meaningful Rewards: Provide meaningful rewards (e.g., abilities, items) that enhance gameplay and are desirable to players.
• Balanced Challenge Ratings: Align challenge ratings with player progression to maintain a steady difficulty curve.

In-Game Currency and Economy

Suggestions:

• Consistent Pricing: Ensure item costs reflect their rarity and effectiveness. Rare items should be more expensive and impactful.
• Acquisition vs. Usage: Balance acquisition rates with usage rates to prevent hoarding or scarcity.
• Player Feedback: Regularly gather player feedback to adjust item effectiveness and pricing.

Currency Flow

Suggestions:

• Balanced Economy: Ensure players can earn enough currency through regular gameplay to afford essential items and upgrades.
• Reward Variety: Offer varied sources of currency to encourage different playstyles and activities.
• Economic Stability: Monitor the net gain/loss to prevent inflation or deflation in the in-game economy.

Player Stats and Balance or level difficulty

Suggestions:

• Stat Progression: Ensure stats increase in a way that reflects player progression and increasing challenges.
• Ability Unlocks: Introduce new abilities at key levels to keep gameplay fresh and exciting.
• Balance Across Levels: Maintain a balance where no single stat or ability becomes overpowered.

Item Drops and Loot Tables

Suggestions:

• Drop Rate Balance: Ensure drop rates are balanced to provide a mix of common and rare items, keeping players engaged.
• Reward Variety: Include a variety of items that cater to different player needs and playstyles.
• Scaling with Difficulty: Adjust drop rates and item rarity based on the difficulty of defeating the enemy.

Quests and Rewards

Suggestions:

• Clear Objectives: Ensure quest objectives are clear and achievable within the context of the game's world.
• Scaling Rewards: Scale rewards appropriately with the difficulty and effort required to complete the quest.
• Variety in Quests: Offer a variety of quest types (e.g., fetch, combat, puzzle) to keep gameplay diverse.

Dynamic Difficulty Adjustment (DDA)

Suggestions:

• Adaptive Challenges: Implement adaptive challenges that can dynamically change based on real-time player performance.
• Fair Rewards: Adjust rewards based on difficulty to incentivize players to tackle harder challenges.
• Player Feedback: Gather player feedback on difficulty levels to fine-tune the DDA system.

Skill Trees and Abilities

Suggestions:

• Clear Progression Path: Ensure skill trees provide a clear and logical progression path.
• Variety of Skills: Offer a mix of offensive, defensive, and utility skills to cater to different playstyles.
• Balanced Costs: Balance the skill point costs to ensure players can make meaningful choices without feeling restricted.

Conclusion

Game balancing and a robust game economy are crucial for maintaining player engagement and satisfaction. By understanding different player archetypes and motivations—such as Achievers, Explorers, Socializers, and Killers—you can design features that cater to diverse playstyles. The specific approaches and tools you use will depend on the genre and type of game you’re working on. Utilizing tools like the AERM matrix, Dynamic Difficulty Adjustment (DDA), and detailed spreadsheets for economy modeling helps in creating a balanced and enjoyable game.

Remember, effective game design is an iterative process that combines player feedback, analytical tools, and a deep understanding of game mechanics. These instruments are just a starting point to guide your work. Keep refining your approach, and your game will offer a compelling experience for all players.

Hope you enjoyed. Subscribe to learn more about business of gaming.

More interesting stories is yet to come!

👾 🕹 🎮Stay tuned 👾 🕹 🎮