Benchmarking Your Supply Chain: Identifying Areas for Improvement

By Rafael A. Vela / Nov 05, 2024

Through my years working in supply chain management across industries, I’ve seen how benchmarking can transform a supply chain. By comparing performance against industry standards or similar companies, you get a clear view of what’s working and where improvement is needed. A well-executed benchmarking process can help identify weak spots, optimize costs, and improve overall efficiency.

Why Benchmarking Matters

Benchmarking is essential because it provides an objective look at your supply chain’s performance. When running a supply chain day-to-day, it’s easy to miss inefficiencies or areas for improvement. Benchmarking removes the guesswork by setting specific standards and metrics for comparison. It allows you to see where your operations stand compared to best-in-class companies and gives you a direction for improvement.

In my experience, companies that benchmark regularly are better positioned to adapt to change, address gaps, and meet customer expectations. It can be a powerful tool for continuous improvement, helping align operations with industry best practices.

Start with Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

To benchmark effectively, you need to focus on the right metrics. KPIs are critical indicators that show the performance of your supply chain processes. The most useful KPIs vary depending on your industry and business model, but some common ones include:

• Order Fulfillment Cycle Time: Measures the time taken from order receipt to delivery. A shorter cycle means quicker deliveries and satisfied customers.
• Inventory Turnover: Shows how often inventory is sold and replaced. High turnover can indicate strong demand, while low turnover may mean overstocking or slow-moving items.
• Perfect Order Rate: Tracks the percentage of orders delivered on time, complete, and without issues. High rates reflect reliability, while low rates highlight room for improvement.
• Cost per Order: Indicates the cost involved in fulfilling each order. Monitoring this helps identify areas where cost savings are possible.

Once you select your KPIs, gather data over a set period to create a baseline. Having reliable data is essential, as accurate benchmarking depends on it. In my experience, even small errors in data collection can lead to misleading conclusions, so this step is crucial.

Compare Against Industry Standards

After you’ve established your baseline, the next step is to compare your performance with industry benchmarks. There are a few sources for this data, including industry associations, third-party research, and consultants. Many times, the information you need can be found in industry reports or specific benchmarking studies.

The aim is not only to see where your supply chain stands but to identify performance gaps. For example, if your order fulfillment cycle is longer than the industry average, you may need to look into factors causing delays, such as bottlenecks in picking or packing, shipping methods, or vendor lead times.

Analyze Internal Processes and Identify Bottlenecks

Benchmarking provides a great opportunity to look closely at internal processes. During my career, I’ve found that even small inefficiencies, like outdated workflows or poorly organized warehouse layouts, can lead to significant delays or cost increases over time. Use your benchmark data to pinpoint specific processes that are lagging behind.

For example, if your inventory turnover is lower than competitors, investigate how inventory is managed. Look for signs of overstocking, excess safety stock, or a lack of demand forecasting accuracy. Understanding the root cause of these issues helps you target improvements and make decisions that drive measurable results.

Engage Your Team in the Benchmarking Process

The people working in your supply chain are often your best resource when benchmarking. They have hands-on experience and can offer insights into why certain processes are falling short. In my experience, engaging the team fosters a culture of continuous improvement and makes it easier to implement changes based on benchmarking results.

Encourage employees to share their perspectives on process challenges and possible solutions. They may suggest improvements in areas like warehouse organization, order picking, or communication with suppliers. This input often uncovers practical, ground-level insights that may not show up in metrics alone.

Evaluate Technology and Automation Opportunities

Technology can play a significant role in improving benchmarked areas. Warehouse Management Systems (WMS), Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems, and automation tools can all help increase efficiency, reduce errors, and lower costs. For instance, implementing a WMS can provide real-time inventory visibility, reducing inaccuracies that can slow down order fulfillment.

In my experience, even modest investments in technology can yield substantial returns. Automated solutions, such as barcode scanning, conveyor systems, or robotic picking, streamline processes and reduce labor costs. Benchmarking can reveal specific areas where technology can bring the most value, helping to build a business case for upgrades.

Monitor Progress and Adjust as Needed

Benchmarking isn’t a one-time activity. To maximize the benefits, it’s essential to track progress regularly and revisit benchmarks over time. After implementing changes, measure performance against your baseline and industry standards to ensure improvement. This ongoing assessment helps confirm that adjustments are working and allows for fine-tuning when necessary.

For example, if you notice improvements in cycle time after changing your order picking process, monitor it for a few months to ensure sustained progress. In my experience, a successful benchmarking process involves continuous monitoring and making further changes as needed.

Final Thoughts

Benchmarking offers a structured way to evaluate your supply chain’s strengths and weaknesses. By focusing on KPIs, comparing with industry standards, engaging your team, and leveraging technology, you can identify and address areas for improvement. Over time, benchmarking helps create a resilient, efficient supply chain that’s aligned with industry best practices and equipped to meet evolving demands.

Ultimately, benchmarking isn’t just about identifying gaps—it’s about building a supply chain that’s agile, competitive, and capable of delivering lasting value.

Did you find this information useful? Want to stay ahead of the game when it comes to all things supply chain?

Join our community and connect with like-minded professionals by

• subscribing to our newsletter
• connecting/following me on LinkedIn
• joining my LinkedIn community, Supply Chain Solutions

By doing so, you'll have access to a wealth of valuable information and resources, including free downloads of publications from our knowledge center plus, you'll have the opportunity to network with industry leaders and stay up to date on the latest trends and developments.

Don't miss out, subscribe now, and share with your colleagues and friends!