Declining GDP, Rising Purchasing Power, and Reversing Monetary Policy: The Curious Case of Japan and Its Carry-Trade Positions
The recent optimism in global stock markets has been driven by the interest rate cuts in the US and China, coupled with the Chinese government's broader stimulus measures* directly aimed at reviving their stock markets. Major Chinese stock indices surged by ~20% in the past week, reflecting the market's confidence in these reforms. However, amidst this global euphoria, a significant development in Japan warrants close attention.
Japan is witnessing a change in leadership, with a new prime minister taking the helm who favors raising interest rates. This stance presents a stark contrast to the current global trend, where most economies, including India, are entering an interest rate downcycle. Japan, on the other hand, appears poised to reverse its prolonged period of ultra-low interest rates. The NIFTY 50 is down 1.4% at the time of this writing, while the Japanese Nikkei index is down by almost 5% in just one session, perhaps signaling early anxieties about this policy shift.
This paradoxical divergence can be attributed to Japanese investors preferring to invest in external economies rather than in domestic enterprises
Declining GDP, Rising Purchasing Power: Japan's Economic Paradox
For over a decade, Japan has maintained near-zero interest rates, with the current rate standing at a mere 0.25%. This unconventional monetary policy was adopted to stimulate economic growth and combat deflation. However, it has led to an interesting economic phenomenon: while Japan's GDP has declined considerably in this period, from $6.2 trillion in 2012 to just $4.2 trillion in 2023, its per-capita GNI (PPP-adjusted) has risen significantly from $38,000 in 2012 to $52,000 at present. This paradoxical divergence can be attributed to Japanese investors preferring to invest in external economies rather than in domestic enterprises, contrary to the original intention of reducing interest rates to stimulate domestic growth. This trend is partly due to the country's aging and declining population, which has dropped from 128 million in 2008 to about 124 million at present.
The new Japanese leadership is particularly concerned about the declining morale of the younger population and the weakening yen. They hope to address these issues through a tighter monetary policy, aiming to cut down the availability of cheap capital for external lending. Coupled with other domestic growth-oriented reforms, their new strategy aims to revive Japan's GDP growth from hereon.
Recommended by LinkedIn
As of June 2024, Japan's NIIP stood at an impressive $3.83 trillion. More tellingly, Japan's external equity assets totaled $5.3 trillion
Carry Trade Unwinding and Global Market Impact
A key development to note for international markets is the potential unwinding of Japanese carry trade positions. These positions involve investors borrowing in low-interest currencies (like the yen) to invest in higher-yielding assets elsewhere. The unwinding of these positions could potentially disrupt global stock markets. While the exact size of Japan's current carry trade positions is debated, we can gain insights from Japan's Net International Investment Position (NIIP) report, which shows the difference between a country's external financial assets and foreign-owned domestic assets.
As of June 2024, Japan's NIIP stood at an impressive $3.83 trillion. More tellingly, Japan's external equity assets totaled $5.3 trillion, comprising $2.2 trillion in direct investments, $2.3 trillion in portfolio investments, $0.25 trillion in other equities, and $0.5 trillion in financial derivatives. These figures underscore the significant global footprint of Japanese investments.
While the current bullish case for global stock markets is underpinned by interest rate cuts, government stimulus measures, and low oil prices, this potential shift in Japan's monetary policy presents a considerable bearish factor. For instance, a 20% unwinding in equity carry trade positions could potentially erase more than $1 trillion from global market capitalization.