Determining Fault for Left Turn Accidents in Massachusetts

Left-turn accidents are among the most common types of collisions at intersections, especially in Massachusetts, where the busy roads and frequent intersections add to the complexity of maneuvering left turns. In many cases, the driver making the left turn is presumed to be at fault. However, fault is not always straightforward, and understanding the nuances of left-turn accident liability is essential for drivers, insurers, and personal injury attorneys alike. This article examines how fault is determined in left-turn accidents in Massachusetts, the legal standards that apply, and important considerations for building a strong case.

Understanding Left-Turn Accidents and Fault Presumptions

Left-turn accidents often occur because the driver making the turn is crossing oncoming traffic lanes. This maneuver requires them to judge the speed and distance of approaching vehicles accurately and to ensure the intersection is clear. When accidents occur during this maneuver, fault is typically assigned to the left-turning driver. This presumption is based on the following factors:

• Duty to Yield: Massachusetts law requires that drivers making a left turn yield the right of way to oncoming traffic.
• Crossing Traffic Lanes: The left-turning driver must cross the path of other vehicles, which increases the likelihood of collisions if they misjudge distances or fail to yield.

While these points establish a general presumption of fault, exceptions exist that may shift partial or total fault to the other driver.

Key Factors Affecting Fault Determination in Left-Turn Accidents

1. Traffic Signals and SignsMassachusetts law dictates that traffic signals and signs must be obeyed at all times. If a left-turning driver has a green arrow, they are legally entitled to proceed, and oncoming traffic must yield. However, if the turn is made on a standard green light without a designated arrow, the driver must yield to oncoming vehicles.Fault can be affected if the oncoming driver disregarded a red light, which would then shift responsibility away from the left-turning driver.
2. Speeding and Reckless Driving by the Other DriverOncoming drivers who are speeding may have a significant impact on fault determination. If the oncoming vehicle was traveling at an excessive speed, this could impair the left-turning driver’s ability to judge the distance accurately, potentially shifting part of the blame to the speeding driver.In Massachusetts, evidence of speeding or reckless driving, such as skid marks or witness testimonies, can be used to contest fault.
3. Distracted DrivingBoth parties’ attention to the road is another factor. If the left-turning driver or the oncoming driver was distracted, such as by texting or talking on the phone, this behavior may be used to determine comparative negligence.Massachusetts has banned texting and driving, and this evidence could be instrumental in cases where distracted driving contributed to the accident.
4. Road and Weather ConditionsAdverse road conditions, such as rain, snow, or poorly maintained streets, can affect stopping times and visibility. For example, if the road was slick and the left-turning driver could not judge oncoming traffic accurately, or if the oncoming driver lost control due to poor weather, these factors can play a role in assigning fault.Massachusetts courts consider these factors, particularly when weather may have prevented a reasonable reaction time.

Comparative Fault in Massachusetts

Massachusetts follows a modified comparative fault rule, meaning that a plaintiff can only recover damages if they are found to be less than 51% responsible for the accident. If a left-turn accident results in a personal injury claim, the court will examine the role each party played in causing the accident. Here’s how comparative fault may impact the case:

• Partial Fault by the Left-Turning Driver: If the left-turning driver is found to be 30% responsible due to misjudgment but the oncoming driver is 70% at fault for speeding, the left-turning driver can still recover damages, reduced by their share of fault.
• Fault Split Evenly (50/50): If both drivers are found equally responsible, the left-turning driver can still recover, but their compensation will be reduced by 50%.

Comparative fault encourages fair compensation by holding each party accountable according to their role in the accident, allowing plaintiffs in Massachusetts to pursue damages even if they are partially at fault.

Steps to Take After a Left-Turn Accident

In Massachusetts, documenting the accident properly can strengthen your case, especially if fault is disputed. Here are critical steps to follow:

• Collect Evidence: Take photos of the accident scene, including traffic signs, road conditions, and vehicle damage.
• Obtain Witness Statements: Witnesses can provide objective accounts of the accident, which can help support claims regarding speed, signals, and driver behavior.
• Seek Medical Attention: Documentation of injuries not only ensures your health is addressed but also serves as evidence in potential injury claims.
• Contact Your Insurance Provider: Reporting the accident promptly to your insurer ensures that claims processing starts without delay.

Legal Considerations for Left-Turn Accidents in Massachusetts

Massachusetts operates under a no-fault insurance system for car accidents. This means that minor injuries are generally covered by each driver’s personal injury protection (PIP) coverage, regardless of fault. However, if injuries surpass certain thresholds—such as significant disfigurement, fracture, or medical bills exceeding $2,000—a personal injury lawsuit may be filed. In cases involving serious injuries, determining fault becomes paramount, as a favorable fault determination may lead to higher compensation through an at-fault driver’s liability coverage.

When to Consult a Personal Injury Attorney

Left-turn accidents can be legally complex, especially when factors like speeding, distraction, or weather contribute to the accident. Consulting an experienced car accident attorney can help victims:

• Assess the strength of their case and potential compensation.
• Gather necessary evidence, including traffic camera footage, police reports, and accident reconstruction.
• Negotiate effectively with insurance companies or pursue litigation if necessary.

Conclusion

Fault in left-turn accidents in Massachusetts is often attributed to the driver making the turn, but multiple factors can influence liability. By understanding how comparative fault works, drivers and accident victims can better navigate their options for compensation. Following the steps outlined above, consulting a personal injury attorney, and understanding the legal framework can help individuals involved in left-turn accidents protect their rights and seek fair compensation.

Need Legal Help? Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law is One Phone Call Away

Navigating Massachusetts Car Accident Claims can be challenging. Fortunately, you don't need to do it alone. The experienced Car Accident Lawyers at Brandon J. Broderick, Attorney at Law, are available 24/7 to help you understand your legal options, gather necessary evidence, and build a strong case to secure the settlement you deserve.

Contact us now for a free legal review.