Difference about Silicon Carbide (SiC) and Ferro Silicon (FeSi) used as deoxidizers in steelmaking and foundry applications

Silicon Carbide (SiC) and Ferro Silicon (FeSi) are both commonly used as deoxidizers in steelmaking and foundry applications, but they differ in terms of composition, functionality, cost, and application specifics. Here's a comparison:

1. Composition

• Silicon Carbide (SiC):
• Contains 70-99% silicon carbide (SiC), depending on grade.
• Composed of silicon (Si) and carbon (C).
• Provides dual functionality as a deoxidizer (Si) and carbon source (C).
• Ferro Silicon (FeSi):
• Contains silicon (Si) (typically 65-75%) and iron (Fe).
• Used solely as a source of silicon for deoxidizing purposes.

2. Deoxidizing Efficiency

• Silicon Carbide (SiC):
• Reacts with oxygen in molten steel to form silicon dioxide (SiO₂) and carbon monoxide (CO).
• Both silicon and carbon in SiC participate in the deoxidizing process, which enhances its efficiency: SiC+O2→SiO2+COSiC + O₂ → SiO₂ + COSiC+O2→SiO2+CO
• Provides additional heat to the process since the reaction is highly exothermic.
• Ferro Silicon (FeSi):
• Reacts with oxygen to form silicon dioxide (SiO₂): Si+O2→SiO2Si + O₂ → SiO₂Si+O2→SiO2
• Deoxidation is limited to silicon and does not add carbon. It is less exothermic compared to SiC.

3. Heat Contribution

• Silicon Carbide (SiC):
• Releases significant heat during the reaction, which helps maintain or increase the molten steel's temperature. This is particularly useful in energy-intensive steelmaking processes.
• Ferro Silicon (FeSi):
• Does not contribute significant heat, as its reaction is less exothermic. Additional energy may be required to maintain the steel's temperature.

4. Cost Efficiency

• Silicon Carbide (SiC):
• More cost-effective as it performs dual roles: deoxidizer (Si) and carbon additive (C).
• Ideal for applications where both silicon and carbon adjustments are needed.
• Ferro Silicon (FeSi):
• Slightly more expensive than SiC due to its high silicon content and limited functionality (only deoxidation).
• Better suited for applications where precise silicon control is required without adding carbon.

5. Impact on Steel Composition

• Silicon Carbide (SiC):
• Adds both silicon (Si) and carbon (C) to the steel.
• Suitable for producing high-carbon steels or when carbon content adjustments are needed during deoxidation.
• Ferro Silicon (FeSi):
• Adds only silicon (Si) to the steel.
• Preferred for steels where low or controlled carbon levels are required (e.g., low-carbon or alloy steels).

6. Slag Volume

• Silicon Carbide (SiC):
• Produces less slag during deoxidation compared to FeSi. This helps reduce waste and simplifies slag removal.
• Ferro Silicon (FeSi):
• Can produce more slag due to its reaction products, which can increase process inefficiencies.

7. Applications

• Silicon Carbide (SiC):
• Used in electric arc furnaces (EAF), induction furnaces, and foundries.
• Common in the production of high-carbon steel, cast iron, and in energy-efficient steelmaking processes.
• Ferro Silicon (FeSi):
• Widely used in basic oxygen furnaces (BOF) and ladle refining for silicon deoxidation without impacting carbon levels.
• Ideal for low-carbon steels, stainless steel, and alloy steel production.

8. Environmental and Operational Impact

• Silicon Carbide (SiC):
• Due to its heat contribution, SiC reduces the energy required during steelmaking, resulting in a more energy-efficient process.
• Produces lower volumes of slag.
• Ferro Silicon (FeSi):
• Requires more energy input to maintain steel temperature due to its less exothermic reaction.
• Can increase slag volume, which may require additional processing.

• The choice between silicon carbide and ferro silicon as a deoxidizer depends on the specific requirements of the steelmaking process. If both silicon and carbon additions are needed, SiC is a more cost-effective and efficient choice. However, for applications requiring precise control of silicon without increasing carbon levels, FeSi is preferred.
• To learn more about our hashtag#siliconcarbide and other ferro alloys, please comment below or email me at lisa@ferrosialloy.com. You can also reach me on Whatsapp at 8618624885692hashtag#chengganghashtag#metallurgyhashtag#steelmakinghashtaghashtag#Deoxidizerhashtag#metallurgicalhashtag#siliconcarbide