Do you want a promotion? Are you sure?

It’s Monday and that can only mean one thing.  It’s time to share!!  Ok, it can mean other things, but at one point, you will need to turn on the heat and stop layering sweaters.

Given my lack of proper mic, I won’t be publishing this in audio format this week but keep your subscription to the podcasts as I will be back in a few weeks. In the meantime, enjoy the written word! 

In the past, the path to professional success, or our perception of it, was straightforward: climb the corporate ladder and get promotions. Becoming the big cheese was synonymous with fulfillment, prestige, and accomplishment. Today, however, a notable shift is occurring in how employees define success and fulfillment. Modern workplace trends suggest that many workers no longer equate career satisfaction solely with promotions. Bridgman, Cummings, and Ballard’s study (2019) says that striving for the top might actually be detrimental to one's creative existence. What is your view?  Do you want to get promotions or is there other things that motivate you more?  Personally, my perspective shifted several times in my career.  I wanted promotions in the past and got several, but realized through time that not all steps up were a step up for my mental and physical health, nor my happiness and creativity.  I loved getting the experiences and learned from them, which I am grateful for. Is that success?

How is the definition of success changing?  Workplace research shows that many employees now prioritize work-life balance, personal well-being, and meaningful work over traditional markers of success. A 2023 study by Deloitte found that younger generations, including Millennials and Gen Z, place a strong emphasis on purpose, flexibility, and overall job satisfaction rather than just job titles or pay scales.  I can also confirm that thought pattern is not limited to younger people.  Many of the olds, this guy included, have adopted the YOLO approach to life, taking time to enjoy opportunities for travel and work breaks while we are still in good shape and able to take on more physical adventures, like cross-country road trips, mountain hikes, zip-lining and exploring deserts. This shift underscores that fulfillment does not necessarily align with higher positions and more dinero but with roles that support autonomy, creativity, and balance.

The research also highlights the importance of intrinsic motivation (That comes from inside). Self-Determination Theory (Deci & Ryan, 2000) explains that human motivation is deeply rooted in the need for autonomy, competence, and relatedness, or as Dan Pink put it Mastery, Autonomy and Purpose. When individuals feel pressured to climb the corporate ladder without these needs being met, their motivation and well-being may suffer. It is not uncommon for employees to experience "career fatigue," where the continuous pursuit of higher roles leads to stress, decreased creativity, and burnout, especially when the loyalty of corporations to their employees seems to have left the building entirely. 

The connection between creativity and workplace hierarchy is complicated, like my relationship to sugary treats (I am diabetic, but really love cake). Studies have shown that creativity often flourishes in environments where individuals feel a sense of psychological safety and freedom. In contrast, higher-level positions often come with increased responsibilities, bureaucracy, and reduced opportunities for creative expression. Research by Amabile and Pratt (2016) indicates that while senior roles may offer more influence, they often limit an individual's ability to engage in spontaneous, exploratory work due to the constraints of decision-making and administrative duties.

The pursuit of promotions can also hinder personal growth if individuals become overly focused on external rewards at the expense of their intrinsic interests. In such cases, the competitive nature of striving for top positions can stifle creativity and reduce job satisfaction. This  argument aligns with findings from the Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, which noted that employees who value creative freedom and self-expression are often more fulfilled when they are not tethered (handcuffed?) to relentless pursuit of career advancement.

The expansion of remote work has amplified the desire for roles that align with personal values and flexibility. Remote work has shifted the focus from traditional, promotion-driven paths to more nuanced understandings of job satisfaction. We also know that employees who work remotely or in hybrid roles are more likely to value flexibility and the ability to work on projects that inspire them over climbing the organizational hierarchy.

This shift emphasizes that fulfillment can stem from work that aligns with a person’s lifestyle and goals, whether that involves taking on challenging projects, collaborating across teams, or pursuing lifelong learning. Through the pandemic, remote work encouraged many employees to redefine their relationship with work, valuing flexibility and impact over hierarchical status.

How can we motivate staff if not with promotions and cold, hard cash?  Managers play a big role in fostering an environment where employees can find motivation without relying on traditional career paths. To engage and inspire teams, managers can focus on several key strategies:

-          Recognition and Appreciation: Employees often feel motivated when their work is recognized, not through promotions but meaningful feedback and appreciation. Public acknowledgement of achievements, awards, or simple verbal recognition, the proverbial pat on the back can strengthen motivation and job satisfaction.

-          Opportunities for Growth: Providing opportunities for continuous learning, skill development, and project-based roles can fulfill employees' desires for growth without a promotion. Learning new skills can drive motivation and creativity.

-          Flexible Career Paths: Organizations that offer lateral career moves and encourage cross-functional projects let employees explore different areas of interest. This can provide diverse experiences that enrich their careers and make their work more rewarding, not to mention build relationships across departments that will inevitably help with work in many ways.

-          Empowering Autonomy: Allowing employees to take ownership of their projects and contribute ideas can enhance their sense of autonomy. This autonomy supports a work environment where employees feel trusted and valued, leading to higher satisfaction and creative output, as well as reduce the perceived need for boss surveillance. 

-          Wellness Programs: Given the growing emphasis on mental health, teams can support well-being by promoting wellness programs, flexible working hours, and mindfulness practices. These can reduce stress and help employees maintain a balanced approach to work.

What does this mean for our organizational strategy? Organizations that recognize the evolving nature of work and adapt their strategies accordingly can benefit from a more engaged and innovative workforce. According to a 2023 report from the World Economic Forum, companies that invest in employee well-being, flexible career development, and inclusive work cultures are more likely to attract and retain top talent. This shifts the focus from hierarchical achievements to a holistic view of what makes work meaningful. 

Companies should also reconsider performance metrics and reward structures that align with diverse employee values. Instead of solely rewarding promotions and tenure, recognition can be expanded to include contributions to team culture, innovation, and mentorship.  Of course, I would also like more companies to stop doing yearly evaluations and move to more real-time methods that actually have a positive impact.  I address this in other articles though, so we’ll stay out of that rabbit hole for now.

Overall, pushing to reach the top may bring a short burst of pride for some but not always fulfillment. The changing nature of work has prompted many to seek alternative ways to find meaning and satisfaction in their professional lives. Leaders and organizations that understand this shift can motivate their teams by prioritizing creativity, well-being, and personalized growth opportunities. By valuing balance and purpose, employees can thrive as creative, engaged members of the workforce without feeling compelled to climb the traditional corporate ladder to “get ahead”.

Have a fantastic week ahead and take some time to think about what getting ahead means to you and how things could be changed to better line up with that. And share it with your friends and colleagues, because People Power Everything.

John

PS: If you like these, feel free to forward and encourage your friends, family, neighbours, colleagues, leaders, staff, and even mortal enemies to sign up to THE LIST and subscribe to the People Power Everything Podcast which has bonus material from time to time.