Election Betting Update and its Impact on Markets.

Election Betting Update and its Impact on Markets.

Trump’s betting:

Average of all betting markets (black)

The three largest betting markets

Polymarket (blue)

Predictit (orange)

Kalshi (green).

Effectively, they all have the same results and trends.



Are these markets trading at the wrong level (suggesting manipulation)? I would still argue no.

Real Clear Politics aggregates polls using a simple moving average.

For the first time since August 4, Trump leads in NATIONAL polling.


For the first time in the three elections that Trump has been the Republican nominee, he leads the NATIONAL polling (red).


Election modelers aggregate data points, such as polls, money raised, economic statistics, etc., to calculate a candidate’s probability of winning.

Silver Bulletin is probably the best-known member of this group.

Trump (orange) leads over Harris (blue).


Silver is not the only one with an election model.

Below are the probabilities that Trump will win for arguably the three most popular models:

Silver Bulletin (blue)

FiveThirtyEight (green)

Economist Magazine (red).


Betting markets show Trump winning in the low 60s, whereas the modelers have him in the low 50s.

We would argue that betting markets reflect all known information, which the modelers do, and anticipate upcoming information.

Since Trump is in an uptrend in every chart shown above, it is reasonable that the betting markets would be trading with a Trump premium versus the models. They expect his gains to continue.

How does it impact markets?

Arguably, the most significant impact is on the bond market. The higher Trump betting goes, the higher 10-year yields go.

Trump will stimulate growth (cutting taxes and regulation) and potentially create more inflation (tariffs).


The Republican Wins basket of stocks is vastly outperforming the Democrat Wins basket of stocks (explained on the chart).


An obvious election play


And another election play, although this relationship might be "fraying" in recent days.



Richard S.

Investment Adviser

2mo

Normally, Mr. Bianco’s analyses of the marketplace are insightful and spot on. However, I have to disagree this time with his conclusion that the political betting websites reflect all the currently available information and are not manipulated when it comes to the race for President. I strongly believe that the Trump advocates are either misinformed about Trump’s chances or attempting to make it look like Trump is stronger than he actually is. Today’s ABC/Ipsos poll has Harris with a 4-point lead (51-47) Nationally. And I strongly suspect that Trump bettors have failed to appreciate the elevated potential of “crossover” votes from Republican registered women who will be casting their votes for Harris. My latest blog column at www.SuttonWatch.net has a more detailed analysis of the current situation and it’s impact on the financial markets.

To view or add a comment, sign in

More articles by James Bianco

  • The New Inflation Cycle

    The New Inflation Cycle

    When the Fed was HIKING (red) in 2022 and 2023, inflation expectations went DOWN and stayed down. Inflation…

    5 Comments
  • Inflation's Impact on Financial Assets

    Inflation's Impact on Financial Assets

    A common belief is that risk assets are effective inflation hedges. History suggests they are not.

    27 Comments
  • The Fed Is Getting Close To Thin Ice

    The Fed Is Getting Close To Thin Ice

    The Wall Street Journal reporter Nick Timiraos had a very good story yesterday. https://www.

    9 Comments
  • Yields and Yield Curves

    Yields and Yield Curves

    The 30-year yield made a new 2024 close high yesterday. Now, the highest yield since November 2023.

    9 Comments
  • What is TLT Signaling?

    What is TLT Signaling?

    TLT is the iShares 20-year Treasury ETF, one of today's largest and most influential bond ETFs. I've been arguing that…

    32 Comments
  • Why Did Long Rate Rise?

    Why Did Long Rate Rise?

    Since September, the Fed cut rates 100 bps, but 10-year yields rose ~100 bps. Why did this happen? The market is…

    11 Comments
  • Why does the Fed/Powell have a credibility problem?

    Why does the Fed/Powell have a credibility problem?

    Consider these passages from his November and December pressers (our emphasis). ------ At the Fed’s November 7 presser,…

    12 Comments
  • Will 2025 Investing Be About Seven Stocks Again?

    Will 2025 Investing Be About Seven Stocks Again?

    The Mag 7 is back to being over one-third of the S&P 500. These seven stocks have accounted for ~52% of the S&P 500…

    6 Comments
  • Momentum vs Valuation, 2025's Dilemma

    Momentum vs Valuation, 2025's Dilemma

    This study says the 60/40 portfolio is dead. Everyone should now be 100% invested in stocks.

    6 Comments
  • Latest Market Probabilities On Fed Moves

    Latest Market Probabilities On Fed Moves

    The Market is pricing a 99% probability of a rate cut next week. 19% probability of a rate cut at the next FOMC meeting…

    2 Comments

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics