The Faux-Bubble
Before you go on and keep saying Egypt is on the cusp of a real estate bubble read this.
Egypt is not your average country, it does not follow the norms of real estate that the rest of the world is bound by. I have been personally working in real estate for over the past 10 years, and my family has been in the real estate business since the early 1990s. Through out all this time, Egypt has always went against the grain when the world did not.
• In the 2008 financial crisis Egypt’s real estate was unaffected
• Through out the Dubai 2010 crisis Egypt’s real estate was not affected, maybe event benefited.
• Through out the 2011 revolution, the 2013 revolution, and the many instabilities that Egypt has been through in the past 8 years, the Egyptian Real Estate has thrived.
• Even when the EGP devalued to half of its former value, Real Estate in Egypt was still selling and increasing in value more than ever before.
Most crisis don’t affect the market, since unlike Dubai and other international markets, Egyptian real estate is backed by Egyptians, so money does NOT fly out of the country the minute there is trouble. Now Im sure you already have an anti-argument planned to respond to each and everyone of those, but there are on ground factors that are the cause of this challenging phenomenon. First of all you need to look at the culture, the culture is 60% illiterate and and have a problem with trusting banks with less 20% of the population that have accounts*.
1 This gives rise to the informal economy, where people see banks as evil, and hammers the first factor where Egyptians use real estate as banks. It is the place they keep their cash safe, not as an investment, but safe.
2 Another cultural factor is marriage. In a male dominated culture it is traditionally required for the male to have an owned home in order to be eligible to get married, which leads us into the second factor, males are required to purchase real estate to get married.
3 This also leads more wealthy families to try and help their children by purchasing their real estate for them early on, and more culturally affluent families purchase homes for both males and females, as a safety net for them, when they need to get married/divorced. Now of course if they do not happen to get married, they can always rent out this home to create a second revenue stream for their lives until its time. Once this was realised, Egyptians almost always bank on the option to rent real estate as a second source of income. Which brings us to Factor number three, its is a recurring revenue source for all Egyptians, which becomes a sort of fall back options if work becomes tight or challenging.
4 This brings us to currency value, throughout time, in Egypt between inflation, devaluation, gas prices, subsidy removal, the EGP hasn’t been the most stable currency in the market, which has made the real estate investment more of the “gold standard” in Egypt, being the fourth factor where the price/sqm has become what people invest in to maintain value of their money. Now with all this real estate purchase in the past century and the jumps in prices over time, in certain areas, people are always trying to be savvy by predicting the expensive real estate market jumps and this is where investment comes in.
5 The fifth and possibly most important factor is that depending on location, Egyptians have made returns of over 1000% in under 10 years, and chasing that investment gold mine has always been the tradition with the previous four factors acting as the safety net, there can be no bad investment, just an OK one, which will end up maintaining the cash value or booming a recurring revenue stream.
Now there is a huge jump in supply, however, this has still not satisfied the demand. Most of the people cannot realise that the purchasing power is constantly moving. And while now it is no longer with the aristocratic upper class, hence the panic. Most of the purchasing power has now moved to government families and Army families, and everyone who was involved in working or benefiting from real estate in the past 5-30 years (between contractors, suppliers, manufacturers, etc). Of course it is also worthy to note the selling power has also shifted to be more government led than in the past few decades, and again that is not the bubble but merely a shift of balance and powers.
I guess what I am trying to say is, Egypt has gets a bit sluggish every 10 years or so, but the market shifts accordingly, every industry has its saturation point, and the real estate market in Egypt is no different, but it will still be some time before this market levels out and demand and supply will lead to a more stable price/sqm, however, Egypt has yet to even start introducing mortgages and until then expect prices to keep soaring.
But then again, I'm always open to different opinions, change my mind...
CTO, Kaf Insurance
5yGreat post Tamer! I completely agree with you that we won't be facing a bubble as simply from all the reports I reach more that 80% of real estate transactions happen in cash and not installments or mortgage. I have a few points that I would love to discuss them with you. You mentioned the buying power is growing as our population grows and we won't reach a point of over supply and accordingly stagnation. I think the main market gap now is that there's significant supply of luxury housing while there's definitely under supply of the medium income housing. Basically if I am a guy who makes 10-20k a month in salary there are almost no options for me to buy a property. What's your take on this discrepancy and how can we bridge this gap especially with the medium income housing (finished units costing 500k - 1 million). Also what's your take on Mortgage and how can it play a role in the future?