Has Elon Musk Lost His Magic?

Elon Musk has long been viewed as one of the most audacious innovators of the 21st century. The serial entrepreneur behind Tesla, SpaceX, and more recently X (formerly Twitter), Musk has built a career out of pushing boundaries, upending industries, and creating some of the most ambitious projects of our time. His ability to take enormous risks and execute seemingly impossible ideas has led to widespread fascination, earning him a reputation as a transformative figure in the world of technology.

Yet, in recent years, Musk’s near-mythical status as a visionary has been tested. A series of high-profile controversies, missed deadlines, and strategic missteps have led some to question whether his magic is fading. The much-hyped “We Robot” event, in which Musk promised significant breakthroughs in Tesla’s autonomous driving technology, left many underwhelmed and reignited concerns about his tendency to overpromise and underdeliver. Meanwhile, challenges around Tesla’s RoboCab—a driverless electric taxi concept—raise doubts about whether Musk can successfully navigate the regulatory and technological hurdles that lie ahead.

As the competitive landscape in both electric vehicles (EVs) and autonomous driving heats up, with traditional automakers and startups alike making significant strides, the question arises: has Musk lost the edge that made him a tech icon, or is this merely another chapter in his unpredictable career?

Elon Musk's Ascendance

Elon Musk’s rise to prominence began in the late 1990s with successful ventures like Zip2 and X.com, the latter of which became PayPal after a merger. When PayPal was sold to eBay for $1.5 billion in 2002, Musk used his newfound wealth to pursue even more ambitious projects.

Tesla, which Musk joined in 2004 as chairman and later CEO, became the crown jewel of his empire. The company redefined the electric vehicle market, turning once-niche technology into a mainstream, desirable product. Despite early challenges, including manufacturing bottlenecks and skepticism from industry insiders, Tesla became the world’s most valuable automaker by the early 2020s, symbolizing Musk’s ability to defy conventional wisdom and succeed against the odds.

SpaceX, founded in 2002, reinforced Musk’s status as a disruptor. The aerospace company achieved several notable milestones, from launching reusable rockets to partnering with NASA for manned space missions. Its goal of making space travel affordable and accessible further cemented Musk’s reputation as a forward-thinking innovator capable of transforming multiple industries.

But success has not come without turbulence. While Musk has seen numerous victories, his career has also been punctuated by controversy and significant setbacks.

Signs of Strain: Overpromising and Controversy

As Musk’s enterprises grew, so did his propensity to set audacious goals—often to the point of overpromising. One of the most prominent examples came during Tesla’s so-called "production hell" period from 2017 to 2018. Musk had set aggressive targets for the production of the Tesla Model 3, an affordable electric car aimed at the mass market. What followed was a period of missed deadlines, operational chaos, and questions about whether Tesla could meet its lofty ambitions.

Although the Model 3 eventually became a success, the episode revealed cracks in Musk’s management style and his tendency to set targets that were difficult, if not impossible, to meet. This pattern would repeat itself in other aspects of Tesla’s business, including its much-touted autonomous driving technology, which has been delayed for years.

At the same time, Musk’s behavior became increasingly erratic. In 2018, Musk shocked investors by tweeting that he was considering taking Tesla private at $420 per share, claiming that funding had been "secured." The tweet triggered a Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) investigation, ultimately leading to Musk stepping down as Tesla’s chairman, though he retained his role as CEO.

Musk’s frequent use of Twitter to engage in public spats, controversial statements, and market-moving comments became a growing source of concern for investors and the public alike. While some saw Musk’s unconventional style as a reflection of his unorthodox genius, others viewed it as reckless, especially for the CEO of a publicly traded company.

The "We Robot" Letdown and RoboCab’s Regulatory Challenges

The most recent blow to Musk’s reputation came with the "We Robot" event, which had been billed as a major milestone in Tesla’s pursuit of autonomous driving. However, the event failed to deliver on the massive expectations that Musk had set. The unveiling of the RoboCab—a driverless electric taxi—raised more questions than it answered, particularly around its compliance with U.S. vehicle safety laws and the overall viability of Tesla’s autonomous driving technology.

Tesla’s current system, known as Autopilot, is classified as a Level 2 driver assistance system, which means it requires constant human supervision. Achieving Level 4 autonomy, where the vehicle can drive itself without human intervention under certain conditions, is a far greater challenge. Despite years of development, Tesla has yet to demonstrate that its autonomous systems can operate safely without human oversight. Compounding the issue, Tesla is under federal investigation for a series of fatal crashes involving Autopilot, raising significant safety concerns.

For Tesla to commercialize Level 4 autonomous driving, it would need to clear major regulatory hurdles. California, one of Tesla’s key markets, has some of the strictest regulations in the country for testing and deploying autonomous vehicles. In other states, Tesla would still need to show that its vehicles can perform basic safety functions, such as pulling over safely in the event of a malfunction.

Moreover, the RoboCab’s lack of steering wheels or pedals puts it out of compliance with federal vehicle safety laws. Tesla is not the first company to encounter this issue; General Motors’ Cruise division faced similar roadblocks with its robotaxi, the Origin, and ultimately shelved the project after failing to gain approval from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Unless Tesla can find a way to navigate these regulatory hurdles, its RoboCab concept may never come to fruition.

The Twitter Saga: A Self-Inflicted Distraction?

Musk’s decision to acquire Twitter in 2022 also raised eyebrows. Initially hesitant, Musk ultimately completed the $44 billion purchase, citing concerns about free speech and content moderation. However, his management of the platform—now rebranded as X—has been chaotic and polarizing.

Immediately after taking control, Musk laid off much of Twitter’s workforce, including key executives, and overhauled the company’s content moderation policies. His decision to replace Twitter’s legacy verification system with a paid subscription model led to widespread confusion, impersonations, and a temporary surge in misinformation on the platform. Many advertisers, concerned about the platform’s direction, pulled their ad dollars, resulting in a significant drop in revenue.

Musk’s hands-on management style at Twitter has also raised concerns that he is distracted from his other responsibilities, particularly at Tesla and SpaceX. Tesla investors have expressed frustration with Musk’s focus on Twitter, fearing that it could detract from his leadership of the electric vehicle company at a time when competition in the EV market is heating up.

Rising Competition in EVs and Autonomous Driving

Tesla’s early dominance in the electric vehicle market is now facing increasing pressure from both legacy automakers and newer players. Companies like Ford, General Motors, and Volkswagen have all ramped up their production of electric vehicles, while Chinese automaker BYD has surpassed Tesla in global EV sales.

In the autonomous driving space, Tesla’s reliance on camera-based systems for self-driving has been met with skepticism from experts who believe lidar—a laser-based system used by competitors like Waymo and Cruise—is essential for the safe operation of autonomous vehicles. Waymo, a subsidiary of Alphabet, and GM’s Cruise have both made significant advances in autonomous driving, with Waymo already operating a commercial robotaxi service in select U.S. cities.

The growing competition, combined with Tesla’s regulatory and technical challenges, suggests that the company’s lead in autonomous driving is not as secure as it once seemed.

A Tarnished Legacy or a Temporary Setback?

So, has Elon Musk lost his touch? The answer is not straightforward. Musk has proven time and again that he can bounce back from adversity and turn ambitious ideas into reality. Tesla remains the most valuable automaker in the world, and SpaceX continues to make breakthroughs in space exploration, particularly with its Starship program.

However, Musk’s recent controversies, regulatory challenges, and competition are testing his leadership in ways that he hasn’t faced before. His acquisition of Twitter has introduced an element of unpredictability that could further strain his reputation and distract him from the companies that made him a household name.

Musk’s legacy as a transformational figure in technology is secure, but his recent setbacks suggest that he is not immune to the pitfalls of overreach. Whether he can regain his footing and continue to lead his companies into the future remains to be seen. What is clear is that Musk’s ability to navigate the challenges ahead will determine whether his magic is truly fading—or simply evolving.

Elon Musk’s journey from tech entrepreneur to cultural icon has been defined by bold visions and groundbreaking achievements. Yet, as his businesses face increasing challenges, from regulatory hurdles in autonomous driving to intensifying competition in electric vehicles, and as his leadership at Twitter continues to raise questions, Musk’s future appears more uncertain than ever.

While it is premature to write off Musk’s ability to innovate and disrupt, the mounting evidence suggests that his once-untouchable reputation is showing signs of wear. Whether this marks a turning point in his career or just another hurdle remains the critical question.

Ahmed Banafa's books

Covering: AI, IoT, Blockchain and Quantum Computing