"It is not heroes that make history, but history that makes heroes."

"It is not heroes that make history, but history that makes heroes."

Stephen Kotkin'sKotkin's Stalin: Paradoxes of Power, 1878–1928, is the first volume in a projected three-part biography of one of the most notorious figures of the 20th Century. Kotkin, a distinguished historian, presents a meticulously researched and fascinating account of Joseph Stalin's early life, rise to power, and consolidation of authority by 1928. The work stands out for its depth and the broader historical context in which Stalin's story is situated, making it more than just a biography.

The book spans Stalin's early years in Georgia, his path to revolutionary Marxism, and his role in the Bolshevik revolution, focusing heavily on his political manoeuvrings within the Communist Party. How did a cobbler's son who was not even ethnic Russian become one of the most influential figures of the 20th Century? A man who joked that WW II was fought with American money and machines and Russian soldiers. The Soviet Union had a mind-boggling 27 million soldiers killed in action and many more wounded, all under the mercurial leadership of Stalin. The German army, by far the most efficient of all belligerents, was simply overwhelmed by numbers and resources. Stalin was ruthless in his wartime strategies, willing to sacrifice millions to protect the state and secure victory. His ability to marshal resources and rally the Soviet people, despite early catastrophic losses, was crucial for defeating Hitler. He famously said that the death of one man is a tragedy; the death of millions is a statistic.

Stalin's policies, particularly his Five-Year Plans, played a pivotal role in transforming the Soviet Union from a largely agrarian society into a significant industrial power. Under Stalin's leadership, the Soviet Union underwent rapid industrialisation in the 1930s, which enabled it to produce the machinery, steel, and infrastructure needed for a modern economy.

Stalin is a controversial figure and a ruthless one at that. What worked for him were clarity of mind and an ability to stay adaptable. Everything and everyone was expedient. He comes across as a man with no scruples or values and a questionable personal legacy. He created a super power though.

Arvind Keshav Giri

Independent Consultant (Fertilizers/Chemicals/Supply-Chain Mgmt.) I Professor of Practice (MBA/BBA) I Certified Corporate Director I Philanthropy

2mo

Whether its Stalin, Hitler, Mussolini, or Castro - one thing one cannot deny. These dictators may have brought their respective countries to catastrophic consequences, but they had a leadership quality (call it Charisma) to rally an entire nation behind them. And most important, it's their respective ideology which penetrated most of their population. It's for history to judge them.

Prof. Shankar H.N

IT Strategy, Management Consulting, Training and Development - Independent Consultant

2mo

Interesting perspective.

Like
Reply
Ravi Kumar

Senior Sales Professional

2mo

Absolutely true.

Like
Reply

To view or add a comment, sign in

More articles by Capt. A. Nagaraj Subbarao, PhD

  • An Officer & A Gentleman!

    An Officer & A Gentleman!

    The first engagement between the Indian and Pakistani Air Forces occurred at Boyna, off Kolkata, in November 1971…

    10 Comments
  • The Leader - Leader Equation!

    The Leader - Leader Equation!

    Leadership must be the most enigmatic area under consideration. One area of leadership that should be discussed is…

    6 Comments
  • Treason of the Intellectual!

    Treason of the Intellectual!

    If something like the QS Rankings for Higher Education existed in the 20th Century, you would have found many of the…

    10 Comments
  • Are the Tailwinds Gone?

    Are the Tailwinds Gone?

    China, an economic miracle of the modern age, is experiencing headwinds. An indicator is the country's skewed…

    6 Comments
  • The Vision vs. Values Conundrum!

    The Vision vs. Values Conundrum!

    The "Vision vs. Values" conundrum reflects a common tension in organisations between pursuing long-term goals (vision)…

    5 Comments
  • Monitoring Behaviour: A Leadership Trait

    Monitoring Behaviour: A Leadership Trait

    The United States of America sometimes struggles with their history. In my many travels across that country, denizens…

    2 Comments
  • The Realm of the Uncivilised!

    The Realm of the Uncivilised!

    A few days ago, I spent almost a day at a plantation in New Orleans, USA. The experience made me wonder at humanity's…

    6 Comments
  • Starbucks: The Coffee Leader

    Starbucks: The Coffee Leader

    As an educator, I had the privilege of teaching a case study on Starbucks in my MBA class. This academic interest was…

    3 Comments
  • Industry Leadership: The People Way

    Industry Leadership: The People Way

    "The best way to predict the future is to create it." (This quote is often associated with Google's innovative culture…

    9 Comments
  • Leadership The Lincoln Way!

    Leadership The Lincoln Way!

    “Give me six hours to chop down a tree and I will spend the first four sharpening the axe.” When one thinks about…

    2 Comments

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics