Immigration doesn't create bad planning. Bad planning creates bad planning.

This week Prime Minister Scott Morrison set out some important markers on his approach to managing population growth.

In his speech the PM delivered both a spirited defence of the economic benefits of population growth and a message that he had heard public concerns about the fast pace of change in our cities. The resulting headlines were all about immigration cuts and a slow-down in population growth, but it is important to unpick the detail of what he actually said.

Fundamentally, the PM has now made three announcements.

First, there will be a new process for setting immigration levels, the biggest driver of population growth. This will be a ‘bottom up’ process involving the states and territories, that will consider the infrastructure base of various cities, their ‘carrying capacity’ and those leaders' views about population growth. COAG will meet on 12 December to begin this process.

Second, this process will be used to set an annual ‘cap’ for Australia’s migration program, a decision that will still be made by the Federal Government. While the current cap is 190,000 people, for the last two years the migration program has been running at around 160,000. When asked whether the cap might be brought down to current actual levels, the PM said that “it wouldn’t surprise me if any process we went through arrived at that sort of territory”.

Third, the Government had previously announced a targeted measure to encourage new independent migrant visa holders to locate outside of Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane.

So for all the headlines, this could amount to minimal change to our immigration numbers. Certainly it's unlikely to amount to imminent big cuts which would undoubtedly hit employment and the economy hard.

The Property Council has urged the PM not to let the states off the hook when it comes to planning and infrastructure. It’s not the size of a city that is so important, it’s how well they’ve planned for the future. And, as a recent Fairfax-Ipsos poll found, 52 per cent of those surveyed were in favour of keeping or increasing the current level of immigration.

Population growth will remain an Australian reality and one that is most keenly felt in our larger cities. Planning for growth in all our cities – big and small – remains a core task of governments.

After all, immigration doesn’t create bad planning. Bad planning creates bad planning.

Alan Mackinlay

Retired Sessional Lecturer in Highway Engineering at Victoria University

6y

No planning is even worse!

Gary Inberg OAM

Property Strategy / Independent Chair / Project Control Group

6y

Lack of direction and indecision doesn't help either.

John Few

Linking China and Australia | Property, Renewable Energy and more | Freelance Writer

6y

Spot on. It is a failure in planning an Infrastructure.

Rahul Nawle

Sustainability Consultant (Architecture & Urban Design)

6y

Migration is inevitable, but how to be prepared for the same and channelize it is what is more important. 

To view or add a comment, sign in

More articles by Ken Morrison

  • Getting down to business

    Getting down to business

    Property Australia, 22 May 2019 The federal election has been run and won, and we congratulate Prime Minister Scott…

  • The serious work is about to begin

    The serious work is about to begin

    Property Australia, 15 May 2019 When the final ballot is cast and the last democracy sausage has been sizzled this…

  • Connecting the dots on housing

    Connecting the dots on housing

    There was always going to be especially keen interest in the RBA’s decision on interest rates during the last couple of…

    1 Comment
  • A year of activity and achievement

    A year of activity and achievement

    As we wind down for the Christmas and New Year period it’s a great opportunity to take a moment to reflect on the year…

    4 Comments
  • Our diversity journey

    Our diversity journey

    The property industry has been on a journey over recent years. Spurred on by the actions of the Property Male Champions…

    3 Comments
  • A sense of purpose and activity

    A sense of purpose and activity

    Victorian voters have delivered their electoral judgement and emphatically returned the Andrews Labor Government for…

    1 Comment
  • Powerful people magnets

    Powerful people magnets

    For a country that has been built on growth, some of Australia’s political leaders seem to be increasingly ambivalent…

  • Population brings prosperity

    Population brings prosperity

    In less than three weeks the citizens of our fastest growing state will head to the polls. With more than 12,000 people…

  • Property policy changes will hit everyday Aussies where they live

    Property policy changes will hit everyday Aussies where they live

    [my opinion piece published in The Daily Telegraph, 7 November 2018] PROPERTY investors are mostly everyday…

  • The great divide

    The great divide

    What comes first: the people or the transport? It’s the perennial planning debate for policy makers and the industry…

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics