The intelligent automation journey: my 13 key challenges
Today’s need for intelligent automation is real and is not going away.
It is undeniable that the intelligent automation market is going through a rapid development and we, human workers, are somehow much more inclined to coexist with virtual workers. From automation that just “execute” to automation that “think” and “learn”, the intelligent automation ecosystem is growing at fast pace and in an orchestrated manner.
The quest for more intelligent automation will be a promising and rewarding journey but without any doubt a challenging one. Here are my 13 "macro" challenges:
- Given that intelligent automation is perceived as the next wave of innovation for most organisations, there will be a race between business areas to be the "first one" to evaluate and pilot these new operating models and technologies. Without a macro view of on-going departmental initiatives, organisations will run the risk of internal cannibalisation and the consequences of that situation could be quite damaging. It is quite crucial to ensure that all initiatives are aligned toward a common vision and the net aggregated outcome is presented in a unified way.
- Getting the right intelligent automation strategy enabled by 1) a balanced mix of technology enablers, 2) supported by a well-defined service delivery framework and last but not least 3) governed by an effective operating model will require proper design thinking. Will intelligent automation be deployed to serve specific tactical requirements of each business area or will it be used to holistically and gradually transform the workforce environment across the organisation? Should organisations put intelligent automation at the centre of their overall digital strategy, acting as a key enabler for front and back office transformation?
- Solving the initial automation silo challenge should be a priority. Defining automation principles and derived standards across the organisation will be required in order to ensure maintainability and interoperability of automation. Failure to enforce automation principles since the beginning will drastically limit the organisation's ability to scale and be resilient. To achieve this, commitment and support from senior leadership is a must-have (clear "Tone at Top").
- Significant ongoing co-investment between organisations and strategic service providers for defining and aligning the intelligent automation strategy will be the norm. Money will be spent on trial and error experiments, determining how to scale up the pilot and recalibrating the target operating model. Selecting and prioritizing the right projects for maximum ROI (and finding the required budget) will not be an easy task.
- “ You don’t reward reaction, you reward results” (Edwin Louis Cole). And results are measured through the realisation of expected benefits. Measuring benefit realisation from your intelligent automation initiative will certainly not be an easy task, especially when dealing with intangible benefits. Benefits will not be realised at the same time and organisations need to consider the "speed of onset" of each and every benefit in their overall benefit realisation plan.
- In many cases, optimal automation will require major process adaptation. Even if the change is minimal, the transition to automation will require change management. The key question here is how much will it actually cost to adapt or transform processes in order to enable automation? Is the organisation actually ready, financially and emotionally, to undertake a new "automation-enabled" transformation? Overcoming resistance to automation and managing the change will require planning, discipline, and effective communication. Don’t underestimate the operational fatigue that has been built up during the long and tedious IT-enabled business transformation years.
- Initial strategies for scale will face execution obstacles that can potentially slow down mass adoption. From a business perspective, deployment of intelligent automation at process levels will not consistently realise expected benefits. A wide range of processes and activities are and will continue to be highly unstructured and therefore resistant to automation. From an IT perspective, will IT functions feel that intelligent automation is another burdensome project that will stretch resources and create additional maintenance and support activities? Dependencies with other ongoing IT and business transformation programme or termination date of existing outsourcing contracts will also create an initial bottleneck that can block your aspirational plan.
- Ongoing reliability challenges will create business fatigue in the organisation. Reliability is an important determinant of human use of automation because of its influence on human trust. Lack of reliability could simply totally undermine the benefits of your intelligent automation programme. Hence ensuring high reliability will be one of the most critical focus when applying intelligent automation.
- Resilience and adaptability are key in order to sustain changes to the internal and external contexts. A wide range of factors, ranging from ongoing changes to technology, process, data and customer behaviors, will directly impact the effectiveness of the intelligent automation environment. The deployment of a continuous monitoring system coupled with a flexible human-bot collaborative control must be an integral part of the overall intelligent automation framework in order to allow fast recovery when automation fails.
- It is not a surprise that risk and compliance oversight functions will spend non negligible time and effort during initial years to perform a wide range of “baseline” assurance activities in order to ensure that the intelligent automation environment (people, process and technology) is reliable. What about robots running critical financial activities or accessing/ processing sensitive HR information? What about the auditability of complex machine learning algorithms that are used to take more and more complex and autonomous decisions? How auditors will be able to evaluate the effectiveness of these algorithms knowing that still many machine learning systems have a low interpretability? A lot of scrutiny will be applied and let's be honest here, this situation will inevitably end up costing money to all organisations.
- The tricky question of resource reallocation mechanisms needs to be addressed in a holistic and procedural manner. Training future employees and re-training current ones will be a significant challenge. How the resource reallocation process will be executed and who will pay for it? How employees will be incentivised to actually learn new skills in addition to their day to day activities? Will it be easy to reallocate resources to another function/ process by just “augmenting” skills? Will it be easy to convert an accounting clerk into a virtual agent calibrator or a data insight curator?
- In addition to key drivers such as increased productivity, reallocation of resources to more value-added activities or better customer service, cost reduction will remain a key driver for investing in intelligent automation. There is no doubt that reducing operational costs will be a quick and easy win. But will it be as simple for organisations to deploy intelligent automation in order to ultimately create business value and boost agility?
- There will be non-negligible security concerns regarding the risk of the entire intelligent automation environment being vulnerable to data manipulation. Now that intelligent automation is actually increasing the level of digitisation and networking, how to ensure that the environment is reliable, secured and cannot be tampered by unauthorised activities? Appropriate management of non-human privileged access across the enterprise will certainly not be an option. Cost related to security administration and monitoring must be factored in initial projects and subsequent BAU budgets.
I hope you enjoyed the reading and I would be very interested in hearing your thoughts. If you want to read more about automation, please connect of follow me.
Opinions expressed are solely my own and do not necessarily express the views or opinions of my employer.
Head of Sales North America - Automotive
3yWell said. The biggest ones based on my experience is Change Management and ROI Realism. Technology related ( referring to your dog's balancing act 🙂) and most importantly behavioral change management. When it comes to automation, disappointment can set in quicker than any other transformation if the expectations on ROI and realization strategy is not calibrated. Thoughts?
HFS Research Executive Research Leader | Generative AI & Automation | Web3 | Metaverse | HFS Generative Enterprise & Ecosystem
3yThe smart thing to do is make the journey you describe a process toward OneOffice - supported by Native Automation!
Executive Research Leader and Head of EMEA at HFS Research
3yBang on the money, Ralph! We urgently need broader discussions on this to cut through all the noise.
Building Supervity AI ✨🚀
3yInsightful Ralph. If I can broadly categorize - many of these challenges are humane/change related which can only be fixed with top down approach, planning and communication. Rest - I believe tech is catching up as automation gets democratized like email and collaboration tools today.
RPA Lead |Scrum Master |Agile Coach
3yThis is an awsome post, it reflects exactly all the check points, that someone has to expect when decide to be part of an innovation path. Thanks Ralph Aboujaoude Diaz for sharing!