Let Them Wear Wigs: The Great Simulation Reset

Healthcare simulation was supposed to make learning easier and engaging for student nurses. Somewhere along the way, we've transformed what is an innovative teaching methodology into a source of stress for educators and students.

Healthcare education is a serious matter, but do our teaching methods have to be?

It's time for the great simulation reset.

How We Got Here

Twenty years ago, simulation in healthcare education promised a revolution: hands-on learning that would accelerate competency acquisition while keeping students engaged and excited. Fast forward to today, and we've created a monster. Simulated experiences have become complex, expectations higher, and approach sometimes rigid.

We load our simulation programs with:

• Elaborate scenarios requiring extensive prep work
• Complex debriefing frameworks
• Multiple learning objectives per session
• High-stakes performance expectations
• Strict adherence to realism
• Detailed evaluation rubrics

The result? Overwhelmed faculty, intimidated students, and a learning environment that's become more stressful than supportive.

Nursing students are already navigating an intensive curriculum. When simulation becomes another source of anxiety rather than a safe space for learning, we've lost the way. Novice simulationists, dealing with their own pressures to "get it right," may inadvertently create environments where students feel vulnerable and judged rather than supported and encouraged.

The Great Simulation Reset

What if we let student nurses mess up every single simulation scenario in Year 1? What if we encouraged them to laugh when they forget steps or get techniques wrong? What if we didn't mind them trying on manikin wigs during downtime?

When students are relaxed and enjoying themselves, they're more likely to retain information and develop confidence in their skills. Research shows that positive emotions enhance memory formation and cognitive processing. This means that learning doesn't have to be somber to be effective.

Implementation Strategies for a Lighter Approach

Start with Clear Messaging

• Explicitly tell students that mistakes are not just okay, but expected and welcomed
• Share stories of your own clinical blunders and learning moments
• Make it clear that simulation is a playground for learning, not a stage for perfection

Restructure Your Scenarios

• Limit objectives to one or two key points per session
• Build in moments of levity
• Include "plot twists" that naturally lead to mistakes and learning opportunities
• Allow time for experimentation and "what if" scenarios.

Transform Debriefing

• Start with sharing funny moments from the scenario
• Celebrate creative mistakes and unusual approaches
• Use humor to reinforce key learning points
• Create a "blooper reel" atmosphere where errors become valuable teaching moments

Adjust Faculty Development

• Train simulationists in facilitating playful learning
• Practice using humor appropriately in teaching
• Develop comfort with "controlled chaos"
• Focus on creating psychological safety through lighthearted approaches

Measure Different Outcomes

• Track student enjoyment and stress levels
• Monitor willingness to volunteer for scenarios
• Assess comfort with making and discussing mistakes
• Evaluate long-term retention of skills learned through playful simulation

Small Steps to Start Tomorrow

1. Add a "silly scenario" day where outlandish situations are presented
2. Institute a "best mistake of the day" award
3. Create a photo wall of students and faculty wearing manikin wigs
4. Develop scenario cards with intentionally impossible solutions
5. End each session with students sharing their "favorite fail"

Reconciling Joy and Rigor in Healthcare Simulation

But what about the practical challenges of maintaining advocacy for joyful learning?

Regulatory bodies now allow 25-50% substitution of clinical hours with simulation.

Should we maximize this allowance just because we can?

The Dual Nature of Simulation-Based Healthcare Education

Healthcare simulation now serves two distinct purposes:

1. Clinical hour replacement requiring stringent documentation and assessment
2. Supplementary learning experiences focused on skill development and confidence building

The key to successful simulation programs lies not in choosing between these approaches, but in deliberately separating and designing for both.

Why Maximum Substitution Isn't Always Optimal

Several challenges make maximum clinical hour replacement problematic:

Resource Constraints

• High-fidelity simulation requires substantial financial investment
• Many programs lack adequate numbers of trained simulation specialists
• Physical space and equipment limitations
• Time required for proper scenario development and validation

Faculty Preparedness Gaps

Pedagogical Expertise

• Clinical expertise doesn't automatically translate to simulation expertise
• Limited training in debriefing methodologies
• Variable comfort with technology

Workload Management

• Documentation burden for clinical replacement hours
• Scenario development time
• Validation requirements
• Assessment standardization

Quality Assurance Challenges

• Maintaining consistent experiences across multiple groups
• Ensuring objective evaluation
• Meeting accreditation requirements
• Documenting competency achievement

A Proposed Two-Track Solution

Rather than treating all simulation hours as potential clinical replacements, consider a bifurcated approach:

Track 1: Clinical Replacement Simulations (15-20% of clinical hours)

• Rigorous documentation
• Standardized scenarios
• Formal evaluation
• Multiple validated objectives
• Led by specially trained faculty
• Focused on complex clinical decision-making

Track 2: Developmental Simulations (Unlimited supplementary hours)

• Playful and experimental
• Single-objective focused
• Emphasis on psychological safety
• Room for mistakes and humor
• Led by regular clinical faculty
• Focused on skill building and confidence

Implementation Strategy

Audit Current Resources

• Faculty simulation expertise
• Available technology
• Support staff
• Physical space
• Documentation systems

Set Realistic Goals

• Calculate sustainable clinical replacement hours
• Identify gaps in faculty preparation
• Assess technology needs
• Determine documentation capacity

Develop Clear Criteria

• Which experiences qualify for clinical replacement
• Required documentation standards
• Faculty qualifications for each track
• Student evaluation methods

Create Faculty Development Plans

• Simulation pedagogy training
• Technology competency building
• Debriefing skill development
• Documentation requirements

Making It Work: Practical Tips

Start Small

• Begin with 15% clinical replacement
• Gradually increase based on capacity
• Maintain quality over quantity

Build Faculty Capacity

• Identify simulation champions
• Create mentorship programs
• Provide protected time for development

Document Smartly

• Use templates for clinical replacement hours
• Streamline evaluation tools
• Leverage technology for efficiency

Maintain Balance

• Keep developmental simulations light and playful
• Reserve complex scenarios for clinical replacement
• Allow faculty to grow into advanced roles

Clinical Replacement Simulations Versus Developmental Experiences

By consciously separating clinical replacement simulations from developmental experiences, you can maintain both rigor and joy in simulation programs.

Remember:

• Not every simulation needs to replace clinical hours
• Quality matters more than quantity
• Faculty development is crucial
• Student experience should remain central
• Balance is key to sustainable programs

The future of healthcare simulation lies not in maximizing clinical hour replacement, but in optimizing the learning experience for both students and faculty. Use the regulatory allowance wisely while preserving the engaging, experimental nature of developmental simulation experiences.

The Sound Of Better Learning

Healthcare education is a serious matter, but our teaching methods don't have to be. When we create an environment where mistakes are celebrated, laughter is encouraged, and learning feels like play, we prepare better practitioners.

The goal isn't to create perfect nurses on day one. It's to nurture competent, confident professionals who can learn from their mistakes and maintain their sense of joy in the process.

Your students' laughter might just be the sound of better learning happening.

Repost this article

Subscribe to the Healthcare Simulation Post for content that helps you create content.

Follow HEALTHCARE SIMULATION MIDDLE EAST to be notified.