A Major Obstacle to Economic Growth: Policymakers’ Failure to Divert Investment into Real Businesses
One of the most significant barriers to economic growth in Pakistan is that our policymakers have not been able to channel investment into productive sectors that drive sustainable economic development. Instead, we see investment flowing heavily into sectors like real estate, commodities, and banking instruments, which have limited long-term impacts on economic growth. Looking at other countries can illustrate how investing in productive sectors can transform economies and benefit society.
Capital Shifts into Real Estate and Commodities
In Pakistan, real estate and commodities dominate investment interest, which is counterproductive to economic expansion. Real estate is lucrative, but when unchecked, it can create housing shortages and limit affordable housing options. For example, Dubai and many cities in China witnessed rapid growth in real estate prices due to high investor interest, which eventually led to high property prices that became unaffordable for locals. This trend also diverted capital from industries that could generate employment and innovation.
Similarly, investment in commodities can drive up prices and create inflationary pressures. In Pakistan, the focus on commodities has led to high prices for essential items, impacting the general population’s purchasing power. Countries like Brazil have also faced this issue, where excessive investment in commodities like sugar and coffee sometimes leads to inflation and price instability in local markets.
The Drift Toward Banking Instruments
The banking sector provides various investment instruments like deposit schemes, securities, and bonds. In Pakistan, these instruments attract investors looking for low-risk, high-return opportunities, but this often diverts funds from productive sectors. This trend has a parallel in Japan during the 1980s, where a focus on financial assets and stock market gains caused an economic bubble. Japan's economy slowed as funds left industries like manufacturing and technology, leading to what is now known as the “lost decade.”
Recommended by LinkedIn
Lack of Focus on Real Businesses and Productive Sectors
Industries that create jobs, promote innovation, and add value—like manufacturing, agriculture, and technology—have received inadequate focus in Pakistan. Countries that have directed capital toward these sectors demonstrate the benefits of such a strategy. For example, South Korea invested heavily in technology and manufacturing, building global brands like Samsung and Hyundai. This focus not only made South Korea a major economic player but also created high-quality jobs, improved national productivity, and fostered a culture of innovation.
Similarly, Germany’s focus on its manufacturing sector—specifically in engineering and automotive—has made it an industrial powerhouse, renowned for quality and technological advancements. This approach helps in building long-term resilience against economic shocks and supports steady job creation.
Recommendations for Policymakers
To drive sustainable economic development, Pakistan’s policymakers should aim to channel investment away from sectors that do not produce tangible economic benefits and focus on real businesses. Specific recommendations include:
Conclusion
The economies of countries like South Korea, Germany, and Japan have thrived by prioritizing real business investments over speculative sectors like real estate and non-productive financial instruments. If Pakistan does not address its current investment patterns, it risks continued economic stagnation and missed opportunities for job creation and innovation. By redirecting investments into productive sectors, Pakistan can lay a strong foundation for sustainable economic growth, improve employment rates, and provide better opportunities for its people.