Managing Upwards in the Charity Sector: A Detailed Guide for Leaders
In the charity sector, managing upwards is a critical yet often underappreciated skill that can significantly influence an organisation's success. This involves effectively guiding and influencing those in higher positions—such as trustees and senior leaders—while ensuring that the operational team has the support and resources it needs. Given the unique structure and challenges of the charity sector, managing upwards requires a nuanced approach that balances communication, strategic alignment, governance, and innovation.
Understanding the Context: The Unique Governance Structure of Charities
Charities operate under a governance structure that typically involves a board of trustees who hold significant power over strategic decisions. Unlike in the corporate world, where executives often have the final say, charity leaders must work closely with trustees, who may come from diverse backgrounds and possess varying levels of expertise. This can lead to differing perspectives on the organisation’s direction, making it crucial for charity executives to manage upwards effectively.
Trustees, who are often volunteers, may not be involved in the day-to-day operations, yet they hold a fiduciary responsibility that necessitates informed decision-making. This creates a unique challenge for charity leaders, who must ensure that trustees are not only well-informed but also aligned with the operational realities of the organisation. Managing upwards in this context means fostering a collaborative relationship where trustees feel valued and informed, and where their strategic input is grounded in a realistic understanding of the organisation's capabilities and external challenges.
Building and Maintaining Strong Relationships
Strong, trust-based relationships with trustees and other senior stakeholders are the foundation of effective upward management. This relationship must be built on regular, transparent communication that keeps trustees engaged with the charity's work and its impact. Regular updates, whether through formal board meetings, written reports, or informal check-ins, help to build this trust.
For instance, a report by NCVO highlights that clear and consistent communication is key to fostering a culture of openness. This not only helps in building trust but also empowers trustees to make informed decisions, ultimately leading to more effective governance. Leaders should also seek to understand the individual motivations and concerns of each trustee, tailoring their communication and engagement strategies accordingly. By doing so, they can better align the board’s strategic vision with the charity’s operational needs.
Aligning Expectations: Bridging the Gap Between Strategy and Operations
One of the most significant challenges in managing upwards is aligning the often lofty expectations of trustees with the practical realities of day-to-day operations. This involves clearly communicating both the opportunities and the constraints the charity faces. For example, while trustees might push for ambitious growth targets or new initiatives, it’s the responsibility of the executive team to present a balanced view that considers resource limitations, funding challenges, and operational capacity.
Data and evidence play a crucial role in this process. As highlighted in recent discussions by Civil Society, the use of clear metrics, performance indicators, and real-world examples can bridge the gap between strategic ambitions and operational realities. This ensures that trustees are not only aware of what is feasible but are also supportive of the direction the charity is taking. Moreover, involving trustees in the decision-making process by presenting them with detailed analyses and options can help in achieving a more collaborative approach to strategy development.
Considering Governance and Compliance: Ensuring Informed and Effective Decision-Making
Governance and compliance are critical areas where upward management plays a pivotal role. With the increasing complexity of regulatory requirements, charity leaders must ensure that trustees are fully aware of their responsibilities. This includes staying informed about upcoming changes to financial reporting standards, such as revisions to FRS 102, and the implications these have for the charity’s financial health and reporting obligations.
Additionally, charity leaders must be proactive in educating trustees about their governance duties, particularly in areas like safeguarding, financial oversight, and risk management. By providing trustees with the necessary tools, training, and information, leaders can ensure that the board is not only compliant but also capable of making decisions that enhance the charity's strategic objectives.
Recommended by LinkedIn
Leveraging Technology for Better Communication and Decision-Making
In the digital age, technology can be a powerful enabler of effective upward management. Digital platforms that facilitate real-time communication, document sharing, and data analysis can help bridge the gap between executive teams and trustees. However, as noted by Civil Society, many charities still struggle to fully embrace these tools due to budgetary constraints and a lack of digital skills.
Despite these challenges, there are cost-effective solutions available that can significantly enhance communication and decision-making processes. For example, using cloud-based project management tools can provide trustees with ongoing insights into the charity's operations, allowing them to make more informed decisions. Additionally, video conferencing tools can facilitate more frequent and flexible communication, especially for trustees who may not be able to attend meetings in person.
The Strategic Importance of Managing Upwards
Managing upwards is more than just a managerial skill; it is a strategic necessity in the charity sector. By building strong relationships, aligning expectations, navigating governance challenges, and leveraging technology, charity leaders can ensure that their organisations are not only compliant and well-governed but also strategically aligned and poised for long-term success.
As the charity sector continues to navigate economic challenges, regulatory changes, and the push for greater digital adoption, the ability to manage upwards effectively will be a critical determinant of success. Leaders who can master this skill will not only enhance their own effectiveness but also contribute significantly to the resilience and impact of their organisations.
Emily Formby
Not-for-Profit / Charity - Search Specialist
Twitter: www.twitter.com/Exec_Recruit