the idea that matter has a wave nature turns 100 years old
a shallow fake of Louis de Broglie, for the centennial of his seminal achievement on wave nature of matter

the idea that matter has a wave nature turns 100 years old

Modern quantum mechanics began in 1925.

But one of its most solid intellectual pillars rests in a speculation that was advanced by Louis de Broglie one year earlier: exactly 100 years ago.


Let us summarise his reasoning:

  • de Broglie acknowledges that light has a dual nature, that of wave and particle, as had been pointed out by Maxwell and Einstein respectively. This seemed to many little less than an intellectual impossibility!
  • But rather than seeing this dualism as an absurdity - or a philosophical limitation to be amended - he turns this acquisition into a motif of inspiration.
  • de Broglie was guided by the vision, that there should be a fundamental correspondence between light and matter; this led him to think that also the electron (discovered a few decades earlier) could be conceived along similar lines.
  • Thus, he boldly proposed the idea that the electron could behave like a wave. On this basis, he concludes that it can be subject to diffraction.

Recall that electron where discovered at the end of 1800, thanks to the study of the cathode rays, shown in the figure.

the trajectory of the cathode rays can be visualized by their interaction with the residual air; as they are constituted by electrons, they can be curved by applying a magnetic field.

It is curious that the debate on their nature had seen supporters of the corpuscular nature arrayed against those who argued for the wave nature.

The corpuscular view had a momentary triumph with JJ Thomson's Nobel Prize (1906); but then GP Thomson (Nobel 1937), his son, proved that electrons could indeed be diffracted, just as de Broglie had hypothesised.


de Broglie's ideas would receive countless supporting evidence and acclaim, earning him the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1929.

They would be developed by many people, notably by Schrödinger, Dirac, Majorana.

Today, they form the basis of our understanding of the world of the infinitely small:

in suitable conditions, all material particles are deemed to behave as waves.

To view or add a comment, sign in

More articles by Francesco Vissani, PhD

  • Il terzo manifesto

    Il terzo manifesto

    Ieri ho imparato una cosa nuova sugli sviluppi successivi alla pubblicazione del "Manifesto del partito fascista" del…

  • La colpa di Ulisse

    La colpa di Ulisse

    Dante ebbe un accesso alla tradizione greca mediato da traduzioni e in sostanza limitato. La interpretò dunque…

    7 Comments
  • Un filosofo che nobilitava il fascismo sul Corriere di oggi

    Un filosofo che nobilitava il fascismo sul Corriere di oggi

    Sull'inserto "La lettura" del Corriere di oggi 24 marzo 2024 troviamo un bel dialogo tra gli storici Gennaro Sasso ed…

    5 Comments
  • Una tavola rotonda con Giorgio Parisi

    Una tavola rotonda con Giorgio Parisi

    Il 13 gennaio 2024, in occasione della lezione magistrale che il professor Giorgio Parisi ha tenuto presso il Liceo…

    1 Comment
  • Qualche IδEA dal Brasile

    Qualche IδEA dal Brasile

    Ecco la traduzione di una intervista rilasciata dopo una visita all'Istituto IδEA. Ho limato un paio di passaggi per…

    6 Comments
  • Neutrinos from the Milky Way!

    Neutrinos from the Milky Way!

    Today scientific news I congratulate my Colleagues of the IceCube experiment, who found evidence of a population of…

    5 Comments
  • Come scrivere un saggio di filosofia da schifo: breve guida per gli studenti

    Come scrivere un saggio di filosofia da schifo: breve guida per gli studenti

    di Jimmy Lenman, Dipartimento di Filosofia Sheffield U. Iniziate sempre il vostro saggio in un modo del genere: "Fin…

    3 Comments
  • Edoardo Borgomeo con “Oro blu” vince il premio ASIMOV 2023

    Edoardo Borgomeo con “Oro blu” vince il premio ASIMOV 2023

    6 Maggio 2023 Oro blu. Storie di acqua e cambiamento climatico di Edoardo Borgomeo, edito da Editori Laterza, è il…

    1 Comment
  • Dante e il pi greco

    Dante e il pi greco

    La perfezione del cerchio e la misura del pi greco Il pi greco viene presentato a volte come simbolo di conoscenze…

    8 Comments
  • Lectures on Neutrinos

    Lectures on Neutrinos

    I have just returned from Florence, where I gave five lectures on Neutrinos as part of the PhD school GGI Lectures on…

    2 Comments

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics