The MEI Mirage: Don't Let the 'Merit' Trap Fool You

Today, let's unpack a debate that's causing ripples in the world of inclusion: the clash between DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion) and the newly proposed MEI (Merit, Excellence, and Intelligence) coined by Alexandr Wang, co-founder and CEO of Scale AI

The MEI Mirage: A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing?

At first glance, MEI seems to champion a meritocratic ideal, focusing on individual talent and accomplishments. It sounds appealing, doesn't it? A workplace where the best and brightest rise to the top, regardless of background. But let's peel back the layers or should I say sheer that sheep.

MEI, as currently framed, risks overlooking the systemic barriers that prevent individuals from underrepresented groups from even reaching the starting line. It assumes a level playing field that simply doesn't exist. It places the onus solely on individuals to prove their worth, ignoring the historical and societal factors that have created unequal opportunities.

As the CEO of Contentstack astutely points out, "You're kind of creating an environment where only certain types of people can get in the door. And that's not really a fair assessment of talent."

I personally have a feeling of deja vu about it, isn’t this just returning to the status quo?

The DEI Difference: More Than Just Buzzwords

DEI, on the other hand, acknowledges these systemic inequalities. It recognises that 'merit' isn't always objectively measured and that unconscious biases can creep into even the most well-intentioned hiring and promotion processes.

• Diversity: DEI celebrates the full spectrum of human differences, understanding that diverse teams lead to richer ideas and better solutions. Recent research even suggests that businesses run by entrepreneurs from ethnic minorities are more innovative than their rivals.

• Equity: DEI actively addresses systemic barriers, providing tailored support to ensure everyone has a fair shot at success. It's about leveling the playing field, not just pretending it's already level. As I shared in my book Equality vs Equity, tackling issues of race in the workplace:

"…meritocracy is a myth, the idea that through determination and hard work, alone, we can pull ourselves up by our bootstraps is frankly not true, none of us are self-made, we all stand on the shoulders of giants."

• Inclusion: DEI fosters a culture where everyone feels safe to contribute their unique perspectives, knowing their voices will be heard and valued. It's about creating a sense of belonging, not just tolerance.

Beyond the Acronyms: Building a Truly Inclusive Workplace

The debate between DEI and MEI highlights a fundamental truth: meritocracy does not exist because a recognition of systemic inequities is needed. We need to create a workplace where everyone has the opportunity to develop their talents and showcase their merit, while also acknowledging and addressing the barriers that prevent some individuals from reaching their full potential.

This means going beyond buzzwords and taking concrete action. It means investing in diverse talent pipelines, providing mentorship and sponsorship opportunities, and creating a culture where everyone feels valued and respected.

Let's Break Barriers, Together

The conversation around DEI and MEI is an important one. It forces us to examine our assumptions, challenge the status quo, and strive for a workplace that is truly inclusive.

Let's not get caught up in the acronyms. Let's focus on the goal: creating a workplace where everyone has the opportunity to thrive, contribute, and succeed based on their merit, in an environment that is equitable and inclusive.

Until next time

Our next free event takes place on the 26th September at 12.30pm, register here for Unlocking the Power of Executive Coaching for an Inclusive Culture.

Subscribe to my Monthly newsletter here

 #DEI #MEI #InclusionMatters #DiversityAndInclusion #EqualityVsEquity #WorkplaceCulture #Leadership #UKBusiness #JennyGarrett