New Perspectives in Recruitment

New Perspectives in Recruitment

I have always been a big advocate of the recruitment industry and firmly believe (and still do) that a lot of the problems we experience in recruitment is down to the contingent nature of the industry.

However, I have to say I have had a few shocking revelations since working "on the other side of the fence" in internal recruitment.

I have bitten my tongue for some weeks now but after today I have to say something, and please do take this in the spirit it's intended - to help, not to recruiter-bash.

1) I must get on average 60 - 70 speculative emails a week from recruiters. Most of them start with "I know you must get lots of emails like this but..." Yes I do. As soon as I read this, or another recruiter proclaiming to be the Number One in their field, I press the delete key.

2) Recruiters contacting line managers/ sending CVs, despite my requests not to do this. Setting up a brand new recruitment function in a £350m turn over company with stakeholders who are used to doing things for themselves, is NOT an easy task. I would really appreciate you working with me and my colleagues. You are much more likely to get on the PSL I am creating that way.

3) Don't tell lies. I have had numerous lies told to me by various recruiters since I started. If you tell me you supply us but don't, I will find out and lies really do damage your credibility. 

4) Please don't spam. A couple of recruiters email me literally everyday, sometimes twice a day. The scatter-gun approach is one I never agreed with when I worked in agency recruitment and I can categorically state that being on the receiving end of spam is really annoying and becomes a noise - so I am even less likely to read these emails, which I am guessing is counter-productive to what you are trying to achieve.

I know being a recruiter is hard and that business development is possibly the toughest part of the job, however I could not be more passionate in my belief that in order to succeed it's not about numbers, its about being different, being credible, knowledgeable and honest.

Now for the positive:

I have had some approaches that I have responded to. Without fail these have come from recruiters who have either offered me something different - a "value add" - or just been very authentic / real in their interaction with me.  

They kept it simple, gave me some REAL USP's (not the "expert" word) and most importantly, they were confident in their ability without any salesy BS.

I still firmly believe that recruiters, if engaged with in the right way, are a huge asset to their clients. The reputation our industry has upsets me and in the main is unjust and caused by people interacting with our industry without a real understanding of what we do. However, a lot of recruiters don't help themselves. I implore you to stop chasing the numbers and instead strive to deliver first class customer service, and always be mindful as to how your actions are perceived by others. If you know your market, work hard but strategically, you really can't go wrong. 

Shaun Windram

Talent & Culture Consultant at ANZx

7y

Nice blog Jennifer. I was curious, of those you responded to, where did you perceive their value proposition?

Darren R.

Recruitment Websites, SEO & Marketing

7y

At last, a recruiter who crossed to the dark said and tells you how to work with her as well as how to not. Normally we just get the not.

BATMAN..!!!! Lol or the LONE RANGER 😃😁😁😃😂😂😂😂

Like
Reply
Steve Huxham

Very experienced international Recruitment leader for SMEs; HR Advisor; SME Non-Executive Director; Associations sector professional

7y

Firstly - have to admit that the "60-70 speculative emails" makes me feel a lot better about the number I get (though to be fair our number doesn't include all the line managers who tell cold calling agency idiots where to go without bothering me about it.) Question though - what genuine "value add" or USPs precisely did they offer you? BTW I'm excluding here Temp suppliers from the Q. Even the genuine or as you say, authentic ones, will usually admit they don't do anything different to anyone else? I did at one point include in the reply I send to the speculative emails an invitation to come up with something new and surprising in the offering - never had a real reply to that one. I'm also thinking of amending mine to say we would only work with partners who are not commission or salary percentage led - I wonder how that will play? Seriously though, hasn't the main question got to be: "What can you do for us that we can't do ourselves and better?"

Judy Goddard

Now with TechnologyOne in Brisbane xApple xMicrosoft

7y

Spot on! I have been on both sides and agree with your recommended way of approach for BD.

To view or add a comment, sign in

More articles by Jennifer Swain

  • Driver Shortage v Driver Treatment

    Driver Shortage v Driver Treatment

    The Driver Shortage. The main topic of discussion in logistics at the moment.

    3 Comments
  • Career in HGV Driving - a Women's Perspective

    Career in HGV Driving - a Women's Perspective

    Logistics is in the news! The national pandemic has highlighted the importance of the logistics industry – their…

    8 Comments
  • Tackling the Driver Shortage the Home Bargain way!

    Tackling the Driver Shortage the Home Bargain way!

    During the research phase of Road to Logistics, I have recently had the privilege of speaking with the logistics team…

    2 Comments
  • My Experience of Flexible Working

    My Experience of Flexible Working

    My name is Jennifer Swain and I was a single parent. I left an abusive relationship when my two boys were just one and…

    30 Comments
  • Recruitment - a Data-Led Industry??

    Recruitment - a Data-Led Industry??

    So I received an email the other day that made me really angry. Its subject was “Recruitment is now a Data Driven…

    3 Comments
  • Why Does Notice Served = Relationship Severed?

    Why Does Notice Served = Relationship Severed?

    Those of you who follow my posts will know that I am a big defender of the recruitment industry, and feel that it is…

    1 Comment
  • "On Demand" Interviews. A Good Idea?

    "On Demand" Interviews. A Good Idea?

    I spoke with a contact yesterday. A very experienced and talented professional, whom I both respect and admire.

    4 Comments
  • The Do's and Don'ts of Social Networking

    The Do's and Don'ts of Social Networking

    I have been a prolific social networker since 2008. Networking is the life-blood of my business and the advent of…

    12 Comments
  • Do You REALLY Care About Logistics?

    Do You REALLY Care About Logistics?

    I have lost count of the amount of logistics professionals I have met or interviewed over the years. You are all very…

    22 Comments
  • Recruitment and the Blame Game

    Recruitment and the Blame Game

    LinkedIn appears to have turned into a bit of a war zone of late. Candidates airing frustrations over inadequate…

    64 Comments

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics