Obama asked the Military for a Plan to Protect Civilians in Combat: Here's One

Obama asked the Military for a Plan to Protect Civilians in Combat: Here's One

President Barack Obama last week issued an executive order directing the military to improve the protection of civilians in combat zones. As veterans who have commanded American forces in combat, we [David Petraeus and Christopher Kolenda] urge the Department of Defense to consider hard-won lessons from recent conflicts when implementing the order.

The military teaches its leaders to balance the needs of the mission with protection of the force. In some cases, this balance can present a difficult trade-off. The best leaders accomplish both to the greatest extent possible.

Today’s wars that are typically fought among the people often result in a third critical task – protection of the civilian populace. In the wars of the post-9/11 era, balancing the need to protect our force while minimizing civilian casualties has become increasingly difficult – and increasingly consequential to successful accomplishment of the mission.

To read the article, click here.

Bart Kemper, P.E.

F.ASME, F.NSPE, F.NAFE, DFE, Int.PE

8y

Well considered. It is a start.

Like
Reply

There is no doubt that this will be a very challenging task, especially when the enemy's main battle strategy is to hide amongst the civilian population and use them as human shields to protect themselves and thereby increasing the propaganda value of their cause and to gain sympathy and support from the locals. In so doing any good, that you may do now or in the future will always be overshadowed by the civilian casualties you have caused.

Stephen M. Apatow

Founder, CEO, Humanitarian Resource Institute: H-II OPSEC Expeditionary Operations, Director: Global Special Operations Network, War Crimes Committee, International Bar Association, Certified Sailing Rescue Swimmer.

8y

After cut and run in Iraq and Afghanistan, facilitating a spiral that has now transitioned Syria, Iraq, Yemen, Libya and Afghanistan to 5 Somalia level failed states (looking at the same spiral in Continental Africa), one can only shake their head in disbelief, at such an important civil affairs question. Meanwhile, NATO gets to watch the impoverished African American cities, rally across America under the banner of Black Lives Matter, with a call to 33,000 gangs to rise up and target federal, state and local law enforcement for assassination.

Stephen M. Apatow

Founder, CEO, Humanitarian Resource Institute: H-II OPSEC Expeditionary Operations, Director: Global Special Operations Network, War Crimes Committee, International Bar Association, Certified Sailing Rescue Swimmer.

8y

It is frequently critical that we and our host nation partners gain the support of the people. Their active support is needed for host nations to win; by contrast, their passive or active support of our adversaries enables insurgencies to endure. Legitimacy in the eyes of the population is essential for success.

To view or add a comment, sign in

More articles by Chris Kolenda

  • Four Lessons from Radical Government Reform

    Four Lessons from Radical Government Reform

    Government reform is getting a lot of attention in the United States, so I asked my chatbot to come up with historical…

    4 Comments
  • Three Leadership Lessons from the Alamo

    Three Leadership Lessons from the Alamo

    The Alamo is a testament to leadership in the face of overwhelming odds; here’s how you can embody that same…

  • Are You Hiring for Slope or Intercept?

    Are You Hiring for Slope or Intercept?

    When building great teams, the difference between long-term success and short-term fixes often comes down to how you…

    2 Comments
  • Regrettable Versus Unregrettable Turnover

    Regrettable Versus Unregrettable Turnover

    Struggling with turnover? Here’s how to build a workplace where people want to stay. Some employees are not the right…

  • What’s Your Mission Question?

    What’s Your Mission Question?

    Discover the power of a mission question (and why you need one). I listened to a podcast interview with Warren Berger…

    2 Comments
  • How I Help Trailblazers

    How I Help Trailblazers

    Learn how trailblazers gain a decisive competitive advantage in any market. Armies fight with weapons and businesses…

  • What Do I Mean by Trailblazer?

    What Do I Mean by Trailblazer?

    Find out how to unlock your leadership potential and become a trailblazer. A trailblazer is an exemplar of bold…

  • The Right Mindset Is a Vital Foundation for Accountability

    The Right Mindset Is a Vital Foundation for Accountability

    Discover how accountability tools like supportive criticism can strengthen relationships while addressing problems. How…

    3 Comments
  • Reducing Confirmation Bias

    Reducing Confirmation Bias

    Discover how to improve your decision-making by reducing confirmation bias. I was convinced that business owners would…

    4 Comments
  • When Failure Is the Best Option

    When Failure Is the Best Option

    Discover why and when failure could be your secret weapon for success. Everything until 1862 came easy for U.

    3 Comments

Insights from the community

Others also viewed

Explore topics