Paramedics in the ER: A Nursing and Emergency Medicine Perspective
Dr. Orlando E Rivera DNP, MBA, RN
Doctor of Nursing Practice | Masters in Business Administration | Expert in Performance Improvement | Informaticist | Dedicated Mentor & Educator | Innovator | Executive Healthcare Professional
The Controversy
Emergency Rooms (ERs) across the nation are experimenting with a new staffing model: integrating paramedics into their teams. Traditionally, paramedics have been the frontline warriors in pre-hospital emergency care, adept at providing life-saving interventions in high-pressure situations. However, the transition from the field to the fast-paced environment of an ER is sparking a heated debate among healthcare professionals.
The Nursing Perspective
From a nursing standpoint, the infusion of paramedics into ER staffing brings both challenges and opportunities. Nurses undergo rigorous training focused on a broad spectrum of patient care, including critical thinking skills tailored to the diverse needs of patients in a hospital setting.
Some nurses express concerns that paramedics, although highly skilled in emergency response, may not have the extensive training in certain aspects of hospital care, such as in-depth patient assessments and long-term care planning. There's a worry that this could lead to gaps in patient care or misunderstandings in a multidisciplinary team.
Recommended by LinkedIn
The Emergency Medicine Physician's View
On the other hand, emergency medicine physicians see this as a potential game-changer. Paramedics bring a unique skill set to the table – their ability to perform under extreme pressure and their proficiency in emergency procedures can be invaluable in an ER setting, where seconds often count. Physicians argue that with appropriate orientation and continued education, paramedics can bridge the gap between pre-hospital and hospital care, enhancing patient outcomes.
The Synergy of Skills
Despite the differing opinions, there’s a silver lining. Both nurses and physicians agree that the key lies in leveraging the strengths of each profession. By providing paramedics with additional training and support, ERs can create a dynamic team where each member contributes their expertise. This synergy could lead to more efficient patient care and a richer learning environment for all healthcare professionals involved.
The Positive Outlook
While the integration of paramedics into ER staffing is a work in progress, it holds the promise of innovation in patient care. With open communication, mutual respect, and a commitment to continuous learning, this model can pave the way for a more robust and responsive healthcare system. In the end, it's all about working together towards the common goal of providing the best possible care for patients.
I think this is a good point of discussion. I will say that this is also not a new discussion but merely a revisit. As a NYS paramedic for over 30 years and a newly minted NYS RN, I think that creating a true bridge program is what is needed. paramedics and nurses learn differently and according to different theories- paramedics follow a medical theory and are extensions of physicians whereas nurses following nursing theory. Although I know plan to go into ED nursing, there are certainly many things that I learned in nursing school. More to follow but paramedics have been used in disasters to conduct triage in order to allow the nurse to provide patient care in the ED. There are certain things that nurses must do things whereas paramedics have more autonomy working out of hospital. For example, nurses must be ACLS certified but they are usually not allowed to intubate patients whereas paramedics do that on a routine basis. Things need to follow a systematic approach and remember that the team approach is best and it will only work when everyone knows and respects each other's roles and responsibilities.
Executive Director, Ground Emergency Medical Services
11moWhat was old is new again. However, the pool is much more shallow these days.
BSN, NREMT-P, CEN
12moAs a paramedic for 14 years in a busy system who then turned ER nurse, I can certainly attest that my medic education and background prepared me for the ED. My knowledge from being in the streets is vast, my critical thinking skills in under pressure situations is great. I hate the paramedic vs. nurse fight. Both are skilled in different ways and should work hand in hand to provide the best patient care.
Nurse 👩🏼⚕️/ Advocate, 🗣 Navigator 🧭 / Creator 💡 and Managing Partner 🤝 of DrassAssociates.com 💻 / MHS, MSN, RN, PMH-BC, NEA-BC, CLNC, NCC 🏫 /👩🏫 Professor/🧠 Behavioral Health🏥& Legal Nurse⚖️ Consultant 🏛
12moI'm all for "all hands on deck"; as long as each hand knows what to do and the standard of care for doing it!
Fire and Safety Inspector Commonwealth of PA
12moHaving started my pre-hospital career as a hospital based provider, I can find nothing wrong with working as an integral part of the hospital system. It is not a new frontier but one that has come full circle from its origins. Many a time the physicians or nurses paged the paramedics when in house and not on a call to provide skilled services of life saving cared . Also, the educational experience in a hospital based system is hands down a better exposure to patient assessment than a fire based system.