Part V-Trade Series: AGOA & AfCFTA; Will the Next Two Decades of AGOA Be Like the Last Two?
Foster Awintiti Akugri
Change Management | Market Development & Expansions | Agile | Process Engineering | Six Sigma Black Belt Consultant | MBA 2x | Sustainable Management | Business Development | Sales Leadership
As the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA) enters its third decade, questions abound regarding its future trajectory and its interplay with the African Continental Free Trade Area (#AfCFTA). AGOA, enacted in 2000, has been pivotal in facilitating trade between the United States and Sub-Saharan Africa, granting duty-free access to the U.S. market for thousands of products from eligible African countries. However, as the AfCFTA seeks to create a single, integrated market across Africa, the dynamics of AGOA's impact and relevance may shift. This op-ed explores whether the next two decades of AGOA will mirror the last two, or if significant changes are on the horizon, influenced by the AfCFTA and evolving global trade dynamics.
The Legacy of AGOA: Achievements and Challenges
Trade Expansion and Economic Growth
Over the past two decades, AGOA has significantly expanded trade between the U.S. and Sub-Saharan Africa. According to the United States International Trade Commission (USITC), AGOA has facilitated billions of dollars in exports from Africa to the U.S., supporting economic growth and job creation in eligible countries. Key beneficiaries have included the textiles and apparel sectors, which have seen substantial growth due to preferential access to the U.S. market.
Case Study: Ethiopia’s textile industry has thrived under AGOA, attracting significant foreign investment and creating thousands of jobs. Companies like H&M and Levi’s source products from Ethiopia, leveraging the duty-free access provided by AGOA.
Diverse Impact Across Countries
While AGOA has had notable successes, its impact has not been uniform across all eligible countries. The benefits have often concentrated in a few nations with the capacity to meet the stringent requirements and leverage the opportunities provided. Countries like South Africa, Kenya, and Nigeria have been major exporters under AGOA, while others have struggled to maximize its potential due to structural and capacity constraints.
Case Study: ARISE IIP (Integrated Industrial Platforms), with initiatives in Benin and Togo, exemplifies how small economies can leverage AGOA benefits. By creating special economic zones and industrial platforms, these countries have attracted investment, boosted industrialization, and increased their participation in international trade.
Challenges and Criticisms
Despite its achievements, AGOA has faced criticisms related to its limited scope and duration, stringent eligibility criteria, and lack of capacity-building support. Many African countries have found it challenging to comply with AGOA's regulatory requirements, hindering their ability to fully exploit the opportunities. Moreover, the program's periodic renewals have created uncertainty, affecting long-term planning and investment decisions.
AGOA as a Political Tool
One of the critical criticisms of AGOA is its use as a political tool by the United States. The eligibility criteria for AGOA benefits are not solely based on economic factors but also on compliance with U.S. foreign policy objectives. This has led to the suspension of some countries from AGOA eligibility due to political reasons rather than purely trade-related issues.
Examples of Suspensions:
Using AGOA as a political tool undermines its primary objective of promoting trade and economic development. For AGOA to succeed on fair trade grounds, it should be insulated from political maneuvering and focus on mutually beneficial trade relationships.
The Emergence of AfCFTA: A Game Changer?
Creating a Unified African Market
The AfCFTA, launched in January 2021, aims to create the world's largest free trade area by connecting 54 African countries into a single market. This ambitious initiative seeks to boost intra-African trade, promote industrialization, and foster economic diversification. By reducing tariffs and non-tariff barriers, AfCFTA is expected to enhance the competitiveness of African products and create new opportunities for SMEs across the continent.
Synergies and Potential Conflicts with AGOA
As AfCFTA promotes intra-African trade, questions arise about its interaction with AGOA. On one hand, the two initiatives could complement each other by expanding market access and creating new trade routes. AGOA’s access to the U.S. market, combined with the AfCFTA’s intra-African integration, could provide a dual pathway for African products to reach global markets.
However, potential conflicts could also emerge. The increased focus on intra-African trade might divert attention from leveraging AGOA benefits, particularly if African countries prioritize regional markets over exports to the U.S. Additionally, the rules of origin under AfCFTA could complicate compliance with AGOA’s eligibility criteria, posing challenges for businesses trying to navigate both trade regimes.
The Future of AGOA: Adapting to a Changing Landscape
Reforming AGOA to Align with AfCFTA
To remain relevant and effective in the next two decades, AGOA may need to undergo significant reforms. These could include extending the duration of the program to provide greater certainty for investors, simplifying eligibility criteria, and enhancing capacity-building support to help African countries meet regulatory requirements. Aligning AGOA with the objectives of AfCFTA could create a more cohesive and supportive trade framework, leveraging the strengths of both initiatives.
Recommended by LinkedIn
Promoting Value Addition and Industrialization
One of the key criticisms of AGOA has been its focus on exporting raw materials and low-value products. To foster sustainable economic growth, future iterations of AGOA should emphasize value addition and industrialization. Encouraging the export of processed goods and supporting the development of manufacturing capabilities in Africa can create more jobs, enhance skills, and increase the resilience of African economies.
Case Study: Ghana’s cocoa industry has traditionally exported raw cocoa beans under AGOA. By investing in processing facilities and exporting cocoa products like chocolate, Ghana can capture more value and create a higher economic impact.
Strengthening Regional Value Chains
AGOA can play a crucial role in strengthening regional value chains within Africa. By promoting cross-border investments and partnerships, AGOA can help integrate African economies more closely, supporting the goals of AfCFTA. For instance, textiles produced in one African country could be transformed into apparel in another, leveraging the comparative advantages of different regions.
The Role of Digital and Physical Infrastructure
Digital Transformation
The future success of both AGOA and AfCFTA will heavily depend on digital infrastructure. Investing in robust digital networks, e-commerce platforms, and digital payment systems can facilitate trade and make it easier for SMEs to access international markets. Programs that support digital literacy and entrepreneurship can further empower African businesses to leverage technology for growth.
Example: Standard Bank Group has been intentional about developing financing instruments to enable value maximization of AGOA. Their TradeSuite solution provides African businesses with the necessary tools and support to navigate international trade complexities and capitalize on AGOA benefits.
Physical Infrastructure
Similarly, improving physical infrastructure such as roads, ports, and railways is essential for the smooth movement of goods across borders. Public-private partnerships can play a significant role in financing and developing these critical infrastructures, reducing logistical bottlenecks, and lowering the cost of trade.
Capacity Building and Institutional Support
Building Institutional Capacity
For AGOA and AfCFTA to achieve their full potential, building institutional capacity within African governments and trade bodies is crucial. Training programs, technical assistance, and knowledge sharing can help institutions effectively implement trade policies, negotiate trade agreements, and support businesses in navigating the complexities of international trade.
Example: AFI - Africa For Investors emphasizes the importance of building institutional capacity to attract and sustain investments. Their initiatives aim to improve the business environment and regulatory framework, making it easier for African countries to leverage trade agreements like AGOA and AfCFTA.
Supporting SMEs
Specific programs aimed at supporting SMEs can enhance their ability to compete globally. This includes providing access to finance, technical expertise, and market information. Initiatives like export readiness programs and trade facilitation services can help SMEs understand and meet the requirements of AGOA and AfCFTA, enabling them to expand their reach.
Navigating a New Era of Trade
The next two decades of AGOA will not be a simple continuation of the past. The emergence of AfCFTA, coupled with evolving global trade dynamics, presents both challenges and opportunities for AGOA. By reforming and aligning AGOA with AfCFTA’s objectives, investing in infrastructure, and supporting SMEs, African countries can create a synergistic trade environment that leverages the strengths of both initiatives.
The future of AGOA depends on its ability to adapt to the changing landscape and continue providing meaningful benefits to African economies. With strategic reforms and a focus on value addition, regional integration, and digital transformation, AGOA can remain a vital tool for fostering economic growth and development in Africa. As Africa embarks on this new era of trade, collaboration between governments, private sector players, and international partners will be key to unlocking the continent’s full potential.