The Red Flags of a Toxic Boss

Welcome to Leading Engineers - a weekly newsletter specifically for engineering leaders who want to increase your impact at every level of the organization.  Each week you’ll gain powerful strategies, techniques, and insights for driving your team, company, and career forward!

This week's topic: The Red Flags of a Toxic Boss

In engineering teams, strong leadership is crucial for innovation, problem-solving, and overall productivity. But what happens when leadership is the problem itself?

Spotting a toxic boss can be tough, especially when you’re focused on your work, but the consequences of staying under poor management can be damaging to both your career and mental health.

Here are the common signs of a toxic boss, how these behaviors impact your job, and why it’s essential to recognize these red flags early.

1. The Micromanager

If your boss has to oversee every little task, not trusting anyone to make decisions without their input, you're dealing with a micromanager. In engineering roles, where creativity and problem-solving are key, micromanagement stifles your ability to innovate. A micromanager wants to control every detail, leaving you no room to grow or think on your own.

How it Impacts Your Work:  

• You lose autonomy, which lowers your job satisfaction  
• Constant supervision leads to stress and anxiety  
• Innovation takes a back seat to “playing it safe”

According to Gallup, employees who feel micromanaged are 28% more likely to experience burnout. And once burnout hits, productivity, creativity, and morale all take a nosedive. When your boss is more concerned with minor details than the bigger picture, it’s a clear sign of a toxic environment.

2. The Blame Shifter

A healthy work environment relies on accountability—owning your mistakes and learning from them. But with a blame-shifting boss, the moment something goes wrong, the fault is placed squarely on your shoulders, no matter the real cause. If your boss never owns up to mistakes and always passes the buck, it creates a culture of fear and mistrust.

How it Impacts Your Work:

• Morale plummets, and teamwork suffers  
• You’re afraid to take risks, worried that failure will cost you  
• Creativity is squashed as you avoid stepping out of the box

According to a study by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), 58% of employees who leave their jobs blame toxic leadership, specifically citing blame-shifting and lack of recognition. When you’re constantly worried about being the scapegoat, you stop contributing your best ideas, and that’s a recipe for stagnation.

3. The Unpredictable Boss

One day they’re supportive, the next, they’re unpredictable and moody. If your boss’s attitude changes with the wind, it’s hard to know where you stand. This kind of volatility is a common sign of toxic leadership. For engineers who need stability and focus to solve complex problems, an unpredictable boss can wreak havoc on productivity.

How it Impacts Your Work:

• Increased stress from not knowing what to expect  
• You hesitate to bring up issues, fearing a negative reaction  
• The team becomes divided, focusing more on managing the boss’s mood than on their work

Forbes reports that employees under volatile leadership are less likely to voice concerns, leading to unresolved issues and poor communication. When you’re more worried about navigating your boss’s mood swings than tackling your next project, work quality takes a hit.

4. The Credit Thief

It’s your hard work, your problem-solving skills, and your late nights that bring projects to life. But when it’s time for recognition, your boss takes all the credit. This not only demotivates you but also drives a wedge between leadership and the team. A boss who doesn’t share credit with their team is prioritizing themselves, not the success of the group.

How it Impacts Your Work:

• You lose motivation because you feel undervalued  
• Resentment builds, creating tension in the team  
• You’re less likely to give 100% if your efforts go unnoticed

Harvard Business Review found that 70% of employees say they’d work harder if they felt recognized. When your contributions go unrecognized because your boss is hoarding the praise, it’s easy to become disengaged, and that affects both your performance and your team's morale.

The Toll of Toxic Leadership

Toxic bosses don’t just impact individual employees; they poison the entire workplace environment. Here’s how:

• Burnout: Constant stress and anxiety are direct consequences of toxic leadership. Gallup reports that 76% of employees experience burnout due to poor management.
• Turnover: People don’t leave bad jobs; they leave bad bosses. SHRM reports that 50% of employees who leave their jobs do so to escape toxic leadership.
• Lower Productivity: When you’re spending energy navigating a toxic boss’s behavior, you’re not focused on the task at hand. Studies have shown that toxic leadership can lower productivity by up to 40%.

Why It’s Important to Spot These Signs Early

If these red flags sound familiar, it’s time to take stock of your work environment. Toxic leadership can erode your productivity, job satisfaction, and overall career trajectory. While it’s tempting to “ride it out” or ignore the signs, being aware of toxic behaviors allows you to make informed decisions about your career.

The engineering field is already demanding enough without the added pressure of dealing with a toxic boss. Recognizing these signs early can help protect your well-being, prevent burnout, and keep your career on track.

Working under a toxic boss takes a toll on your mental health, job performance, and future career prospects. The sooner you can recognize these traits, the quicker you can decide how to navigate or address the situation. Whether it’s through open communication, seeking mentorship, or planning an exit, knowing the signs of toxic leadership empowers you to take control of your career.

Sources:

• Gallup, Burnout Statistics, 2020  
• SHRM, Employee Retention Report, 2021  
• Forbes, Workplace Toxicity, 2019  
• Harvard Business Review, Employee Recognition and Performance, 2018 

Struggling with stress and anxiety due to a toxic boss?

You're not alone. 

In my recent YouTube episode, “Managing Stress and Anxiety at Work: Tools for Coping with a Toxic Boss”, you’ll gain practical tools and techniques to help you manage stress and anxiety at work.

Learn how to protect your mental health and stay productive even in challenging work environments.

WATCH NOW!

- Doug Howard PE

PS - If you want to learn more about this topic, and gain access to bonus material, free training resources, and special offers - subscribe to the Leading Engineers email list CLICK HERE