The Singaporean Beer Industry and Water Wastage: A True Cost Problem
Siya Tayal
Founder & CEO @ Project I Am Enough | United Nations Youth Leader | Entrepreneur since '12 | Global Activist | Environmentalist | Building @SPAID.org 🇺🇳
Attending the drone festival? Crack open a beer. Just came home from a long day at work? Crack open a beer. Celebrating a win? Crack open a beer. While Singapore isn’t a major consumer for beer, Singapore's beer production is steadily increasing, expected to reach over 200,000 metric tons within a mere two years. The average Singaporean consumes around 24.2 liters of beer annually, and the market for beer is projected to reach SGD 145 million by 2021.
The beer industry, known for its widespread consumption as a celebratory companion, faces a significant sustainability challenge: water wastage. Brewing beer is a water-intensive process, and the industry's reliance on this vital resource raises concerns about environmental impact and long-term sustainability.
According to the Brewers Association, it takes approximately 6 to 8 gallons of water to produce one gallon of beer. With global beer production exceeding 1.9 billion hectoliters annually, which would equal the volume of over 422,222,222.22 elephants annually, the industry's water footprint is substantial, contributing to freshwater scarcity and ecosystem degradation.
As breweries compete for water resources with agricultural producers, especially in regions prone to water scarcity, increased demand from the beer industry can exacerbate competition and strain local water supplies. This dynamic not only affects farmers' access to water for irrigation but also disrupts food production systems, leading to potential conflicts over water allocation and land use.
Excessive water usage by the beer industry also has detrimental effects on local ecosystems and biodiversity. Withdrawals of water from rivers, lakes, and aquifers for brewery operations reduces water availability for aquatic habitats and wildlife, leading to habitat loss, species displacement, and ecosystem degradation. Furthermore, the discharge of untreated or inadequately treated wastewater from breweries introduces pollutants such as organic matter, nutrients, and chemicals into water bodies, contributing to water pollution and ecosystem damage.
Inadequate access to clean water for drinking and sanitation jeopardizes public health, exacerbating waterborne diseases and sanitation-related illnesses. Moreover, disruptions to local water supplies can undermine livelihoods and economic activities dependent on water, such as fishing, tourism, and small-scale agriculture. Vulnerable populations, including low-income households and marginalized communities, are disproportionately affected by water scarcity and pollution, exacerbating existing inequalities and social disparities. Currently, the Singapore water crisis is causing for a need to import water. According to the Johor-Singapore Water Agreement, Singapore is taking up more than a hefty forty percent of its 300-million-gallon daily demand from its neighbor, Malaysia. Singapore is at a crisis, “borrowing” 250 million gallons of water a day from the Johor River, of which Singapore is obliged to provide Johor with treated water for up to 2% of the water it imports.
Additionally, the transportation of raw materials and finished products incurs energy consumption and carbon emissions, further exacerbating environmental impacts associated with water usage in the beer industry.
The beer industry's water wastage stems from various stages of the brewing process, including raw material cultivation, brewing operations, and wastewater treatment. In particular, brewing operations account for the majority of water consumption, highlighting the need for improvements in technology and efficiency.
Furthermore, market dynamics, such as the dominance of large breweries and the prevalence of water-intensive brewing techniques, amplify the industry's water footprint. Large breweries benefit from economies of scale but often prioritize cost reduction over sustainability initiatives, perpetuating inefficient water usage practices.
Regulatory interventions, while well-intentioned, often fall short of addressing the root causes of water wastage in the beer industry. For instance, water discharge regulations may incentivize breweries to invest in wastewater treatment facilities but do not directly address water conservation or efficiency measures. Moreover, the lack of standardized reporting requirements hampers transparency and accountability, impeding stakeholders' ability to assess and compare breweries' water management practices. While 88% of craft breweries in the United States have implemented some form of wastewater management practices, water pollution caused by the beer industry continues to grow every day.
While breweries use only less than 1% of the total water consumption in Singapore, and that number sounds quite insignificant, we fail to realize that this 1% is a whopping 3 million gallons of water a day.
The waste created by breweries, however, isn’t just a problem for Singapore. Last year, a mayor in the town of Zaragoza in Coahuila state accused a Constellation Brands brewery of sucking up so much water that it left his town without drinking water. Constellation Brands denies that its breweries threaten water resources. The company says their plant will be sustainable, is being built with the proper permits and support from the government, and is buying water rights at fair prices. They claim the plant will consume only 0.1% of the available water in the region. But Mexican farmers fear that the brewery will bring long-term problems. Mexico’s National Water Commission: Conagua, has declared the area’s aquifer overexploited and prohibited the drilling of new wells.
In Brazil, a major beer-producing country, regions such as Sao Paulo have experienced severe water shortages exacerbated by both drought and high water demand from industries including breweries. South Africa, another notable beer-producing nation, grapples with water scarcity exacerbated by factors like climate change and population growth. The beer industry in South Africa, particularly in regions like the Western Cape, puts additional pressure on already strained water resources. Furthermore, in countries like Germany and the United States, where beer production is a cornerstone of the economy, water scarcity concerns arise from both the volume of water consumed in brewing processes and the pollution caused by brewery wastewater. These examples underscore the global nature of the issue and the urgent need for sustainable water management practices within the beer industry to mitigate its impact on water resources.
To analyze the issue of water wastage in the beer industry, I will utilize the economic framework of externalities, market failures, and regulatory interventions. Externalities arise when the production or consumption of a good affects third parties not involved in the transaction. In this context, water wastage represents a negative externality, as breweries do not bear the full cost of their water consumption, leading to inefficient resource allocation.
Market failures occur when markets fail to allocate resources efficiently, often due to incomplete information or externalities. In the case of the beer industry, the absence of proper pricing mechanisms for water fails to reflect its true scarcity value, creating wasteful practices. Moreover, the fragmented nature of regulatory frameworks contributes to inconsistent water management practices across breweries, hindering industry-wide sustainability efforts.
Singapore is paving the way for change. It has has implemented stringent water management practices and conservation efforts to decrease demand and optimize water usage. These include initiatives like public awareness campaigns, efficient irrigation methods, and utilizing reclaimed water for non-potable purposes. It has also introduced NEWater, a high-quality reclaimed water produced through advanced purification processes. It is utilized for various non-drinking purposes such as industrial processes and air conditioning, along with indirect potable use by blending it with reservoir water. NEWater has notably bolstered Singapore's water self-sufficiency and diminished dependence on imported water. Singapore has made investments in desalination plants to supplement its freshwater supply. Desalinated water aids in diversifying water sources and lessening reliance on rainfall and imported water. Singapore has introduced a tiered water pricing system to encourage conservation and discourage wasteful usage. Higher rates are applied for higher consumption levels, motivating individuals and businesses to use water more efficiently. Singapore has furthermore allocated significant resources to research and development to continually enhance water technologies and devise innovative solutions for water management and sustainability.
However, this simply isn’t enough. Cost-benefit analyses suggest that investing in water-saving technologies and sustainable practices can yield long-term economic benefits for breweries. For example, implementing closed-loop water systems, optimizing cleaning processes, and reusing treated wastewater can reduce operational costs and mitigate regulatory risks. Additionally, enhancing water stewardship initiatives can enhance brand reputation, attract environmentally conscious consumers, and foster partnerships with local communities.
Water is a crucial ingredient in beer production, but it is also used extensively for cleaning, cooling, and other operational purposes. Breweries can significantly reduce their water footprint by implementing water recycling systems, upgrading equipment for energy-efficient operations, and optimizing cleaning and sanitation procedures.
Water recycling systems allow breweries to treat and reuse wastewater generated during the brewing process. Advanced filtration and purification technologies can remove contaminants and pathogens, producing high-quality water suitable for various brewery operations. By recycling water, breweries can minimize their reliance on freshwater sources and reduce the volume of wastewater discharged into the environment.
Upgrading equipment for energy-efficient operations not only reduces energy consumption but also indirectly conserves water. Many brewing processes, such as heating, cooling, and refrigeration, require large amounts of water and energy. By investing in energy-efficient equipment and technologies, breweries can minimize their environmental impact while also lowering operational costs.
Optimizing cleaning and sanitation procedures is another effective way to reduce water usage in breweries. By implementing efficient cleaning protocols and using water-saving equipment such as low-flow nozzles and automated cleaning systems, breweries can minimize water waste without compromising on hygiene and quality standards.
Recommended by LinkedIn
Cost-benefit analyses suggest that investing in water-saving technologies and sustainable practices can yield long-term economic benefits for breweries. For example, implementing closed-loop water systems, optimizing cleaning processes, and reusing treated wastewater can reduce operational costs and mitigate regulatory risks. Additionally, enhancing water stewardship initiatives can enhance brand reputation, attract environmentally conscious consumers, and foster partnerships with local communities.
Water is a crucial ingredient in beer production, but it is also used extensively for cleaning, cooling, and other operational purposes. Breweries can significantly reduce their water footprint by implementing water recycling systems, upgrading equipment for energy-efficient operations, and optimizing cleaning and sanitation procedures.
Water recycling systems allow breweries to treat and reuse wastewater generated during the brewing process. Advanced filtration and purification technologies can remove contaminants and pathogens, producing high-quality water suitable for various brewery operations. By recycling water, breweries can minimize their reliance on freshwater sources and reduce the volume of wastewater discharged into the environment.
Upgrading equipment for energy-efficient operations not only reduces energy consumption but also indirectly conserves water. Many brewing processes, such as heating, cooling, and refrigeration, require large amounts of water and energy. By investing in energy-efficient equipment and technologies, breweries can minimize their environmental impact while also lowering operational costs.
Optimizing cleaning and sanitation procedures is another effective way to reduce water usage in breweries. By implementing efficient cleaning protocols and using water-saving equipment such as low-flow nozzles and automated cleaning systems, breweries can minimize water waste without compromising on hygiene and quality standards.
While individual breweries can take steps to minimize water usage, government intervention is essential to create a supportive regulatory and economic environment for sustainable practices. Governments can play a proactive role in incentivizing water conservation and promoting sustainable practices within the beer industry through various policy measures.
One crucial measure is implementing water pricing mechanisms that reflect the true cost of water. Many breweries currently pay nominal fees for water usage, which do not accurately reflect the environmental and social costs associated with water extraction, treatment, and disposal. By implementing tiered pricing structures or water taxes based on usage levels, governments can incentivize breweries to conserve water and invest in efficiency improvements.
Financial incentives for investments in water-saving technologies can also encourage breweries to adopt sustainable practices. Government grants, subsidies, or tax credits can help offset the upfront costs of implementing water recycling systems, upgrading equipment, or conducting water audits. By providing financial support, governments can facilitate the adoption of state-of-the-art practices that benefit both breweries and the environment.
In addition to financial incentives, governments can establish regulatory frameworks that encourage innovation and collaboration within the beer industry. By setting mandatory water efficiency targets, imposing pollution controls, and promoting information sharing and best practices, governments can create a level playing field and drive continuous improvement in water management practices across the sector.
Water wastage poses a significant sustainability challenge for the beer industry, requiring coordinated action from breweries, regulators, and other stakeholders. Ultimately, addressing water wastage is not only an environmental imperative but also a strategic opportunity for breweries to enhance ethical competition, minimize risks, and safeguard the planet's precious resources.
Financial incentives for investments in water-saving technologies can also encourage breweries to adopt sustainable practices. Government grants, subsidies, or tax credits can help offset the upfront costs of implementing water recycling systems, upgrading equipment, or conducting water audits. By providing financial support, governments can facilitate the adoption of state-of-the-art practices that benefit both breweries and the environment. In addition to financial incentives, the Singapore government can establish regulatory frameworks that encourage innovation and collaboration within the beer industry. By setting mandatory water efficiency targets, imposing pollution controls, and promoting information sharing and best practices, governments can create a level playing field and drive continuous improvement in water management practices across the sector.
Lastly, an important development in the beer market in Singapore is the growing popularity of non-alcoholic and low-alcohol beers. Singapore is arguably one of the healthiest cities in the world with it’s life expectancy exceeding 84 years. Customers in blue zones such as Singapore look for healthier options to traditional alcoholic beverages are driving this development. Low- and non-alcoholic beers provide a healthier choice without sacrificing flavor. In addition, new beer products infused with natural components including fruits and herbs have been introduced as a result of the increased interest in health and wellness.The growth of beer sales online is another development in the industry. Singaporeans can now easily order their preferred beers online and have them delivered right to their door thanks to the growth in popularity of e-commerce platforms. The production of a non-alcoholic beer takes significantly less resources than that of an alcoholic beer in two key ways.
Water wastage poses a significant sustainability challenge for the beer industry, requiring coordinated action from breweries, regulators, and other stakeholders. Ultimately, addressing water wastage is not only an environmental imperative but also a strategic opportunity for breweries to enhance ethical competition, minimize risks, and safeguard the planet's precious resources.
Bibliography
Chief financial Officer at Project I Am Enough
9moSuch an interesting and well-put article. Do you think the Singaporean beer industry particularly is going to grow or diminish over the next two decades?